All of these people who are suggesting that we not pay Malkin for what he has done, only for what he will do, would be saying to "just pay the man" if it were Crosby in Malkin's shoes and Geno in Sid's. Just saying.
There has been a negative bias around Malkin since day 1. Media being what it is has everything to do with this. Good ol' Canadian lad can never do anything wrong, but that dastardly Russian dude? Well, he is hit or miss. That has been the narrative throughout.
The reality is, this era is the Sid and Geno show. Not just one, not just the other. There is no Stanley Cup champion Sidney Crosby without Stanley Cup champion Evgeni Malkin. Sure, Mark Messier won a Stanley Cup without Wayne Gretzky (two in fact). This team has always been built for Sid, but could never win without Geno too.
I am sick and tired of the Malkin dissing that goes on throughout the league. He is one of the very best centers to ever play the game. He is a top-25 player all time in my estimation. Is he a different sort of cat? You betcha. And that is why the masses do not see him as this all-time legend. They see him as a great player who has hung around and ridden the coattails of their own media darling.
Look, I love Sidney Crosby. From day 1. I watched him play in the QMJHL when he was 16. I knew he was going to be special, and he is special. But he has never been anymore special than Malkin. Both are equals in Penguins lore in my view. They are Joe Sakic and Peter Forsberg. Only better.
If they choose not to bring him back, they will lose a Penguins fan (since 1990).
Oh, and since we are talking about legends, I am still waiting for the Jaromir Jagr jersey retirement ceremony as well.