SoupNazi
Gee Wally/SoupNazi 2024
- Feb 6, 2010
- 27,056
- 17,153
When there is nothing left to doHow often do guys retire when they're still clearly capable of playing and leading a club in the NHL?
I don't think Bergy returns. Especially for min salary.How often do guys retire when they're still clearly capable of playing and leading a club in the NHL?
I don't think Bergy returns. Especially for min salary.
I see an outside chance of him join the team/mid season.
I hear you both - but actually how many players retire when they can still play at an elite level?When there is nothing left to do
My boys told me he was gone if they won and he pretty much put the Traveling Wilburies together for one last dance
So if he was retiring if they won why would he come back
I hope he comes back from a selfish standpoint (oops, is it ok for me to say I’m selfish or do I just accuse Bergeron for being selfish playing both last game and telling Monty he’s playing game 5?)
Dream scenario for moi
He comes back and Bettuzzi ends up taking 6:36 which is making the rounds among the group chat
They role out
63-37-74
59-18-88
71-13-11
Boom
However, because they hurt me so bad emotionally and I was eating only frozen pizza and wearing only my Bruins bathrob snd B medallion/chain for 3 weeks an around the house, I won’t watch the regular season
I’m praying to the Gallery Gods Bergeron kids want him playing so when bring your dad to school they can say ‘he’s captain of the greatest regular season team ever and we love him’
Oh and @Ladyfan if he’s back we gotta take the girls back to Montreal (I owe that Habs tour bus guide one)
For what season though?I hear you both - but actially how many players retire when they can still play at an elite level?
I totally hear what you are saying - I just cant think of any player who could still play at that high a level who chose to retire. So I'm asking if anyone has some names that I'm forgetting? It's not a rhetorical question.For what season though?
Bergy is not young anymore. He could probably still excel in regular season for another 2 to 3 seasons. His experience, iq, leadership alone would be enough to get the job done.
But come playoffs...
How many close to 40 y/o players were able to lead their team to a deep playoff run?
The other thing is... lack of funds. While other older players (like Ovie) gets about 10m per season. Bergy would be playing for peanuts in comparison.
Bourque was playing 25+ minutes a night for Colorado in his last season. Lidstrom won a Norris in his final season. Those are the only two that come to mind right now.I totally hear what you are saying - I just cant think of any player who could still play at that high a level who chose to retire. So I'm asking if anyone has some names that I'm forgetting? It's not a rhetorical question.
Yah one more year would Bs great for meI hear you both - but actually how many players retire when they can still play at an elite level?
Defence..... versus center. Not the same imo. It is like apple and orange.Bourque was playing 25+ minutes a night for Colorado in his last season. Lidstrom won a Norris in his final season. Those are the only two that come to mind right now.
The question was what players retired at the top of their game. If we’re narrowing it to centers that’s a different question. Your last sentence is exactly the reason why it would make sense for Bergeron to retire. Sakic was still around a ppg when he retired. Plenty of players had to quit due to injuries adding up even though they were still good players.Defence..... versus center. Not the same imo. It is like apple and orange.
Roy went out when he was at the top... but he was a keeper...
In the past 99 and Howe comes to mind but different era..... 37 did not play against the Mickey Mouse or California Seals or in at the AMH.
Right now, Pavelski is the closest comparaison....
Bergeron body has been quite wreck thru the years....
Good stuff thanksBourque was playing 25+ minutes a night for Colorado in his last season. Lidstrom won a Norris in his final season. Those are the only two that come to mind right now.
Yeah - if his back is busted then it's a whole different story. IMO the state of his health short and long term is probably more important a factor in his decision about this year than family, $, or the roster issues.The question was what players retired at the top of their game. If we’re narrowing it to centers that’s a different question. Your last sentence is exactly the reason why it would make sense for Bergeron to retire. Sakic was still around a ppg when he retired. Plenty of players had to quit due to injuries adding up even though they were still good players.
Want to feel old?
Happy Bruins birthday, Bergy
I hope he comes back from a selfish standpoint (oops, is it ok for me to say I’m selfish or do I just accuse Bergeron for being selfish playing both last game and telling Monty he’s playing game 5?)
He comes back and Bettuzzi ends up taking 6:36 which is making the rounds among the group chatHowever, because they hurt me so bad emotionally and I was eating only frozen pizza and wearing only my Bruins bathrob snd B medallion/chain for 3 weeks an around the house, I won’t watch the regular season
I’m praying to the Gallery Gods Bergeron kids want him playing so when bring your dad to school they can say ‘he’s captain of the greatest regular season team ever and we love him’
Oh and @Ladyfan if he’s back we gotta take the girls back to Montreal (I owe that Habs tour bus guide one)
Yes, this exactly. Most NHL players, especially guys like Bergeron, are warriors and competitors. You don't get to that level of professional sports without having a strong competitive streak in you. To retire when you can still play, and you still seek to raise that Cup again, is virtually unheard of. I'm sure he would have retired had they won the Cup this year, but that storybook ending didn't happen.I totally hear what you are saying - I just cant think of any player who could still play at that high a level who chose to retire. So I'm asking if anyone has some names that I'm forgetting? It's not a rhetorical question.
Yes, this exactly. Most NHL players, especially guys like Bergeron, are warriors and competitors. You don't get to that level of professional sports without having a strong competitive streak in you. To retire when you can still play, and you still seek to raise that Cup again, is virtually unheard of. I'm sure he would have retired had they won the Cup this year, but that storybook ending didn't happen.
If he retires, I feel it would be for health reasons, or if the Bruins went into full rebuild mode. Assuming management can still put a competitive team on the ice, I think Bergy will want to take another run at it, to make a better showing than last playoffs, and at least purge some of the bitter taste from the way it ended. Why would anyone want to end their career on such a sour note?
I wonder if we'll know his decision before the awards ceremony next week. If not, and assuming he wins the Selke, it will be interesting to see how emotional he gets (or doesn't get). Although I expect he has a good poker face when he needs it.Life can get complicated for anyone. I can't even imagine how much more complicated it gets when your body goes through hell every year and you are on the road away from your family a good part of every season. Lots of things for Bergy to consider.
Your point about the competitive streak might be correct in that it could trump all of the other considerations. Only the elite of the elite players with major competitive streaks win multiple Selke Trophies. Part of the reason Bergy is so broken down by the playoffs is that he doesn't have an off switch. Every shift he is going balls to the wall in all three zones. That's one of the reasons he has so many Selkes.
I agree that it might be tough to just walk away from things, especially given how this past season ended. Bergy takes a lot of pride in his game and in being a B. I hope he comes back, but will certainly understand if he doesn't. Hate to see the hole it will leave if he retires. Also hate to see a great player leave when he is still capable of playing at a high level. One thing is for certain -- I will respect 100% whichever path Bergy chooses to take.
That's where the Bruins need to go out and get him help at the Center position. Bergy needs help there and that doesn't mean he still isn't great because he is. You bring in a Dubois/Lindholm/Mercer/Barzal a center who can log heavy minutes and take a lot of the wear and tear away from Bergeron in a long Season.For what season though?
Bergy is not young anymore. He could probably still excel in regular season for another 2 to 3 seasons. His experience, iq, leadership alone would be enough to get the job done.
But come playoffs...
How many close to 40 y/o players were able to lead their team to a deep playoff run?
The other thing is... lack of funds. While other older players (like Ovie) gets about 10m per season. Bergy would be playing for peanuts in comparison.
Bergy is def a hard one to read based on facial expressions. Maybe Monty will be looking at his body language and cue us all in (I kid, I kid). Hopefully we know earlier this summer than last summer on what he decides to do. If nothing is officially announced by a certain point perhaps the moves/non-moves the front office is making will reveal something.I wonder if we'll know his decision before the awards ceremony next week. If not, and assuming he wins the Selke, it will be interesting to see how emotional he gets (or doesn't get). Although I expect he has a good poker face when he needs it.
This^ If he decides to retire from playing, I hope he takes time off and then considers working for the BsLife can get complicated for anyone. I can't even imagine how much more complicated it gets when your body goes through hell every year and you are on the road away from your family a good part of every season. Lots of things for Bergy to consider.
Your point about the competitive streak might be correct in that it could trump all of the other considerations. Only the elite of the elite players with major competitive streaks win multiple Selke Trophies. Part of the reason Bergy is so broken down by the playoffs is that he doesn't have an off switch. Every shift he is going balls to the wall in all three zones. That's one of the reasons he has so many Selkes.
I agree that it might be tough to just walk away from things, especially given how this past season ended. Bergy takes a lot of pride in his game and in being a B. I hope he comes back, but will certainly understand if he doesn't. Hate to see the hole it will leave if he retires. Also hate to see a great player leave when he is still capable of playing at a high level. One thing is for certain -- I will respect 100% whichever path Bergy chooses to take.
Want to feel old?
Happy Bruins birthday, Bergy