Regardless of how you dole out the blame, you feel for the players and coaching staff after a game like today. That is one long bus ride home after you know that you just blew your season, and that you simply weren't good enough.
I know it is great sport to scapegoat Dave Cameron, but to me that is misplaced. James Boyd and his staff wear this one as far as I am concerned. Drafting simply hasn't been good enough, both in the Midget and the Import draft. Let's look at the drafting of Henry Brzustewicz - we take him and he almost immediately defects, which we are told was a deliberate strategy of Boyd to be able to trade a player he knew wouldn't report and bank extra picks. So we trade him, and in his draft year he is predictably having an outstanding season for London. What have we done with the "bounty" of picks we got in return? Not a lot from what I can see. We absolutely have to make those high picks count and find some diamonds in the rough in the late rounds. And again, two seasons of Kimi Korbler as one of your import slots on the roster? That's a waste of a roster spot that absolutely has to be producing for you. And finally, keeping Pinelli and then missing the playoffs anyway is straight up management malpractice no matter what kind of song and dance they might give you. They had a duty to move him out for some assets, but then left it too late and got left with nothing. You can't call yourself a competent GM and then allow blunders like that to happen on your watch.
I'd actually feel better if Boyd came out and admitted that this season was a write off and took responsibility. At least then I would know that he is self aware and willing to be honest. But no - we will almost certainly get a litany of excuses, intermingled with gaslighting trying to tell us that the team wasn't as bad as its record showed. (It was.)
I don’t see it as quite as bad as you do. It is still bad but I don’t think the strategies have been completely off. I think there was one single fundamental mistake that Boyd made and that one mistake domino’d into a series of unfortunate circumstances.
I have stated this before. The one monumental mistake was not going at it harder in 2022-23. He left trades sitting on the table. Shane Wright was an Ottawa 67. All he needed to do was move Mews and it was done. He had a few extra bodies that could have been moved out and either draft picks added or a couple extra bodies that had more purpose. Had he made those moves, the following year would have been a retool year. He could have traded Beck without any negative blowback, drafted the defect and banked draft picks (plus Eshkawkogan as the comp pick), made a few other seller moves like the Petes did. He could have done all of that under the blanket of being an OHL Champion. All of a sudden, the outlook completely changes.
HOWEVER, he did not do that. HE left gas in the tank for the following year where he once again didn’t empty the tank. Back to back 2nd round exits because he wasn’t’ truly committed. That leads to this year where the message should have been from day one that we are rebuilding. Is that the message? Nope. “We want to be competitive.” So, what do you think the players think? They think they are supposed to be competitive. No problem, except when the deadline comes around, it is a struggle to get players on the same page.
The Deadline: Well, Pinelli drove the bus off the cliff. He wanted Kitchener (they didn’t want him) or Oshawa (Griffin wouldn’t waive his No trade). He refused to go to Barrie int he deal for Vaughn. And then something happened to crash the potential Brantford deal. The word is now pretty much out that the deal to Barrie was done during the WJHC. Then, after the tourney, the deal was presented to Pinelli and he said he wanted to go to Kitchener or Oshawa. So, Barrie pivoted to the NB deal. Boyd needed to manage that situation better. He should have known Kitchener had no interest. And he also should have known Griffin had already refused SSM. All of that should have been communicated.
Then to top it all off, because Pinelli wound’t waive, the other potential deals stopped. Foster and Dever didn’t move. The focus then became trying to gain a playoff spot.
This was all a big chain of events linked to 2022-23 when Boyd left gas in the tank, got screwed and then continued to screw himself and the team with all the events that flew out of that deadline in 2022-23.
If you look at each deal individually, it really doesn’t look bad. We got a good return for HB as a defect. Same with Beck and an OA demanding a trade to start a season. The value moved for MAyer, Mallet, and Kressler was fine. I’m not too sure about the Mews deal because I don’t know what the options are on the 7-8-9 picks. That one may end up stinking really bad but Boyd was handcuffed, didn’t read the market well, and ended up having to eat it.
Of course, I had highlighted the Import issue in the summer. Korbler scored almost all of his goals last year playing on the top line against the non-playoff teams. He wasn’t competitive enough to return. He should not have returned and anyone with any clear sense would have realized that moving an NHL draft pick for a 4th round pick to keep Korbler was insane. On top of that, we were a team pretty much void of right shooting wingers and we keep the left shooting Import and move the right shooting NHL drafted Import. Of all the individual decisions made, that was by far the dumbest move possible. AND, I wasn’t looking at Uronen as a 1.5 PPG player either. I was thinking he would be around that 60 point range. I was thinking he could be a good deadline selloff player. Imagine moving him at the deadline to Kingston? We’d have gotten much more than a 4th round pick.
This whole situation is about not committing to a competitive cycle. This is about continually keeping an eye on next year. You can be competitive while participating in a cycle. Your moves are simply coordinated to the cycle. If you look at the standings year over year, finishing .500 isn’t all that difficult for mediocre teams. You can do that or a little better 2 years with one really good year and one really poor year. That is the cycle. Fans see the cycle and understand it. They see assets go out in a Championship run year. They see sell offs when it is a poor year. They understand it. They can get behind it and maintain their support. But, this year was a disaster. Actually, like I said, the last three years of management was a disaster that has culminated in a freak show.