Official 9th Baseball ATD Thread (Picks Only)

Tecumseh

Scorched Earth
Oct 20, 2012
9,352
825
Southbridge, MA
With the 201st overall pick in the thirteenth round, the Albuquerque Dukes select SP Urban Shocker.

3448_a.jpg


Although the question about who is the best major league baseball team is quite subjective, the answer that is given on many occasions is the 1927 New York Yankees. The team that was dubbed “Murderers’ Row” included Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Earle Combs, Tony Lazzeri, Herb Pennock and Waite Hoyt. All are members of the National Baseball Hall of Fame. There are some who would argue that Bob Meusel could join them. Throw in stars Joe Dugan and Mark Koenig, plus catcher Pat Collins and you have the whole starting nine.

It almost seemed unfair that the Yankees obtained Urban Shocker from the St. Louis Browns. Shocker won 20 games four years in a row for the Browns, and now he was an added gun to the best team in baseball. Especially when one considers the Yankees were Shocker’s first major league club and they unloaded him to St. Louis in 1918. “There were a lot of things I had to find out, even about my own players,” said Miller Huggins, who had just taken over as manager of the Yankees in 1918. “So I poked around and found out as much as I could about them before the training season started. One of the things I was told was that I would do well to get rid of Shocker as quickly as possible because he was a trouble-maker. I later discovered that my information had done Shocker a grave injustice. Urban has never made trouble for anyone.”1 Huggins righted his wrong, reacquiring the St. Louis ace.

Shocker was able to fulfill the dream of most ballplayers; winning a World Championship. Shocker pitched that 1927 season on guts and guile. What was known to very few, and certainly not outside the Yankee organization, was that he was suffering from a heart disease that corroded one of his valves. But he battled through the pain on his way to 18 victories and a 2.84 ERA, the third-lowest in the league.

12 year career

187-117
3.17 ERA
124 ERA+
1.255 WHIP
3.54 FIP
54.9 WAR
200 complete games
28 shutouts
983 strikeouts
1921 AL wins leader (27)
1922 AL strikeout leader
1926 AL Pennant
1927 World Champion​
 

Pwnasaurus

Registered User
Feb 21, 2003
8,124
0
Robot City
The St.Louis Cardinals are pleased to select a left handed middle reliever and a member of both the Canadian BBHOF and the Canadian Sports HOF, RP - John Hiller. Hiller's comeback story after suffering a heart attack in 1971 is nothing short of miraculous, 2 years later he would lead the league in saves as well as setting a major league record in the process (later broken in 1983 by Dan Quisenberry). Hiller's adjusted ERA+ of 285 in 1973 is the highest in team history and he ranks 24th all-time in that category currently tied with Greg Maddux. In 1974 he would set an AL record with 17 wins in relief.

- 1 Top 5 MVP Finish
- 2 Top 10 Cy Young Award Finishes
- 5 Top 10 Save Finishes
- 1 World Series Championship
- Career Record: 87-76, 2.83 ERA, 125 Saves, 1036 Strikeouts in 1242 Innings Pitched
 

Vegeta

Prince of all Saiyans
May 2, 2009
4,197
667
Capsule Corp.
The Detroit Tigers select, the criminally underrated southpaw, SP Cole Hamels

Cole-Hamels-Texas-Rangers-v-Detroit-Tigers-y57jO2w0h9xl.jpg


Career Stats

136-96
3.31 ERA
125 ERA+
49.8 WAR
1.161 WHIP
8.6 K/9​
 
Last edited:

darko

Registered User
Feb 16, 2009
70,272
7,803
204 - New York Yankees select - CF, Kenny Lofton

.299 career batting average
2428 career hits
6x All Star
4x Gold Glove Winner
622 career stolen bases
 

NJDevs26

Once upon a time...
Mar 21, 2007
68,454
33,898
Pick #205 - For my #4 starter, another big-game pitcher:

Hunter%20Catfish%20Plaque%20247_.png


-Won five World Series with the A's and the Yankees
-Eight time All-Star
-234 or more innings pitched every season for ten straight years, including two seasons of 300+
-181 complete games in 476 starts
-A 1.13 WHIP (47th all-time)
-Twice led the league in wins and had five straight 20+ win seasons
-Cy Young, Walter Johnson and Christy Mathewson were the only pitchers to win 200 games by the age of 31 before Catfish
-Had a 3.26 ERA and a 1.12 WHIP in 19 postseason starts

“Catfish Hunter was the cornerstone of the Yankees success over the last quarter century,” Yankees owner George Steinbrenner said. “We were not winning before Catfish arrived…He exemplified class and dignity and he taught us how to win.”

 

Porn*

Registered User
Mar 6, 2002
36,386
5
In your nightmares
Toronto Blue Jays select,

2nd - Bill "Maz" Mazeroski

Mazeroski is regarded as one of the greatest defensive second basemen of all time. He was an All-Star for seven seasons[a]and a Gold Glove Award winner for eight seasons. He was a key member of the Pirates' World Series-winning teams in 1960 and 1971, and is best known for his walk-off home run in the bottom of the ninth inning in game 7 of the 1960 World Series—the only game 7 walk-off homer in World Series history.[1]

Batting average .260
Hits 2,016
Home runs 138
Runs batted in 853

10× All-Star (1958–1960², 1962–1964, 1967)
2× World Series champion (1960, 1971)
8× Gold Glove Award (1958, 1960, 1961, 1963–1967)
Pittsburgh Pirates #9 retired

While his defensive ability typically overshadowed his contributions with a bat – Pirates broadcaster Bob Prince used to call him simply "The Glove" – Mazeroski had several fine offensive seasons. His best was in 1958, when he batted .275, hit 19 home runs (a career best), had 68 RBIs, good enough that along with his sterling mitt he was considered for the MVP Award. In 1966 he knocked in 82, a career best. During his peak (1957–68), he drove in more runs than any other middle infielder of the period. Mazeroski's power numbers were held down by the distant fences in Forbes Field. In his career, he hit over twice as many home runs on the road as he did in his home park – 45 home runs at home versus 93 on the road. By comparison, the Chicago Cubs slugging second baseman Ryne Sandberg hit only 118 of his 282 career home runs away from the comfy confines of Wrigley Field.
 

Porn*

Registered User
Mar 6, 2002
36,386
5
In your nightmares
Toronto Blue Jays are pleased to select,

RP - Jeff Reardon

Games pitched 880
Win–loss record 73–77
Earned run average 3.16
Strikeouts 877
Saves 367

4× All-Star (1985, 1986, 1988, 1991)
World Series champion (1987)
NL Rolaids Relief Man Award (1985)
NL saves leader (1985)



Schilling
Halladay
Bumgarner
Pettitte

Rivera
Reardon
 
Last edited:

NJDevs26

Once upon a time...
Mar 21, 2007
68,454
33,898
Waiting out the run on RP's and a bit of a value/course correction pick after taking stock and seeing that I probably need one more true HR bat in my lineup (Ducky might not be too happy about being my top bench player now that Frank's going to LF - his better fielding position - to accomodate this guy):



-1998 MVP winner
-Six silver slugger awards
-An average 162-game season of .273-42-115 and 16 SB's
-609 career HR's (8th all-time)
-Eleven seasons of 30+ HR's (including six straight of 40+ and an unprecedented three seasons of 60+)
-A .533 slugging percentage (42nd all-time)
-1667 career RBI's (29th all-time)
-Nine straight seasons of 100+ RBI's (including two of 150+)
-For good measure, throw in 234 career steals including three seasons of 30+ and two more of 20+
 
Last edited:

darko

Registered User
Feb 16, 2009
70,272
7,803
213 - New York Yankees select - OF, Paul Waner

1927 MVP
3x NL batting champion
4x all star
3152 career hits (17th all time)
.333 career batting average
.404 career OBP
 

Vegeta

Prince of all Saiyans
May 2, 2009
4,197
667
Capsule Corp.
The Detroit Tigers welcome back RP Andrew Miller

andrew-miller-of-the-detroit-tigers-during-game-three-of-the-2006-picture-id72341962


Career Stats (As a reliever)

1.92 ERA
0.98 ERA (Postseason)
199 ERA+
0.981 WHIP
14.0 K/9

Andrew Miller is one of the worst starting pitchers I have ever, ever had the displeasure of watching in the Old English D. But hot damn has he turned into an incredible reliever. Arguably the greatest closer in the game today, Miller can act as both set up and closer for the Tigers, alongside Rollie Fingers. Both guys regularly proved that they can go 2-3 innings deep with ease, and both are absolutely shut down. The Tiger's backend is going to be a tough nut to crack for opposing hitters.​
 

Pwnasaurus

Registered User
Feb 21, 2003
8,124
0
Robot City
The St. Louis Cardinals are pleased to select one of the best pitchers of the 1950's and also one of the better ones not in the HOF, SP -Billy Pierce. Pierce slots in as a 4th starter on this club and another lefty to pair with Gomez.

- 2 Times finished Top 10 in league MVP voting
- 2 Times led league in Pitcher's WAR (6 Times finished in Top 5)
- Led League in ERA (1955), 4 Times finished in Top 5
- Led League in Strikeouts (1953), 5 Times finished in Top 5
- Led League in Wins (1957), 4 Times finished in Top 5
 

Tecumseh

Scorched Earth
Oct 20, 2012
9,352
825
Southbridge, MA
With the 216th overall pick in the fourteenth round, the Albuquerque Dukes select RP Gary Lavelle.

101744-14342752Fr.jpg


13 year career

80-77
2.93 ERA
126 ERA+
3.14 FIP
136 saves
769 strikeouts
2x All-Star​
 

Winger for Hire

Praise Beebo
Dec 9, 2013
13,058
1,692
Quarantine Zone 5
With the 217th pick in the draft, the Yomiuri Giants select 2B Jacob Nelson "Nellie" Fox

EBC6136B-DF2C-4B36-8085-321440012996.jpg


Fox's season high in strikeouts was 18. He also ranks 5th all time in AB/SO, while leading the league in Games Played (5), Plate Appearances (5- all consecutive), and At Bats (5) in numerous season, so it wasn't because he never played.

Fox was also one of the best fielding 2B ever, only earning 3 Gold Gloves because the award only started during his 10th season in the league. He did earn the first Gold Glove for second basemen that year.


Career Highlights

HoF Inductee (197)
AL MVP (1959)
15 time All-Star
3 time Gold Glove
Lead League in hits 4 times

Career Stats

.288/.348/.363 Triple Slash
.710 OPS (93 OPS+)

2367 Games
10351 Plate Appearances

2663 Hits
355 Doubles
112 Triples
35 Home Runs
790 RBI
1279 Runs Scored
76 Stolen Bases

216 Strikeouts (Career, not one season)
719 Walks

49.0 bWAR
21.0 dWAR

I don't think I could ask for a more ideal #8 hitter.
 

le_sean

Registered User
Oct 21, 2006
41,872
44,879
With the 218th (219th) pick in the ATD, the Montreal Royals select RP Mike Marshall.

CYK7I5mWwAAMlWd.jpg


NL Cy Young (1974)
4 Top-5 Cy Young voting
2x Top-5 MVP voting
2x All-Star
3x Saves leader
3.23 ERA
880 strikeouts​

Screwballer Mike Marshall, led his league in games pitched four times, saves three times, and games finished five times as a reliver. He is the holder of two major league records most appearances in a season (106), and most consecutive team games with a relief appearance (13). In his record-setting 1974 season, he pitched 208.3 innings, all of which came in relief appearances. We are happy to add this workhorse to our bullpen.
 

Voight

#winning
Feb 8, 2012
41,936
18,512
Mulberry Street
635655232518358572-USP-MLB-LOS-ANGELES-DODGERS-AT-SAN-DIEGO-PADRES-72576282.JPG

The Atlanta Braves will select SP Zack Grienke

3× All-Star (2009, 2014, 2015)
2× MLB ERA leader (2009, 2015)
AL Cy Young Award (2009) 3x Top 10 Voting
3× Gold Glove Award (2014–2016)
Silver Slugger Award (2013)

155–100
3.42 ERA
2,021 SO
1.19 WHIP
 
Oct 18, 2011
44,243
10,128
With the final pick of the 14th round the Los Angeles Angels are going to round out their starting rotation with yet another power arm, a player who is one of 18 pitchers all time to win 2 Cy Youngs, a career SO/9 of 10 flat. Max Scherzer. I value peak over longevity, his SO/9 in the post season is 11+ which shows against better competition he remains difficult to hit

I like power arms who can generate strike outs independent of the team around them, and how many rotations are going to have a 2 time Cy Young Winner as it's 4th or 5th starter?
 
Oct 18, 2011
44,243
10,128
With the first pick of the 15th round the Los Angeles Angels select OF/1B Lance Berkman

6 top 10 MVP finishes
Career WAR over 50
Career OPS+ of 144(top 50 all time)
Career OBP of .406(42nd all time)
72nd all time in home runs per AB
Top 100 all time in runs created

Berkman is an offensive machine and can thrive in any role I put him in, either as a starter or off the bench
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad