Proposal: NYR-Ducks

[bfaust30]

Rick Nash (50%) retained + Lindberg + 2018 Rangers 2nd rounder for Lindholm. Maybe another late pick from the Rangers.

Click to read more...

 

[KirkOut]

If I were Anaheim I would not be enthused about that offer

 

[pld459666]

I'm a Rangers fan and I'm not enthused about the deal from the Ducks perspective

 

[Sojourn]

If I were Anaheim I would not be enthused about that offer

Understatement is an unappreciated art form.

This is bad.

 

[bfaust30]

Is it rlly that off?

 

[Trapper]

Rick Nash (50%) retained + Lindberg + 2018 Rangers 2nd rounder for Lindholm. Maybe another late pick from the Rangers.

I would have to say the Ducks easily say no.
That's not close to the basis of a Lindholm deal.

 

[nbducksfan19]

This is trash.

 

[nbducksfan19]

Is it rlly that off?

Yes. rlly.

 

[gump116]

I would have to say the Ducks easily say no.
That's not close to the basis of a Lindholm deal.

How about same offer for Vatanen? Seems like an overpay from Rangers perspective. Maybe take Lindberg out.

Nash (50% retained) + 2nd rounder for Vatanen

 

[dracom]

please just close this thread.

 

[dracom]

How about same offer for Vatanen? Seems like an overpay from Rangers perspective. Maybe take Lindberg out.

Nash (50% retained) + 2nd rounder for Vatanen

We don't want Nash.

 

[Trapper]

How about same offer for Vatanen? Seems like an overpay from Rangers perspective. Maybe take Lindberg out.

Nash (50% retained) + 2nd rounder for Vatanen

Ducks just re-signed Vatanen doubt he's going anywhere.
However if teams want Lindholm/Vatanen, they are going to have to give up something they really don't want to and not something they are trying to get rid of.

 

[Stuzchuk]

Is it rlly that off?

well compare it to below

ANA
McDonaugh

NYR
Kesler (50%)
Despres
ANA 2018-2nd


would you do this...?

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Rick Nash (50%) retained + Lindberg + 2018 Rangers 2nd rounder for Lindholm. Maybe another late pick from the Rangers.

How can Ducks GM B ob Murray turn this down.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

How about same offer for Vatanen? Seems like an overpay from Rangers perspective. Maybe take Lindberg out.

Nash (50% retained) + 2nd rounder for Vatanen

Even if Vatanen was available and he's not, They can still do better then an aging Nash at half off.

 

[McDonald19]

Rick Nash (50%) retained + Lindberg + 2018 Rangers 2nd rounder for Lindholm. Maybe another late pick from the Rangers.

Lindholm is not available.

Your value is also horrible.

 

[HanSolo]

Next. I thank you for not involving Fowler at least.

 

[PCDiesel]

rick nash (50%) retained + lindberg + 2018 rangers 2nd rounder for lindholm. Maybe another late pick from the rangers.

gtfo

 

[One Winged Angel]

well compare it to below

ANA
McDonaugh

NYR
Kesler (50%)
Despres
ANA 2018-2nd


would you do this...?

Not comparable at all. Nash is a 1st line winger that averages over 30 goals a year and is due for a bounce back year. Kesler at this point is a 2nd line center at best.

Oh and McDonagh is definitely better than Lindholm. McDonagh is a proven #1 top-10 defender, Lindholm has potential but isn't at that point.

 

[Savant]

Is it rlly that off?

Yes. Just like all of the other offers you have posted this summer.

 

[KreiderHouseRules*]

well compare it to below

ANA
McDonaugh

NYR
Kesler (50%)
Despres
ANA 2018-2nd


would you do this...?

Absolutely.

NYR would have to find out who McDonaugh is and sign him first, but sure!

 

[JT Kreider]

Bad for the Ducks but no different than every other thread that offers a package for another teams best players

 

[HanSolo]

Not comparable at all. Nash is a 1st line winger that averages over 30 goals a year and is due for a bounce back year. Kesler at this point is a 2nd line center at best.

Oh and McDonagh is definitely better than Lindholm. McDonagh is a proven #1 top-10 defender, Lindholm has potential but isn't at that point.

At best? He is a second line center.

 

[One Winged Angel]

At best? He is a second line center.

Yeah in Anaheim where center depth behind Getzlaf is scarce.

There's a lot of teams in which he would play 3rd line center.

 

[dracom]

Yeah in Anaheim where center depth behind Getzlaf is scarce.

There's a lot of teams in which he would play 3rd line center.

because Selke finalists are just 3rd liners...