Toronto Blue Jays
22nd overall
17th in quality depth (prospects better than 40 FV)
$149.5 million total value
38 players
1. Ricky Tiedemann, LHP, 55 FV (25th on the top 100)
2. Orelvis Martinez, 3B, 50 FV (67)
3. Brandon Barriera. LHP, 45+ FV (161)
4. Leo Jimenez, SS, 45+ FV (174)
5. Hayden Juenger, RHP, 45+ FV (183)
6. Tucker Toman, 3B, 45 FV
7. Addison Barger, 3B, 45 FV
8. Yosver Zulueta, RHP, 45 FV
9. Adam Macko, LHP, 45 FV
10. Sem Robberse, RHP, 45 FV
11. Cade Doughty, 3B, 40+ FV
12. Adrian Pinto, 2B, 40+ FV
40 FV (13): Enmanuel Bonilla/RF, Manuel Beltre/SS, Estiven Machado/2B, Josh Kasevich/SS, Otto Lopez/2B, Gabriel Martinez/RF, Dahian Santos/RHP, Damiano Palmegiani/3B, Alan Roden/LF, Trent Palmer/RHP, C.J. Van Eyk/RHP, Dasan Brown/CF, Alex De Jesus/3B
35+ FV (13): Irv Carter/RHP, Luis Meza/C, Rafael Ohashi/RHP, Hagen Danner/RHP, Nathan Lukes/CF, Spencer Horwitz/1B, Chad Dallas/RHP, Zach Britton/C, Kendry Rojas/LHP, Alejandro Melean/HP, Davis Schneider/3B, Tanner Morris/3B, Mason Fluharty/LHP
2023 Impact: Tiedemann
40+ FV breakout pick: Pinto
40 FV or less breakout pick: Roden
Ranked prospects beyond the top 100
Barriera
drew attention before the draft due to the unique way that he approached his workload late in the spring, opting to not pitch like a running back who skips his bowl game before the NFL draft. He got even more support than I expected as a prospect when I sent around an extended top 100 this offseason, with a number of sources saying he is on their internal top 100. All four of his pitches flash plus and he shows all the starter traits at times, but some scouts worry about a relief risk.
Toman was another of my favorite players in the draft, a switch-hitting infielder with plus power and a proven bat. He got $2 million in the second round because some teams worried that he is a future corner outfielder with some hit tool risk, but I think he'll hit and stay at third base. Doughty (solid-average hit/power combo, probably a third baseman) and Kasevich (plus hitter, good approach, limited power and probably not a shortstop) were two vanilla but solid college infielders from the 2022 draft class. Barger is another solid infielder, but more like Toman as a second or third baseman who now projects for above-average power after hitting 26 homers in a breakout 2022 season. Jimenez is a solid shortstop who can really hit but has little power while Pinto, acquired from Colorado last year, is a 5-6 second baseman who also can really hit but also has very little power.
Juenger took a big step forward in 2022, throwing 98.2 innings across Double-A and Triple-A as a 21-year-old. His fastball, which he throws two-thirds of the time, sits 94-96 mph and his changeup and slider are both above average. The main question going forward is if his command will be good enough to start (I say yes). Zulueta appeared in Triple-A last season and has three above-average pitches, but his command is a notch worse so he's likely a reliever with the stuff to go multiple innings. Macko went in the seventh round in 2019 and has thrown just 95 pro innings since then due to injury. He'll flash four above-average pitches and decent control, but has below-average command. Robberse topped out in the 80s when signed out of the Netherlands in 2019 and now sits 90-92 with a deep, solid-average arsenal and the command to make a number of big league starts.
Others of note
Bonilla is my fifth-ranked prospect in the international signing period that opened last month. Most scouts say he's a slam-dunk right fielder, though Toronto thinks he has a chance to stay in center field. His bat should profile in either spot, with a shot for above-average hit and power tools and that power could possibly be plus or more at maturity. Roden is almost the exact opposite player, as a now 23-year old first baseman/left fielder with one above-average tool. But that hit tool is a 70 and his pitch selection might also be a 70, so he's a likely big leaguer who may slice through the minors with a limited upside.
Santos fits at the top of the pitchers in this range as he's still a teenager, has three above-average pitches and enough athleticism to project improvement in his command. Palmer gets good life and angle on his 91-94 mph sinker while his slider and change both flash above-average as well, but his command is a notch below average. Carter was a power prep righty who made progress in the spring of 2021 by using his athleticism to throw better strikes, eventually signing for $850,000 in the fifth round. He works 92-94 with an above average-flashing slider and changeup, but it's unclear so far what role suits him best at the upper levels
www.thestar.com
