wetcoast
Registered User
- Nov 20, 2018
- 24,474
- 11,446
Stopped by to see if the usual woes of North Americans with evaluating Russians are going away. Nope, they are here to stay. A bunch of awful takes. The real problem though is they will be again refected in the actual draft.
Let's make a list of usual NA failures when evaluating Russians:
1.Lack of actual scouting/information/insight on players playing in Russia. Most of it seems to follow some takes and hypes published by NA based experts who don't really know much about hockey in Russia and so they copypaste eachother's wild guesses. Prime examples last draft: Svechkov over Chibrikov and hype around Poltapov. This time around I see the exact same with Miroshnichenko over Yurov. And a hype around Trikozov. He seems to be this year's Poltapov.
2.Partially because of 1. overrating Russians playing in NA leagues. Example: Gazizov over Perevalov. Really?
3.The usual NA bias. I get the Savoie hype and it's a pity I won't get to see him at the WJC. I somewhat get the C preference, still I don't see particularily Wright(on Savoie I would need more input) ahead of guys like Yurov or Kemell. They are Canadians. That's all what makes them "better"? Also that much "better" that the aforementioned non-Canadian prospects end up outside the Top10 on many lists behind NA players who I hardly see on their level.
Well at least Canadian prospects stay at home to develop right?
Your general biased post (and perspective often cited on these boards) here brings nothing to the table as most posters here or even professional scouts can't be very accurate across either ocean and without reference points which is the biggest factor with some Russian prospects who play in weird situations like the KHL with little of no ice time then shuffle up and down lineups that change hourly in across 3 different leagues.
Yurov and Kemell are fine prospects and are in the mix for top 5 but they also really haven't done enough to separate themselves from Savioe who aside from having an incredible draft season, has the skillset to be an excellent pro at a premium position.