So the poster believes Reinbacher was a mistake - it's an opinion and a prediction. He might be right...
It has nothing to do with Reinbacher.
I think you pick the BPA despite your roster make-up because anything can happen (busts, injuries, contract issues) and if you missed on a potential PPG+ winger with so much talent you’d better make changes to your process so it doesn’t happen again.
Maybe they over-valued “character” like Bergevin did — we still have Lapointe here, don’t forget. Maybe they were too arrogant about the roster’s existing look and felt that Michkov didn’t fit on an already small top6 — a dumb conclusion but I wouldn’t put it past NHL guys. Maybe they felt he wouldn’t want to come to Montreal — then the scout who talked to him should be fired and a better more charming scout should be sent to talk to players.
Whatever the reason, missing on a player so talented should not happen again. I don’t care if the entire top6 is under 5’9”, you can always make roster changes but you can’t acquire PPG+ cost-controlled players so easily.
I don’t want to even talk about Reinbacher because it isn’t fair to the guy to have to stack up against Michkov. What would Reinbacher even have to do in order to get the same aura and league-wide praise as Michkov? It’s asking for too much. I hope he has a good and productive career with us, that’s all I’ll expect from him.