Confirmed with Link: Oilers Do Not Match Broberg ($4.58M X2) & Holloway ($2.29M x 2) Offer Sheets | Oilers acquire STL 3rd '28 & Paul Fischer for Futures

What Would You Do?


  • Total voters
    646
  • Poll closed .

Broberg Speed

Registered User
Oct 23, 2020
8,129
5,469
Right!? And since when is Desharnais bonafide? Pretty sure Van signed him to a two-way contract…

It’s hilarious that Ceci, Broberg, and VD are all bonafide D now. Emberson is no more a maybe than Broberg is, Stetcher is no more a maybe than VD, and Oilers fans have been trying to get rid of Ceci in basically 1 forever. Sheesh.
It was first reported on capfriendly, when that was still an entity, that Desharnais was a two-way contract but I'm pretty sure that was a mistake and it is a one-way contract.

They overpaid on that for sure.
 

Tobias Kahun

Registered User
Oct 3, 2017
44,820
55,962
Broberg is an 8th overall 6'4" 22 year old who skates very well and is trending upwards.

He has far more pedigree than the others and did play like one in his latest stint.

It's hard to believe the Oilers would let that go for a 2nd round pick...

It also seems strange that the Oilers would let a team walk all over them like that. You're then just asking for it again next year. Oh well, I guess we will soon find out which way the cookie crumbles.
Broberg played less games than Emberson last year and had worse results.
 

Broberg Speed

Registered User
Oct 23, 2020
8,129
5,469
Broberg is an 8th overall 6'4" 22 year old who skates very well and is trending upwards.

He has far more pedigree than the others and did play like one in his latest stint.

It's hard to believe the Oilers would let that go for a 2nd round pick...

It also seems strange that the Oilers would let a team walk all over them like that. You're then just asking for it again next year. Oh well, I guess we will soon find out which way the cookie crumbles.
It sucks but it would suck more if Broberg couldn't live up to the contract. No cup... maybe we can no longer sign our superstars kind of bad.
 

Thomas Tatar

Registered User
It was first reported on capfriendly, when that was still an entity, that Desharnais was a two-way contract but I'm pretty sure that was a mistake and it is a one-way contract.

They overpaid on that for sure.
Ah yes, ok thanks for the clarification. But as you say, still an overpay we couldn’t afford. Though in Vinny’s case at least he deserved it.
 

Mr Positive

Cap Crunch Incoming
Nov 20, 2013
37,970
18,891
It sucks but it would suck more if Broberg couldn't live up to the contract. No cup... maybe we can no longer sign our superstars kind of bad.
I really don't see the stakes as like that at all. 3 million destroys our team?

Walking from good young players is how you make Drai and McDavid antsy about staying long term.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThePhoenixx

ThePhoenixx

Registered User
Aug 7, 2005
9,577
6,295
Broberg played less games than Emberson last year and had worse results.
Broberg was with the team only during their horrid beginning. Everybody had bad stats at that time. He played very well in the A and in the playoffs. Like I said, he also has better pedigree.

Emberson may be a great pick up. He is also a few years older. Waivers already as well. He is 6'2" and apparently has a good first pass, that helps.
 

CantHaveTkachev

Cap Space > NHL players
Nov 30, 2004
52,170
34,200
St. OILbert, AB
Broberg was with the team only during their horrid beginning. Everybody had bad stats at that time. He played very well in the A and in the playoffs. Like I said, he also has better pedigree.

Emberson may be a great pick up. He is also a few years older. Waivers already as well. He is 6'2" and apparently has a good first pass, that helps.
makes you wonder why SJ would get rid of such an amazing player
 
  • Like
Reactions: Oilslick941611

Tobias Kahun

Registered User
Oct 3, 2017
44,820
55,962
Broberg was with the team only during their horrid beginning. Everybody had bad stats at that time. He played very well in the A and in the playoffs. Like I said, he also has better pedigree.

Emberson may be a great pick up. He is also a few years older. Waivers already as well. He is 6'2" and apparently has a good first pass, that helps.
Yeah, the Sharks were definitely a good team when Emberson was on them.
 

Broberg Speed

Registered User
Oct 23, 2020
8,129
5,469
I really don't see the stakes as like that at all. 3 million destroys our team?

Walking from good young players is how you make Drai and McDavid antsy about staying long term.
It would. We can't create cap out of thin air.

I'm sure McDavid and Draisaitl would like to get paid more than wiping Broberg's and Holloway's bums.

They chose their own fate by signing those offer sheets. If you disagree that's your privilege.

And you are the only poster who holds Broberg in such high esteem. A one man gang. A lone wolf.
 

Behind Enemy Lines

Registered User
Feb 19, 2003
16,850
18,632
Vancouver
so they made the defense worse in the hopes of getting a better player in March at the TDL?
that's risky as hell
And roll into the casino with a 2nd and 3rd round pick.

Running into THE prime Cup window season with 2 Arizona Coyote alumni who were flushed immediately once the team got an owner willing to spend is comedy gold if it weren't sadly true. Add another Yotes roadkill who's got a 30 game NHL run on the league's worst team. I'm actually curious about Emberson given his age and circumstances.

But it will be f***ing ugly watching a Broberg Parayko pairing while hoping the Oilers can burn more collateral to actually build an NHL contender level defense. They've blown out their two big right shot PKers. Sounds like this is tipping to the one of the biggest buy low heists ever with Oiler management caught asleep at the wheel in minding their pedigree kids. Oldest team in the league is now 2-3 years from having lesser quality NHL prospects Akey or Wanner maybe, maybe, step into third pairing role. Left defense prospects to succession plan for Ekholm and Kulak well that's an even bigger mystery.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CantHaveTkachev

Cloned

Begging for Bega
Aug 25, 2003
81,116
70,402
It would. We can't create cap out of thin air.

I'm sure McDavid and Draisaitl would like to get paid more than wiping Broberg's and Holloway's bums.

They chose their own fate by signing those offer sheets. If you disagree that's your privilege.

And you are the only poster who holds Broberg in such high esteem. A one man gang. A lone wolf.
Do you feel as though you’ve been betrayed by Broberg?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: TheNumber4

Broberg Speed

Registered User
Oct 23, 2020
8,129
5,469
His buyout is around 700k.
I guess, nothing's official yet, is it?

I thought on it long and hard. Initially I wanted to pass. Flip flopped a few times, and now back at not wanting the offer sheets matched.

In the end I don't hold any control over what happens regarding these offer sheets.

Do you feel as though you’ve been betrayed by Broberg?
He's his own driver. No, I can't say I feel betrayed, only a little disappointed. How do you feel about it?
 

CantHaveTkachev

Cap Space > NHL players
Nov 30, 2004
52,170
34,200
St. OILbert, AB
And roll into the casino with a 2nd and 3rd round pick.

Running into THE prime Cup window season with 2 Arizona Coyote alumni who were flushed immediately once the team got an owner willing to spend is comedy gold if it weren't sadly true. Add another Yotes roadkill who's got a 30 game NHL run on the league's worst team. I'm actually curious about Emberson given his age and circumstances.

But it will be f***ing ugly watching a Broberg Parayko pairing while hoping the Oilers can burn more collateral to actually build an NHL contender level defense. They've blown out their two big right shot PKers. Sounds like this is tipping to the one of the biggest buy low heists with Oiler management caught asleep at the wheel in minding their pedigree kids. Oldest team in the league is now 2-3 years from having lesser quality NHL prospects Akey or Wanner maybe, maybe, step into third pairing role. Left defense prospects to succession plan for Ekholm and Kulak well that's an even bigger mystery.
yup, this team is a old as dirt and losing young players...overpaid yes, but with high ceilings
and how have to rely on Yotes and Sharks castoffs to save the day

one injury to Ekholm/Nurse/Kulak and things will go south quickly...that's how thin we will be

but don't worry, we have a 2nd and 3rd rounder nab that top 4 d-man
 
  • Like
Reactions: Behind Enemy Lines

Tobias Kahun

Registered User
Oct 3, 2017
44,820
55,962
Ah, nice to see Pavel made it back.

yup, this team is a old as dirt and losing young players...overpaid yes, but with high ceilings
and how have to rely on Yotes and Sharks castoffs to save the day

one injury to Ekholm/Nurse/Kulak and things will go south quickly...that's how thin we will be

but don't worry, we have a 2nd and 3rd rounder nab that top 4 d-man
And if you sign Broberg.

one injury to Ekholm/Nurse/Broberg and things will go south quickly.

Signing Broberg isnt going to make the defense deeper.
 

VainGretzky

Registered User
Jun 4, 2015
14,024
12,725
yup, this team is a old as dirt and losing young players...overpaid yes, but with high ceilings
and how have to rely on Yotes and Sharks castoffs to save the day

one injury to Ekholm/Nurse/Kulak and things will go south quickly...that's how thin we will be

but don't worry, we have a 2nd and 3rd rounder nab that top 4 d-man
54y.gif
 

ThePhoenixx

Registered User
Aug 7, 2005
9,577
6,295
makes you wonder why SJ would get rid of such an amazing player
I see a few reasons for the trade.

The first is that Ceci will help shelter their younger D from getting shelled. He is a fine player for a rebuilding team. He will always give one hundred percent and does have some playoff experience.

Then they get a third round pick and most likely another third when he is traded at the deadline. That's two picks and a real player for a waiver wire pickup.

The third reason is contingent on the Oilers matching. St. Louis will most likely be entering their compete phase at the same time as San Jose. So instead of St. Louis getting a couple young dynamic players for pennies on the dollar who will be thorns, San Jose gets two picks instead.

Then there is always the good relations thing when your team still sucks.
 

unicornBLOOD

Registered User
Mar 18, 2022
524
594
makes you wonder why SJ would get rid of such an amazing player
asset management, Emberson is a decent, young-ish Dman who had a pretty good first 30 games of his NHL career. No one is saying that he's got superstar potential. But, who knows, if everything breaks right and he develops, maybe he becomes a #4 dman, or even just a bottom pairing dman, it's way too early to tell. SJ is bad, and they expect to be bad for a few more seasons, they added a 3rd round pick and Ceci, a vet dman, with an expiring contract, who has a lot of experience, including a bunch of NHL playoffs experience - which SJ will flip to another team at the deadline or some other point in the season for another asset or 2.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThePhoenixx

Shanahanigans

Registered User
Jun 16, 2011
2,499
2,548
He has no one to blame but himself and I don’t feel sorry for him one bit. No one put a gun to his head forcing him to sign the offer sheet knowing the Oilers may not match. All he had to do was decline it and keep negotiating with the Oilers. He didn't do that, so he can sleep in the bed of his own shit he created by putting pen to paper.
23 year old who got bad advice and made a bad judgement call. He’ll learn from it. What I got from Holloway in his time here is that he loved to be an Oiler. Alberta boy through and through, always brought energy and passion, and the fan base loved him this run. I think his agent told him to call the Oilers bluff and it didn’t work out in his favour.
Broberg finally showed some potential on the third pair but at 4.5 he can kick rocks.
 

Behind Enemy Lines

Registered User
Feb 19, 2003
16,850
18,632
Vancouver
yup, this team is a old as dirt and losing young players...overpaid yes, but with high ceilings

one injury to Ekholm/Nurse/Kulak and things will go south quickly...that's how thin we will be

but don't worry, we have a 2nd and 3rd rounder nab that top 4 d-man
Funny to read about all the concern that Broberg might fail when it's also a strong consideration that he succeeds. Exceedingly rare for a black ace d-man to step into Final Four Cup competition and keep his head above water. This organization has taken an average NHL d-corp and incredibly made it worse. Injuries and we're into the Ben Gleason era.

Shaving the winning window with little NHL ready (or certain) talent.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CantHaveTkachev

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad