Beef Invictus
Revolutionary Positivity
I've been kicking around this idea for a few years of going to 18 games with one or even two bye weeks, assuming that the owners are going to force it no matter what.
The salary cap would go up, of course, and probably roster size, including how many you can dress on game day, but my idea is a Games Played cap -- there is no minimum number of games a player can play in, but nobody gets into more than 16 during the regular season.
It allows older and dinged up or injured players to sit a game without losing face, keeps the stats and records within reach of the old ones (obviously the rule changes and spread principles have obliterated many already), and it massively, massively increases strategy.
A team with a dominant QB has to expose the backup for two games -- do they try to sneak him in early against bottom-feeders, or risk holding him out until the end of the season hoping they'd've clinched by that point? Do you tie your starting LT to your starting QB? If the weaker teams see more of the backups, doesn't that make for closer games? And more intense disrepect hype?
It would complicate and deepen fantasy leagues and gambling in general. Most importantly, it would allow plentiful opportunity for coaches and general manages to screw up, in myriad unpredictable ways.
Failing that, I'd rather they not change the current playoff format or schedule. It feels like a sweet spot.
The games played cap will be a byzantine nightmare to track, especially for the league following every team. I was open to it as an interesting wrinkle at first but over time I like it less and less, hence why I favor two bye weeks, even with just one extra game.
As I see it, the elite players and best teams aren't going to be hit hard by an extra game. Those are the players and teams who can most easily handle an extra game; those are the guys who set the pace instead of trying to follow it. It's the below-average teams and players who will have a hard time. The teams/players that don't have as much talent and are filled with players who are prone to break themselves down while trying to keep up with better talent. Asking them to play an extra game is potentially asking a lot of guys to shorten or end careers. As a Redskins follower I've watched that process annually. By week 8 guys begin breaking. By week 12 their replacements start breaking. When the subpar/average players who are supposed to protect a QB or get open for him to make a play can't because they're all worn down, then that QB is at risk. It snowballs. When guys who aren't as good do too much to keep up with better players, they either get beaten a lot or they shred themselves at a high rate.
So an extra bye week would help with that situation. Ideally, they just stay at 16 games