For you PW will give it a try, there is really no right or wrong answer. As you know I follow progress not make predictions.
We understand there is no Denis Potvin, here.
The three leading candidates,CDH, Poulock and Reinhart. Any of the three could be number one, a case can be made for each. The way this looks down the line, the effectiveness of the gruop is more of a story than just one player yet who knows who emerges if you want to rank who is number one.
Since you asked, will go with Griff. We know he won' t produce the most offense but I think he may be anchor. Key on the penalty kill, some powerplay time, probably on the second unit. When protecting leads late in the game, you want him on the ice much as possible. Of the defenseman over the season, Griff may be the one who will gets the most ice time. He may not be the conventional number one, but he can have an impact in a game even if he does not get any points.
Calvin has been outstanding and he is just getting started, more good things to come. Pulock needs a little work defebsively and on his mobilty, he skates well straight ahead. Nothing fatal, he is the kind who could come on quickly.
You like Calvin, I picked Griff, someone may like Pulock. Each one have important qualities, so will not argue if anyone wants to post their favorite.
Surprised I missed this.
Pretty bang on analysis DRex, as expected.
I'm very high on all 3 players as well and pretty much feel the same as you do. I just prefer CdH because we've seen similar d-men like him around the league and most of them are quite impressive. He also has the best set of offensive tools of all the d-men IMO. I see him leading the charge when it's all said and done because he can pretty much shelter anyone on the team... including Hamonic when they are together. His ability to escape trouble with basically no heart beat is impressive and his 1st pass (and passing ability in general) is sublime.
I agree Reinhart will likely never get the pub and you have to watch for the subtleties to his game to truly appreciate how good he really is. I think over the years, there will be many who will always want more out of him offensively and that's really not his game. He's as unflashy as you can pretty much get in a good way. If he continues to impose his will physically on others like he's been doing lately... I may change my mind.
Pulock is the wild card. Just for his shot alone, it could be one of the deadliest weapons in the NHL because the kid can launch it. He launches it, but he seems to be able to control it too which is pretty damn scary. When he's on, goalies aren't going to be able to do much when he unleashes a 100 mph slapper and it picks the corner. When he's off, he's going to do some serious damage to a lot of shins of opposing players. I also like that he's a leader and has high hockey intelligence, he could conceivably be the best out of the group.
As you alluded to, you really can't go wrong with any one of them. They are all very different players with different skillsets. I personally LOVE that all of them score very high in hockey IQ, the smart players tend to figure out things and have the ability to adapt. Adding Hamonic to the mix, it's a very solid and well rounded group where all will be able to play in all situations. We may not have a Doughty (or could we?), but having a top-4 with guys that all could be solid #2 types... I love the thought of having such a deep group.
I think CdH and Pulock will likely be our #1PP unit and Reinhart-Hamonic will be our #1PK in time. I can't speak for Pulock's PK abilities, but CdH has shown that he's no slouch there too. I don't think he'll be a crease clearer, but he won't need to with Hamonic and Reinhart bringing the physicality. Not to mention people like Mayfield and possibly Pedan who both bring size and nastiness.
I know we like to day dream about the defense group, but it's not like any of them are pimple faced kids right out of the Draft. I'm also quite happy that all 4 of them were Captains for the respective Jr. teams, character and leadership anyone? It's funny how things turn out, but it's looking very much like our defense could be the backbone of this team for many years to come. Johnny should be smiling about that.