SeanMoneyHands
Registered User
- Apr 18, 2019
- 15,337
- 14,737
I guess Crosby doesn't want to win.
Rumor: Pens, Crosby closing in on extension
- Thread starter Forge
- Start date
- Status
- Jun 13, 2010
- 42,897
- 21,776
There's no player in the league that's won more than Sid. Three cups, two Conn Smythes, an Olympic gold (with the Golden Goal), a World Championship, a World Cup, a World Cup MVP, along with several individual awards...
Sid has won it all. Da f*** you talking about boi?
ETA: Oh, and he has an Emmy. Sid has an Emmy.
Last edited by a moderator:
DesertPenguin
Registered User
- Apr 22, 2015
- 3,326
- 1,822
Here's betting they announce the contract on 8/7.
Crosby is 36 years old and has won 3 Stanley Cups and has played his entire career with the Penguins. I am sure he is settled and happy with his life where it is at this point and probably quite happy to finish his career with the Penguins. I am sure the Penguins are happy to keep him for the rest of his career also.
BHD
Here comes Skinner
$30 million for his age 38-40 years and he's not prioritizing money? If he wasn't, he'd be playing at a reduced rate so they can get some talent to play beside them. Not knocking the guy, he's entitled to get what he can, but he sure as shit is prioritizing money. That's probably more than he'd get on the open market at that stage of his career.
Sidgeni Malkby
Registered User
He has consistently de-prioritized money. He has been at $8.7M forever now. Even Malkin signed for higher than him the last pre-retiring contract ($9.5M/yr).
I wouldn't be surprised is he signs for $8.7M again.
ManofSteel55
Registered User
Sid took a contract that I think everyone knew was team friendly on his last deal. I don't understand the "Oh, Sid is just cashing out" comments. Especially considering that even if he took less, Penguins current management team doesn't appear to know how to build a winner around him.
Zirakzigil
Global Moderator
Zirakzigil
Global Moderator
I actually wouldnt be shocked if its 3 years at 19.87mil total signed on August 7th. Because its Sid.
Dipsy Doodle
Rent A Barn
- May 28, 2006
- 77,018
- 21,751
Stamkos just got 8 mil × 4 years but Crosby couldn't get 10 mil × 3.
Right.
Crosby can name his price, not only because of his on ice performance but from the name recognition/prestige he would bring to any organization.
Romang67
BitterSwede
It's probably not the same group, but it's interesting to see the people bemoaning the Penguins' re-signing their long term captain and one of the most important players in their history, while the people in the Vegas thread are calling them mercenary merchants for getting rid of their aging or poorly performing players.
ManofSteel55
Registered User
Crosby's agent will have a formula that shows exactly how much Crosby alone brings in to the Penguins in merchandising as well. In terms of value to financial return the player generates for the team, Sid is still at or near the top.
KingsFan7824
Registered User
Where do people get the idea that aging players have value? Whether it's Crosby or Stamkos, who do people think they'll fetch in return? It's not the 20 year old star. You're not getting the 1st pick in the draft(unless you get an unprotected 1st and the team with the aging player ends up sucking). You'll get some cap dumps, and a mid to late 1st. Maybe a 2nd line prospect. I guess there's always the perfect set of circumstances type trade like with the Huberdeau/Tkachuk deal. If Tkachuk didn't want out/Huberdeau has his average season though, you're not getting Tkachuk for Huberdeau. The age difference there for a guy like Crosby would be like getting a 30+ year old, which means the Pens still aren't fully rebuilding.
In theory, a 36 year old Crosby, or a 33 year old Stamkos, would have value, because they're still productive players. With tremendoes name recognition. In the trade market though, where is any of the historical the evidence for it? When you have to take variables into account.
In theory, a 36 year old Crosby, or a 33 year old Stamkos, would have value, because they're still productive players. With tremendoes name recognition. In the trade market though, where is any of the historical the evidence for it? When you have to take variables into account.
Great news. Will help continue to cement the Pens as a bubble team on the outside looking in for the next few years.
I get this but I also wonder how much Crosby could add to his legacy if he went to say the Avs and became the 4th all time in playoff points as I really doubt he sees the playoffs ever again if he stays in Pittsburg.
I could see some people being in both groups as there is a small vocal minority here that are just complainers.It's probably not the same group, but it's interesting to see the people bemoaning the Penguins' re-signing their long term captain and one of the most important players in their history, while the people in the Vegas thread are calling them mercenary merchants for getting rid of their aging or poorly performing players.
Sign and trade, Letang is going there as well.
A transfer. 
Letang looks useless at Penguins really. 
Sure I guess if you think that he is going to fall off a cliff but he is elite in faceoffs and still finished tied for 12th in points last year and the salary cap is going up so even at 3 X10 million I doubt that he will ever be a bad contract.
I'm reminded of Colby Armstrong's quote "Sidney Crosby trains like there is a league better than the NHL that he’s preparing for".
I think that league will turn out to be "continuing to play at an elite/high-end level as a forward in your late 30s and early 40s in the NHL".
SomeDude
Registered User
The only people who think Crosby needs to add anything to his legacy are bottom of the barrel HFboards posters.
Bouboumaster
Registered User
- Jul 4, 2014
- 10,841
- 9,344
Montréal should go out there and offer him a two years/10 M contract or something
Montréal is a young team, and having a living, beathing and still skating hockey legend like Crosby around wouldn't hurt
Montréal is a young team, and having a living, beathing and still skating hockey legend like Crosby around wouldn't hurt
Empoleon8771
Registered User
lol literally why would Crosby want to leave Pittsburgh for Montreal.
The only reason he'd be leaving Pittsburgh is to go win more cups, and Montreal hasn't won shit in 30 years.
- Sep 16, 2020
- 785
- 811
This is how the end of hof players usually goes. He will have his chance to "turn" the corner once these 3 guys retire.
Sam de Mtl
Registered User
- Oct 11, 2021
- 1,378
- 2,486
I agree with this. It's just that, if you know you can't rebuild while Crosby, Malkin and Letang are still here, why not re-sign Guentzel instead of trading him for futures which will be too little too late anyway?
Give these guys and the team's fans the best shot they can get, because tomorrow is gonna hurt regardless of what they do.
Leviathan
Registered User
- Nov 25, 2008
- 1,329
- 135
He's already got 3 Cups. He probably thinks he can win another in Pittsburgh. That's in his DNA. Also, he convinced Malkin and Letang to stay in Pittsburgh so he's loyal to them. AND he probably knows that if he leaves the team could struggle to turn a profit like it did just before the Pens won the 2005 draft lottery. And that he's going to have a role with the organization once he hangs up his skates. There are LOTS of reasons for him to stay with the team. And chasing a Cup elsewhere usually don't work anyways. Ask Jarome Iginla or Corey Perry.
- Status
