Toggle sidebar

Speculation: Quinn Hughes wants to contend

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
RandV said:
Why have a thread on something highly unpredictable 2 years in advance?
Click to expand...
Because it’s already been made known that the Canucks are listening to offers on Miller, EP, Boeser, and Demko. If those guys are moved it stands to reason that Quinn, who is a UFA in 2 years, will want to move on during a rebuild/retool.

Obviously it would be a disaster to let him walk to FA, hence the speculation about his trade value.
 
Quinning said:
Unlike the others, there's no way he returns anything less than a King's Ransom, because he's 25 and about to win his second consecutive Norris. Every team in the league will ask about him.

Start the bidding at:

U25 top 4 defenceman
Blue chip prospect
Blue chip prospect
1st round pick
1st round pick
Click to expand...
Dude shut the f*** up. McDavid might not even bring back that price with two years left on his contract, let alone a guy who isn't even a Top 10 player in the league.
 
  • Haha
  • Wow
Reactions: Eegs and Kreator
New Jersey is the obvious one, right?
- Nemec or Casey
- Mercer
- 2026 1st Round Pick
- 2x 2025 2nd Round Picks

Vancouver sends Teddy Blueger over as well.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: LemonSauceD
Jersey Fresh said:
I don’t know where, or even if, Quinn goes, but I’m almost positive Canucks fans are going to be disappointed in the return gauging by this thread.
Click to expand...
He’s a Hart level Norris winning dman on his second straight likely Norris win. Giving up an underperforming Nemec and 2 D prospects along with a 50pt point young player and a late first is not much for this guy.

The offers in here for Hughes are embarrassing. Yeesh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ExarKun80, Kreator, Zanon and 1 other person
nergish said:
JR effectively said "If I blow this team up, Quinn Hughes isn't going to want to stick around for that" and followed it up with "We want him here forever".

It's a bullshit thread.

My offer wasn't really a troll though - you're not getting a Hart candidate and perennial Norris-level Dman for any of the offers listed here. But ultimately he's not for sale.
Click to expand...
"If we were going to completely start over that means he goes, and we’d like to figure out a way that he’s here forever.”

Exact response. He's crossing his fingers. Nucks are definitely about to retool by sounds of it. That has to go very well to convince Hughes, otherwise off he goes to UFA
 
RedHawkDown said:
He’s a Hart level Norris winning dman on his second straight likely Norris win. Giving up an underperforming Nemec and 2 D prospects along with a 50pt point young player and a late first is not much for this guy.

The offers in here for Hughes are embarrassing. Yeesh.
Click to expand...
He's not a Hart level player. He's not a lock for the Norris.

Erik Karlsson (who was a Top 5 player in the league) returned a 1st Rounder, two 2nd Rounders, a blue chip prospect, a bottom 6 center, and a bottom pair defenseman.
Seth Jones (who was a Top 10 dman) returned a 1st Rounder, a 2nd Rounder, a 1st Round pick swap, and an underperforming blue chip prospect.
Jack Eichel (who was Buffalo's franchise player) returned a 1st Rounder, a 2nd Rounder, a Top 6 winger, and an underperforming blue chip prospect.


Vancouver fans are being delusional.
 
Last edited:
  • Wow
  • Haha
Reactions: Chaos Giraffe and Zanon
kerrabria said:
He's not a Hart level player. He's not a lock for the Norris.

Erik Karlsson (who was a Top 5 player in the league) returned a 1st Rounder, two 2nd Rounders, a blue chip prospect, a bottom 6 center, and a bottom pair defenseman.
Seth Jones (who was a Top 10 dman) returned a 1st Rounder, a 2nd Rounder, a 1st Round pick swap, and an underperforming blue chip prospect.
Jack Eichel (who was Buffalo's franchise player) returned a 1st Rounder, a 2nd Rounder, a Top 6 winger, and an underperforming blue chip prospect.


Vancouver fans are being delusional.
Click to expand...
If the season ended today. He takes the Norris no problem. Even gets a few Hart votes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RedHawkDown
eviohh26 said:
If the season ended today. He takes the Norris no problem. Even gets a few Hart votes.
Click to expand...
Just because Vancouver fans say this doesn't make it true. It's a two and a half horse race, and Makar/Hughes are neck and neck.
 
DudeWhereIsMakar said:
So I heard a rumour that if Pettersson, Miller, Boeser, Demko and the rest of the Canucks core are traded then Quinn will want a trade from the Canucks.

I mean if they do trade Hughes they're going to be the worst team in the league and unless they trade him Garland is likely going to take over as 16th captain in their franchise's history, that or Tyler Myers anyway. But I think a star leaving their team is usually a bad sign unless they understand that in order to win they need to want to because quitting is almost like losing.

But if Quinn gets traded I only see him going to New Jersey. It's what the NHL wants really.
Click to expand...
Want to contend? Nah, he probably wants to lose every game. /S
 
kerrabria said:
He's not a Hart level player. He's not a lock for the Norris.

Erik Karlsson (who was a Top 5 player in the league) returned a 1st Rounder, two 2nd Rounders, a blue chip prospect, a bottom 6 center, and a bottom pair defenseman.
Seth Jones (who was a Top 10 dman) returned a 1st Rounder, a 2nd Rounder, a 1st Round pick swap, and an underperforming blue chip prospect.
Jack Eichel (who was Buffalo's franchise player) returned a 1st Rounder, a 2nd Rounder, a Top 6 winger, and an underperforming blue chip prospect.


Vancouver fans are being delusional.
Click to expand...

Please don't ever name drop Seth Jones and Jack Eichel in a Quinn Hughes thread again.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: HabzSauce, Burt Macklin and Kreator
Chaos Giraffe said:
Please don't ever name drop Seth Jones and Jack Eichel in a Quinn Hughes thread again.
Click to expand...
Quinn Hughes Norris Trophy finishes...1st, 9th, 13th, 15th
Seth Jones Norris Trophy finishes...4th, 9th, 14th, 18th

Quinn Hughes Hart Trophy finishes...7th
Jack Eichel Hart Trophy finishes...8th

His career is significantly closer to these guys' than to Erik Karlsson's. You may seethe now.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: norrisnick and Bgav
kerrabria said:
He's not a Hart level player. He's not a lock for the Norris.

Erik Karlsson (who was a Top 5 player in the league) returned a 1st Rounder, two 2nd Rounders, a blue chip prospect, a bottom 6 center, and a bottom pair defenseman.
Seth Jones (who was a Top 10 dman) returned a 1st Rounder, a 2nd Rounder, a 1st Round pick swap, and an underperforming blue chip prospect.
Jack Eichel (who was Buffalo's franchise player) returned a 1st Rounder, a 2nd Rounder, a Top 6 winger, and an underperforming blue chip prospect.


Vancouver fans are being delusional.
Click to expand...
I am the furthest thing from a Vancouver fan.

He is absolutely a Hart level player. Erik Karlsson was exiting his prime and had just come off a major surgery. Jones was not even close to the same level of player. Eichel had a neck surgery concern and again not even close to the same level of player.

Some of you don’t watch hockey outside your own teams and it shows. He is at the same level as Makar, if not better.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Burt Macklin and Bgav
eviohh26 said:
Winning what? You guys missed the playoffs last year.
Click to expand...
And the Rangers were President's trophy winners last year, how's that going for them this year?

Winning environment, just like I said.
2nd in PP
3rd in PK
Goals against is down about 1.5 from last yr.
Markstrom is top third G in the league
 
kerrabria said:
He's not a Hart level player. He's not a lock for the Norris.

Erik Karlsson (who was a Top 5 player in the league) returned a 1st Rounder, two 2nd Rounders, a blue chip prospect, a bottom 6 center, and a bottom pair defenseman.
Seth Jones (who was a Top 10 dman) returned a 1st Rounder, a 2nd Rounder, a 1st Round pick swap, and an underperforming blue chip prospect.
Jack Eichel (who was Buffalo's franchise player) returned a 1st Rounder, a 2nd Rounder, a Top 6 winger, and an underperforming blue chip prospect.


Vancouver fans are being delusional.
Click to expand...
Karlsson was 3 years older than Hughes is currently, two seasons removed from his last Norris (though one year removed from being a runner-up), and was not the player he had been previously after struggling through injuries; calling him a top 5 player at that point is quite a stretch.

Calling Seth Jones a top-10 dman is hilarious. He received zero Norris votes the year before the trade and was 14th the year before that. A one-off fourth-place finish 4 years before the trade does not make him top-10.

Eichel had massive injury concerns that everyone knows affected his value.

There's not a single factor that would detract from Hughes' value. He is massively underpaid for a full two seasons after this one, has no trade protection, no significant injury history, is the reigning Norris winner and is looking like a sure shot to at least be a finalist again this year (barring major injury).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bgav
kerrabria said:
Quinn Hughes Norris Trophy finishes...1st, 9th, 13th, 15th
Seth Jones Norris Trophy finishes...4th, 9th, 14th, 18th

His career is significantly closer to these guys' than to Erik Karlsson's. You may seethe now.
Click to expand...

Seth Jones isn't even close to being the best D of his draft class.
 
Hammman said:
Karlsson was 3 years older than Hughes is currently, two seasons removed from his last Norris (though one year removed from being a runner-up), and was not the player he had been previously after struggling through injuries; calling him a top 5 player at that point is quite a stretch.

Calling Seth Jones a top-10 dman is hilarious. He received zero Norris votes the year before the trade and was 14th the year before that. A one-off fourth-place finish 4 years before the trade does not make him top-10.

Eichel had massive injury concerns that everyone knows affected his value.

There's not a single factor that would detract from Hughes' value. He is massively underpaid for a full two seasons after this one, has no trade protection, no significant injury history, is the reigning Norris winner and is looking like a sure shot to at least be a finalist again this year (barring major injury).
Click to expand...
Karlsson won the Norris, then was the runner-up twice in the three seasons before he was traded. I remember the coverage of Crosby vs Karlsson as the two best players in the NHL during that 2017 ECF.

Seth Jones finished 14th in votes that year because he missed 14 games and played on a pair with Werenski, who finished 8th in votes. Yes, he had an unimpressive final year with Columbus, and he seemed on the downswing, but (at worst) he was one year removed from being a Top 10 dman.

Not gonna bother arguing about the unknown extent to which Eichel's trade value was affected.

The factor that affects Hughes' trade value is the ceiling on any given player's trade value. Let alone one with two years left until UFA.
Chaos Giraffe said:
Seth Jones isn't even close to being the best D of his draft class.
Click to expand...
Does that matter? The 2018 draft didn't produce a single defenseman who can defend at a top pair NHL level.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chaos Giraffe
LOL

So Quinn Hughes had an experimental surgery where they removed half his ankle and 40% of his heel

Ohhh wait that was Karlsson


Trash comparison
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom