Okay, so then Emmitt Smith is better than Jim Brown Barry Sanders.
In fact, the person with the most _________ is better than the person with less __________
Don't you think there's a little more nuance?
No one is arguing that Wayne Gretzky had the most productive career of all time. When we talk about "best" though, I'd think most people look at it more in terms of "peak level."
Mario scored more goals per game than Gretzky. He's 2nd all time to him in assists. His peak level of dominance, in my opinion, is greater than Gretzky's peak. He was able to do everything Gretzky did, plus things Gretzky couldn't.
It's hard to figure any logic that would say "Mario is overrated," or that they aren't within a whisker of one another on anything other than career totals in statistics.