ChaosAgent
Registered User
- May 8, 2018
- 18,561
- 12,606
OT: Pirates Talk: That Skenes guy is okay at teh baseball
- Thread starter Zirakzigil
- Start date
It's hockey and football season. The Pirates did their job of getting us to August when the competitive sports begin.
bigdaddyk88
Registered User
- Apr 21, 2019
- 4,555
- 893
No need to worry about baseball until the winter meetings
Empoleon8771
Registered User
Not that anyone watched this game over the Steelers game, but if this is Skenes' last start, he went out with a bang. 9 strikeouts and only 2 hits against in 5 innings, I'm guessing he was pulled so he can get another start.
Also Yorke had his first HR, I think he could be a really good hitter for them next year.
Also Yorke had his first HR, I think he could be a really good hitter for them next year.
BusinessGoose
Registered User
WickedWrister
Registered User
bigdaddyk88
Registered User
- Apr 21, 2019
- 4,555
- 893
GilbertSeinfeld
Registered User
- Mar 4, 2024
- 1,503
- 1,931
Made a nice snag on a hard hit line drive, and nothing glaring that made him look overmatched.
I did watch because I am not a football guy.
bigdaddyk88
Registered User
- Apr 21, 2019
- 4,555
- 893
If York is going to be mainly a 2nd baseman then Nick needs to take over ss. Glad to hear he played well
Empoleon8771
Registered User
I didn't watch the game so I can't comment, but I think the big worry I have with Gonzales at SS is that his arm is really weak. He does have good range though (at least at 2B), so I think he could be passable at SS. That being said, it's really not a good idea to plan on that being option A going into next year.
I think they're better off pushing Yorke to LF and keeping Gonzales at 2B, or perhaps go the opposite way. I don't think either Yorke or Gonzales have the arm to be effective SS or 3B in the long run.
I think they're better off pushing Yorke to LF and keeping Gonzales at 2B, or perhaps go the opposite way. I don't think either Yorke or Gonzales have the arm to be effective SS or 3B in the long run.
bigdaddyk88
Registered User
- Apr 21, 2019
- 4,555
- 893
Ikf arm isn’t great for ss or range. The only way they put Nick or Yorke in Left is if Reynolds moves to 1st unless they want to rotate DH because they know Cutch isn’t going to play 120 games will be interesting going into the winter meetings
GilbertSeinfeld
Registered User
- Mar 4, 2024
- 1,503
- 1,931
Nothing matter unless there is, at least, new management.
I'd like to see Cherington gone, too, but, at the very least, Shelton and his band of flunkies need removed.
I'd like to see Cherington gone, too, but, at the very least, Shelton and his band of flunkies need removed.
Empoleon8771
Registered User
Reynolds to 1B is absolutely something they should be doing.
McCutchen at DH, Reynolds at 1B, Yorke (or whoever wins the role, but I think Yorke's bat will let him win it) in LF and bring in a legitimate bat to play RF.
Too bad deGrom is rarely healthy.
BusinessGoose
Registered User
ImporterExporter
"You're a boring old man"
There's a very real argument that he's been the best pitcher in baseball since he broke into the league. The ROTY voting shouldn't be close.
maybe just give him the cy young and let the other guy have the roty
BusinessGoose
Registered User
GilbertSeinfeld
Registered User
- Mar 4, 2024
- 1,503
- 1,931
The Reds fired their manager basically as soon as they lost yesterday.
He had signed a three year extension this off season, so there you go, Pirates, it IS possible.
He had signed a three year extension this off season, so there you go, Pirates, it IS possible.
Sidney the Kidney
One last time
- Jun 29, 2009
- 56,715
- 49,045
Got a question for you baseball nerds. Does anyone still use HR, RBI, batting average, etc. to determine how good (or bad) players are nowadays?
Reason I ask is when I did follow baseball, all the talk was so and so is better because look at his RBIs or so and so is better because he hit .320 to the other guy's .265. It's what I grew up understanding and liking about baseball as a stats nerd. Looking at someone's baseball card and seeing his year-to-year HR totals and RBI totals and Runs totals. But now it seems the focus almost entirely is on these new numbers (WAR, OPS+, etc.).
Does anyone use those "old school" stats anymore?
Reason I ask is when I did follow baseball, all the talk was so and so is better because look at his RBIs or so and so is better because he hit .320 to the other guy's .265. It's what I grew up understanding and liking about baseball as a stats nerd. Looking at someone's baseball card and seeing his year-to-year HR totals and RBI totals and Runs totals. But now it seems the focus almost entirely is on these new numbers (WAR, OPS+, etc.).
Does anyone use those "old school" stats anymore?
Empoleon8771
Registered User
Depends on how much of a nerd you are. I think the standard level of analysis uses OPS+, which is just on-base (batting average plus walks) plus slugging (how many bases you're getting when you get hits) as a function of league average (100 is league average). WRC+ is similar, but it includes a park adjusted factor.
I think some baseball analytics go a bit overboard with it though, because guys fill useful niches even if their OPS+ or WAR isn't necessarily special. For example, a guy who has an OBP of .350 with speed but zero power is a great leadoff hitter (such as Steven Kwan). A guy who is awful defensively but can hit 35 HRs a year and get a ton of RBIs is still a useful cleanup hitter (such as Nick Castellanos). WAR usually represents it pretty well but it can overrate or underrate niche players with specific roles that WAR either likes or doesn't like.
On the Pirates, I think Hayes is a terrific example of that, especially in his 2022 season. In that year, he only had a slash line of .244/.314/.345, which is a clearly below average hitter (88 OPS+). However, WAR absolutely loved his defense, to the point where he finished with 4.4 WAR in 136 games. That's insanely overrating him, he is simply not as good as his WAR suggests in that year. I think Triolo is another guy on the Pirates who WAR overrates due to his defense.
Empoleon8771
Registered User
Absolute joke franchise, but Tellez didn't really make his case any easier. Dude has a .116 batting average in September, really seems like he just checked out.
Call it an overreaction if you want, but this kind of stuff makes me believe more and more the "Nutting is going to move the team once the lease at PNC Park ends" thoughts that some people have.
Call it an overreaction if you want, but this kind of stuff makes me believe more and more the "Nutting is going to move the team once the lease at PNC Park ends" thoughts that some people have.
Last edited:
