I would complain to Amazon.
I have bought hundreds of items since Amazon was born, and was never disappointed in anything I bought until a couple of years ago, when I purchased a lightning extension for my iPhone that didn't work.
I filed a complaint and they immediately refunded my money, without requiring a return of the product. Maybe you can coax them into sending you the item that is pictured then you would have a matching set for Williams: Cup and Conn-Smyth. The only thing that would be missing is the Campbell Bowl.