Honey, this team is playing to potential.
Their potential is old and slow and unmotivated. You can't analyze potential raw skill in a vacuum divorced from every other factor. Yes, Doughty, Kopitar, Carter, Kovalchuk, etc. are skilled players. But most of those players are declining with age, or playing outright unmotivated. Potential doesn't mean a damn thing. The Canucks had potential in 2012. And how does history remember them?
I said it last season: 17/18 will go down as Kopitar's career capstone year. That was as good as he will ever be. The only player we have with their career season arguably yet to come is Doughty.
The team is not good. Full stop. They're not good on the ice, and they're not good on paper. On paper, they're far too reliant on regressing vets. They have major holes at their top six wings, 3C, and top four RHD. They're just not good. There were MANY posters saying just that over the summer. Tons of question marks on paper. Tons of holes on paper. None of that had the benefit of hindsight, as you claim.
And I would take Edmonton's roster in a heartbeat, because you at least have a young, hungry core who can be built around. Are you seriously suggesting you'd rather have a core of Kopitar and co. than McDavid and Drai?