Prospect Info: Phantoms (AHL), Reading Royals (ECHL), NCAA, Jrs., Int'l, etc. [The Fall 2022 Edition]

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's like any drafter, you have to look at a large sample, Eagles fans wanted to kill Howie over Reagor, then looked up and saw a team composed of his draft picks, trades and signees.

If Tuomaala turns out to be a bad pick, and Kaplan a steal, all is forgiven.
If they all turned out to be bad, hang 'em high!
 
Tuomaala didn’t even have a particularly good junior season. Compare his stats on the same team to Koivunen. Tournament evaluating, especially to raise value, is very often fool’s gold. Sometimes it’s the only sample I have, but I’ll almost always err on the side of “consider it, don’t trust it” across contradictory evidence. Both ways. And if you’re just looking at small sample points, forgettaboutit.

I don’t even think Tuomaala was especially good even in those games; I still couldn’t get a real read. He just skated fast and shot some. Flahrsy drew hearts in his notebook and dreamed of feeding him with a funnel.

Don't write the kid off yet. Had a crazy year being bounced around and a significant injury. Might take him a while to get his head on straight

First off, the team started off his “crazy year” by wasting a month in the AHL for 2 games. Secondly, what significant injury? He was just scratched a ton across both leagues. When the very next pick is the reigning CHL Player of the Year, who plays the same position, who we had ranked 30 spots higher, after this team has barely drafting recently, you’re getting criticism.
 
Tuomaala didn’t even have a particularly good junior season. Compare his stats on the same team to Koivunen. Tournament evaluating, especially to raise value, is very often fool’s gold. Sometimes it’s the only sample I have, but I’ll almost always err on the side of “consider it, don’t trust it” across contradictory evidence. Both ways. And if you’re just looking at small sample points, forgettaboutit.

I don’t even think Tuomaala was especially good even in those games; I still couldn’t get a real read. He just skated fast and shot some. Flahrsy drew hearts in his notebook and dreamed of feeding him with a funnel.



First off, the team started off his “crazy year” by wasting a month in the AHL for 2 games. Secondly, what significant injury? He was just scratched a ton across both leagues. When the very next pick is the reigning CHL Player of the Year, who plays the same position, who we had ranked 30 spots higher, after this team has barely drafting recently, you’re getting criticism.
Stankoven is actually a center that projects as a winger because of his size. The antithesis of the guy they just took 5th overall really. :laugh:
 
Stankoven is actually a center that projects as a winger because of his size. The antithesis of the guy they just took 5th overall really. :laugh:
Stankoven is unlikely to be a NHL regular. There are Smurfs and then there are Stankovens.

However it reinforces what is said earlier. Toumoula wont do what the Flyers want him to do development wise. Then they drafted the kid this year that has a sex conviction. Whoever the Finnish scout is needs to be fired. His job includes basic background checks as well.
 
He's now below O'Brien on the prospect depth chart.
Tuomaala has the speed and shot to be a scorer at at least the ahl level the question is can he mature both on and off the ice.
O'Brien reminds me a lot of Mike Richards the question with him is can he stay healthy long enough to show that kind of determination to succeed.
 
Tuomaala didn’t even have a particularly good junior season. Compare his stats on the same team to Koivunen. Tournament evaluating, especially to raise value, is very often fool’s gold. Sometimes it’s the only sample I have, but I’ll almost always err on the side of “consider it, don’t trust it” across contradictory evidence. Both ways. And if you’re just looking at small sample points, forgettaboutit.

I don’t even think Tuomaala was especially good even in those games; I still couldn’t get a real read. He just skated fast and shot some. Flahrsy drew hearts in his notebook and dreamed of feeding him with a funnel.



First off, the team started off his “crazy year” by wasting a month in the AHL for 2 games. Secondly, what significant injury? He was just scratched a ton across both leagues. When the very next pick is the reigning CHL Player of the Year, who plays the same position, who we had ranked 30 spots higher, after this team has barely drafting recently, you’re getting criticism.

You mean hyperfocus on small sample sizes is basically always bad?

I'd say I'm shocked but I annually learn this lesson watching the Flyers get their opening roster obviously wrong based on preseason.
 
Sorry for maybe some out dated questions. I was swamped the last month so didn't see much from training camp other than a few minutes from some of the preseason games. Did Foerster show anything that might indicate him being a call up this year? Does Wisdom have a future in the NHL? Was Cutter not at camp at all? I thought top picks, especially top 10 ones got a camp invite even when they know they aren't to make the team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ironmanrulez
Sorry for maybe some out dated questions. I was swamped the last month so didn't see much from training camp other than a few minutes from some of the preseason games. Did Foerster show anything that might indicate him being a call up this year? Does Wisdom have a future in the NHL? Was Cutter not at camp at all? I thought top picks, especially top 10 ones got a camp invite even when they know they aren't to make the team.
College kids can't attend.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ironmanrulez
Good guy Cutter.

20221014_160540.jpg
 
Phantoms lineup for regular season opener vs WBS Penguins.

Line 1 LW Willman C O’Reilly RW Foerster
Line 2 LW Marody C Brooks RW Hodgson
Line 3 LW Wilson* C Desnoyers RW MacEwen
Line 4 LW Ratcliffe C Bellerive* RW Wisdom

1st Pair LD York RD Belpedio
2nd Pair LD Hogberg RD Attard
3rd Pair LD Ginning RD Wylie

Goalies:
Starter: Grosenick
Backup: Nagle*

Scratched:
C Gerard*
LW Fitzgerald* + Injured
LD Connauton
LD Zech
RD Karashik*

Desnoyers scored his 1st goal as a professional.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad