Proposal: Petry for PO Jospeh + 2nd

[Hins77]

I just don’t see the reason Montreal would keep him especially if he is hinting he wants out.

Expecting a top prospect for him seems like a lot given that contract.

He still signed a contract one year ago. We will flush this year and begin a new one next year. I mean, matt Duchene been on the block during a long time. I don’t see the reason to sell low Jeff Petry.

 

[HabsWhiteKnightLOL]

Petry sucks now, no team should be trading much of value for him and his massive contract

I will never understand this. He had 4 seasons of 40+ was on pace for Norris last year. Played like a warrior in playoff.

Then Price Edmundson Weber Danault Perry Tatar Kotkaniemi are all gone

We signs reject like Savard Hoffman and we are running without Price and Allen while having 1 damn in the top 4 ,hit by injuries and COVID hard and suddenly Petry is worth nothing.


Doesn't take huge to tell that Petry wants out due to the team going into a rebuild and the problem with his wife and 3 kids not liking Quebec rules are then living in Detroit at this moment.


Saying he has no value is simply dumb. Except Mason he's like the best dman available at the deadline . Top 4 dmans who are offensive doesn't pop 15 times a day

 

[Scintillating10]

Would Dallas trade Klingberg even up for Petry?

 

[1909]

Three-way deal:

Dallas trades Kilingbeg to Pittsburg
Montreal trades Petry to Dallas
Pittsburg trades Poulin + 2nd round pick to Montreal.

 

[vokiel]

In the current context, if Pittsburgh offers the deal, there is no way Montreal refuses.

Not sure why Pens would do this, unless they owe Geoffrey Molson a favor.

 

[elitepete]

Montreal would likely have to retain 50% or take back Zucker.

 

[Nakawick]

You are asking for an early 30’s Petry price but you are offering a late 30’s Petry product.

 

[glenbuis]

Would Dallas trade Klingberg even up for Petry?

not even up . montreal would have to add some . i would do it and then flip klingberg for a specific prospect .

 

[66-30-33]

Petry wont get that return from a team. Also he would have to be 50% retained anyway.

 

[SomeDude]

Kingerski is a "popular Pittsburgh reporter"?

He finished in the top 10 of popular Pittsburgh reporters from the polling at the Kingerski family reunion.

 

[Scintillating10]

not even up . montreal would have to add some . i would do it and then flip klingberg for a specific prospect .

What kind of an add? Salary retention?

 

[Tender Rip]

Petry could be a difference maker on the Pens at the end of our window. But that cap-hit is tough to pay fair value for and the contract has too many years on it to expect Montreal to retain much.

Would take some creativity to make that work, and I'd say part of it would be us dealing John Marino somewhere else. Maybe to Arizona for an asset + them retaining some of Petry's salary for us? Arizona could use a capable young RH d-man with years on his deal, I'd think.

Like: 2nd and Poulin to Montreal. Petry to Pens with Montreal retaining 1 million.

John Marino to Arizona, UFA Lyubushkin to Pens and Arizona retaining 2 million on Petry for us. Is an extra asset needed for Arizona for that amount of money... maybe.

Dumo Letang
Petterson Petry
Matheson Lyubushkin

I'd go to war with that.

 

[Isles72]

Three-way deal:

Dallas trades Kilingbeg to Pittsburg
Montreal trades Petry to Dallas
Pittsburg trades Poulin + 2nd round pick to Montreal.

thats not a bad offer although I havent kept tabs on Poulins progress

 

[McSuper]

we will see. But I won’t selling low any guy of this team because he is not playing at his 100% capacity. I rather keep him

Thats all fine and good but the problem is when the shoe in on the other foot Montreal fans get all high and mighty and tell fans of other teams it will cost a 1st to move them . I seen Montreal fans claim it will cost a first + to move Koskinen when his contract is done in a few months and out of the other side of their mouths want a good pick/prospect for Allen whom has pretty much the same stat line as Koskinen with an extra year on it .

 

[amnesiac]

You are asking for an early 30’s Petry price but you are offering a late 30’s Petry product.

until Jospeh proves it, hes not an "early 30s Petry"

Point is the Pens' window is getting smaller by the day if they want to make another run while Sid, Geno, and Letang are still good. Petry is in his prime, POJ is far from it.

 

[Archijerej]

Pettersson, Legare and a 2nd/3rd for Petry actually seems pretty reasonable to me.

Why? Because Legare has a French name?

 

[Le Magnifique 66]

Three-way deal:

Dallas trades Kilingbeg to Pittsburg
Montreal trades Petry to Dallas
Pittsburg trades Poulin + 2nd round pick to Montreal.

How does that help the Pens in the long run? We get stuck with another UFA in Klingberg to add on to Letang, Malkin and Rust? No thanks!

 

[Le Magnifique 66]

until Jospeh proves it, hes not an "early 30s Petry"

Point is the Pens' window is getting smaller by the day if they want to make another run while Sid, Geno, and Letang are still good. Petry is in his prime, POJ is far from it.

We need PO Joseph a lot more than Petry, Petry is not going to put the Pens over the top thus the offer makes no sense for the Pens going forward. If a prospect is moved, it's more a forward I think that would be traded, like Legare or Poulin not POJ

 

[Nakawick]

until Jospeh proves it, hes not an "early 30s Petry"

Point is the Pens' window is getting smaller by the day if they want to make another run while Sid, Geno, and Letang are still good. Petry is in his prime, POJ is far from it.

The worst thing for the Pens is to trade future assets for an ageing overpaid player. If Petry was a UFA at the end of this season I might offer a 2nd at 50%, but no to the additional years. No offer at all.

 

[Nakawick]

Why? Because Legare has a French name?

There is clearly a bias in Montreal for such players.

 

[Archijerej]

There is clearly a bias in Montreal for such players.

Since 2003, when I started following the Habs, I can't think of one example when they willfully sacrificed quality in order to acquire a French Canadian.

 

[Mandalorian]

Since 2003, when I started following the Habs, I can't think of one example when they willfully sacrificed quality in order to acquire a French Canadian.

Mikhail Sergachev for Jonathan Drouin.

 

[amnesiac]

Since 2003, when I started following the Habs, I can't think of one example when they willfully sacrificed quality in order to acquire a French Canadian.

Louis Leblanc over Chris Kreider was the most obvious.... Gainey wanting to please the Montreal crowd (draft location), and hoping to save his job.

 

[amnesiac]

Mikhail Sergachev for Jonathan Drouin.

I didnt really see it that way.... Habs were starving for a high profile offensive player, Drouin was coming off a great playoff with TB and was still considered a top young forward after being drafted 3rd overall. He just happened to be on the trade block since TB couldnt afford him, and Bergevin went for it. It wasnt even so much criticized at the time.

What a horrible trade in hindsight, no doubt.

 

[Archijerej]

Mikhail Sergachev for Jonathan Drouin.

Doesn't apply. Drouin was acquired as a potential 1st line forward. Being from Quebec was a factor, but not a decisive one.