OMG67
Registered User
- Sep 1, 2013
- 12,843
- 8,558
Hilton was a rookie, so you have to give him a little bit of grace. We also know that it takes longer for the bigger players to develop in any sport. I also remember a lot of us thinking Barlas was done. It is hard to say again, but I point to DC's aversion to or hate for playing rookies.
If he is a forward, Horner should be a first—or second-line player. We need the grit, for sure, but a line of three small guys is not going to do anything. Horner, if he improved his skating, would give a first line a lot of grit and corner presence as well as covering for Pinelli.
Dever is interesting as I think it is a choice between him and Barlas. Barlas is the better face off man and had shown the defensive ability. Dever is just a ittle below Barlas but is a RW. A lot is gong to depend on
a. who comes to camp
Right now I would rate our RW as
Stonehouse
Uronen
Korbler
Horner
unknown Euro pick
Dever
Kelly
At Center we have
Gardiner
Foster
Barlas
Whitehead
Dever
Amidovski
b. what kind of offer does the team get?
As to goal, I agree a lot will depend on the offers that we get for MacK but the one thing I do not want to see is them get into the same thing this year tht they did with Donoso. I also worry about KacK and his injuries. I would hate to go through a season where we have MacK injured Nelson playing every game and rotate in BU goalies that can not play. To me, if Nelson looks good and Hill has a good camp, then trading MacK early would solve our OA issue as well as solidify goaltending. If we run into an issue we can always trde for a rental goalie.
I won’t count out Hilton but each decision has an opportunity cost associated to it. If you give Hilton a spot, maybe you take that spot away from Yanni? Keep in mind that Hilton was a 17 year old rookie, not a 16 year old. So, he comes in as an 18 year old next year. It is definitely a make or break sort of year. We can definitely use the size, that is for sure.
I wouldn’t include Foster as a centre. He has played sparingly as a centre and that has never really amounted to anything positive. I’m also not comfortable with Barlas at centre. He has only succeeded at centre in a 4th line role where I feel his talent is wasted. He is a much better winger, definitely more impactful. I’d like to see Amidovski take on a bigger role as a top 9 winger as opposed to the 4th line centre in his rookie season.
Dever did show very well at centre as the seaosn came to a close and did fairly well int he playoffs too. I think they need to give him the puck in a top 9 role at centre. Let him run with it and see what happens. It would be good if he packed on a few pounds this summer. That would help his case.
At some point I do see MacK gone. That means we do need a backup BUT, I think we’d get a goalie as part of any package coming back in that deal.
As mentioned, there are so many variables at play that it is very difficult to predict the outcome. We really need to just let it play out and see who is left standing.