Speculation: NYR & DET working on Jacob Trouba trade (Brooks)

[nbwingsfan]

https://x.com/i/web/status/1792942207839707339

That’s great, it would be very sad if we were not near the top considering we’ve had a million picks in the first two rounds and barely any of our prospects have graduated.

It still in no way proves he hit home ruins in guys who haven’t played a game or established themselves

 

[bigdog16]

So we managed to win the President's award with Trouba in our top-4 (most of the season), but Detroit won't sniff the playoffs?

You may not like Trouba, and that's fine, but suggesting he's a bottom pairing AHL dmen is impossibly foolish.

Your right, he actually belongs in the coast

 

[Our Lady Peace]

The takes in this thread are simply... I'll put it... Par for the HF course

I hate Jacob Trouba and the way he plays, but if he dials it back, doesn't have a C on his jersey and just plays his game like in Winnipeg, he will be fine at what I hope is retention for 5.5m x 2. He's not some complete scrub unable to play in the NHL anymore. Sometime the change of scenery benefits players greatly

 

[nbwingsfan]

https://x.com/i/web/status/1792942207839707339

That’s great, it would be very sad if we were not near the top considering we’ve had a million picks in the first two rounds and barely any of our prospects have graduated.

It still in no way proves he hit home runs in guys who haven’t even played yet.

 

[nbwingsfan]

No offense, but I'll take Hakan Andersson's drafting for the past 34 years over your opinion. If you can't tell the difference between his track record and track record of Detroit's North American scouts well then I honestly don't know what to say. Ken Holland gave the majority of his first round picks to his NA scouts and they turned out bangers like Filip Zadina, Joe Veleno, Michael Rasmussen, Dennis Cholowski, Evgeny Svechnikov, Anthony Mantha, Riley Sheahan, Thomas McCollum, Brendan Smith and Jakub Kindl.

Sure, they drafted Dylan Larkin and deserve credit for that pick, but the hit rate is abysmal.

And Andersson has had misses too.

I’m as hopeful as the next guy, but saying we “knocked out draft picks out of the park” just because he picked some of them is non sensical.

The fact is we haven’t graduated a player to full time since 2020 draft, and we have no idea what we have right now

 

[ICanMotteBelieveIt]

The Post is garbage in general but Brooks is the most plugged in Rangers reporter there is. So if he’s saying it, it’s not bullshit

I wonder if Trouba will beat him up at a bus stop.

Edit: for reference for those who don't remember this timeless classic!

 

[D3vilsH0ck3y]

Another get out of jail free card coming to the Rangers, must be nice.

Yzerman sucks

 

[Gardner McKay]

Another get out of jail free card coming to the Rangers, must be nice.

Yzerman sucks

These posts might be the best part about this potential trade.

 

[and 99 others]

The Rangers trading their captain to a Steve Yzerman run franchise, a tale as old as 2014

 

[Petes2424]

If Detroit ends up doing this, look for Petry to probably be bought out. Whether they change their pursuit of Matt Roy is another story. Maybe that changes to a Brady Skjei to play with Seider.

Trouba will be asked to be a supporting player, no longer carrying play. That’s a big thing as Seider and Edvinsson will carry the lace for the D for the foreseeable future.

At $5.5 million, its well worth it.

 

[LaffyTaffy13]

These posts might be the best part about this potential trade.

These people on here just live in an alternate universe where players are either negative value and you need to attach four 1st’s to move them or theyre untouchable and only prime 99 coming back the other way would move them.

Youd be a fool to think there wouldnt be takers for trouba

 

[datsyukfan]

If Detroit ends up doing this, look for Petry to probably be bought out. Whether they change their pursuit of Matt Roy is another story. Maybe that changes to a Brady Skjei to play with Seider.

Trouba will be asked to be a supporting player, no longer carrying play. That’s a big thing as Seider and Edvinsson will carry the lace for the D for the foreseeable future.

At $5.5 million, its well worth it.

Would that be with holl leaving too?

 

[FoxyClean]

I don’t think Detroit fans understand just how bad this guy is at this point in his career.

 

[Go Wings]

I don’t think Detroit fans understand just how bad this guy is at this point in his career.

Some of us do that's why we don't want him.

 

[Run the Jewels]

And Andersson has had misses too.

I’m as hopeful as the next guy, but saying we “knocked out draft picks out of the park” just because he picked some of them is non sensical.

The fact is we haven’t graduated a player to full time since 2020 draft, and we have no idea what we have right now

Lucas Raymond has entered the chat..

Edit: the main reason why Walman was let go was because Edvinsson took his spot.

 

[jkutswings]

Does Jacob Trouba still belong in the NHL? Yes.

Does he belong on the second pairing in Detroit for $5.5M AAV? No.

Assuming one of Husso or Holl are not going the other way, I don't understand this proposed deal.

 

[AvatarAang]

What are the odds that Trouba gets traded to Detroit, and then gets suspended for elbowing someone on the Rangers?

 

[TheNumber4]

I’m beginning to think GM Yzerman is a complete fraud.

What could he possibly want with one of the worst defenceman in the NHL? Trouba blows. He’s horrible.

Yzerman better be getting paid a shit load of futures to take this on.

 

[LaffyTaffy13]

I’m beginning to think GM Yzerman is a complete fraud.

What could he possibly want with one of the worst defenceman in the NHL? Trouba blows. He’s horrible.

Yzerman better be getting paid a shit load of futures to take this on.

1) hes not one of the worst dmen in the nhl
2) he is overpaid

Both can be true

 

[TheNumber4]

1) hes not one of the worst dmen in the nhl
2) he is overpaid

Both can be true

I mean sure, there’s a lot of D-men in this league. But he’s still horrific at hockey though.

 

[DanielBrassard]

I mean sure, there’s a lot of D-men in this league. But he’s still horrific at hockey though.

This sort of hyperbole is ridiculous, he’s not horrific. He’s an overpaid but still useful defenseman who is prone to making some dumb decisions. Put him with a defenseman who is good at making that first pass and can cover ground defensively though.

 

[TheNumber4]

This sort of hyperbole is ridiculous, he’s not horrific. He’s an overpaid but still useful defenseman who is prone to making some dumb decisions. Put him with a defenseman who is good at making that first pass and can cover ground defensively though.

I don’t think so. I watched his work in the playoffs. I would call it horrific when nearly every single puck touch he makes turns into something bad. Sure a better partner would help that would help any defenceman in this league, but Trouba will still have to make plays all on his own too, and he seemingly picks plays at random to make, how he plays.

 

[winnipegger]

Trouba does one thing really well, which is to be a mean son of a bitch.

 

[Baby Punisher]

Word on the street is that it's #47 and Justin Holl for retained Trouba?

Holl's cap hit is $3.4 plus $2.5 for Trouba's retention total $5.9.
That's a lit if money to be carry for just $2.1 million in cap space.

I wonder if the Rangers Trade, waive or buyout Holl.

I wonder if Trouba will beat him up at a bus stop.

Edit: for reference for those who don't remember this timeless classic!

Than they went for dinner after that and fought each other at a bus stop.

 

[DingDongCharlie]

Waiting for the elaborate deal that has Seider and Raymond going back to the Rangers

Somehow we're dragged into the deal for the Rangers to grab Broberg.