I feel like McLellan has been in L.A. forever, but I checked and this is only his 4th year there (I swear it feels like he's been there 10 years). I absolutely agree that they could do better. I don't know if I'm being fair to the guy, but for a franchise that is supposed to have one of the best prospect pools in the league, I feel that quite a few of their guys (Byfield, Turcotte) haven't developed the way they wanted, and I wonder how much of the blame could be placed on McLellan (it looks like Villardi finally broke out though).
I think he's pretty JAG at best. He's lucked into a lot of STACKED rosters before LA. He had the Sharks in their best years and they never made the SCF. I'm not saying a better coach gets them to the SCF, as much as I'm saying those were powerhouse teams and he really shouldn't get credit for it.
He also got McDavid in Edmonton. Inherited a lot of the leftover bad players there and didn't have good goalies, but I don't think he was doing anything to help make them better.
He always struck me as a clown with the Sharks. He was also on their hot seat forever, but somehow survived the reverse sweep in 2014, Looking back on it I think that was a brilliant move by Doug Wilson to cover his own ass. That move bought Doug Wilson more time. If he had fired McLellan after that playoff series loss and they still missed the playoffs in 14-15 under a new coach? He might very well get fired in the summer of 2015. I really believe he would have. But he brought back Todd for one more year and they missed the playoffs and it was easy for Doug Wilson to say ''Okay! I'm throwing in the towel on Todd! Let's try this with a different head coach!''. If he had fired him the year before and they missed the playoffs like they did with him, I don't think he would have been the GM in 15-16 when they made the cup finals. And that cup finals and another conference finals appearance 3 years later bought him more time before he stepped down for health reasons last year.
Todd once said after a matinee game out East that started at 1:00 PM EST that it was like playing a 10:00 AM game at home. And I'm pretty sure it wasn't even their first game on the trip. It was so cringy. I've looked for the quote or presser and can't seem to ever find it.
And then I remember in the lockout year I think it was? His post game in a terrible effort was him saying (he looked drunk, he sounded drunk, he had to be drunk) ''Well I didn't think we played badly''. It made me think of what a drunk guy would say and how they would act after being pulled over. ''Well, I'm not drunk officer!''.
And really there was one guy on the Sharks board that loved him so much and was worried than Anaheim would hire him (it turns out LA did instead!) and we'd constantly go back and forth about him.
Eddie Olczyk said during the stadium series game the Kings and Sharks played in 2015 something like ''Well, Todd McLellan, who's an elite coach in the league'' and I remember saying ''At least the coach is elite, right?'' in the GDT and he got so mad about it.