Proposal: NYR-CAL-MTL (3 way)

[broc]

You ppl saying Ny says no are nuts.

The only piece with decent value is Kreider.

You get rid of Nash and his god awful contract. Lose mcIlrath, a decent d prospect at best, and Kreider.

And you get one of the best young D of the past few years, a good 2 way player in Frolik, and a good pick.

Like was said already... Hamilton alone is worth more than that.

 

[Machinehead]

This is horrible for all 3 teams.

Yeah I think every team gets worse. Somehow. Bravo, op.

 

[One Winged Angel]

You ppl saying Ny says no are nuts.

The only piece with decent value is Kreider.

You get rid of Nash and his god awful contract. Lose mcIlrath, a decent d prospect at best, and Kreider.

And you get one of the best young D of the past few years, a good 2 way player in Frolik, and a good pick.

Like was said already... Hamilton alone is worth more than that.

Nash isn't a cap dump. He scored 42 goals in 2015. Career year, but he's good for 30+ a year when healthy. .

That's where you went wrong.

 

[DFF]

Nash isn't a cap dump. He scored 42 goals in 2015. Career year, but he's good for 30+ a year when healthy. .

That's where you went wrong.

15 goals for 7.8M at the tender age of 32. It's going downhill from here on. Other than the one year, he hasnt scored 30 in 5 yrs.

He has negative value...no thank you

 

[Machinehead]

Guy has paced for 30 girls every year since he's a rookie, scores 15 goals once, and that's what he is now.

 

[caymanmew]

15 goals for 7.8M at the tender age of 32. It's going downhill from here on. Other than the one year, he hasnt scored 30 in 5 yrs.

He has negative value...no thank you

Nash goals per 82 games(each season listed)

19
42
47
30
39
42
36
35
30
39
33
44
21

Defiantly a low year and age might be getting to him but we need to see it again to really know. Might of just been a bad season. Either way he is still a 20 goal scorer.

 

[CanadienShark]

Beaulieu, Plekanec, and a second for Nash, McIlrath, and Backlund?

No ****ing thank you

For the Habs:

Plekanec ≥ Nash
Beaulieu > McIlrath
2nd ≤ Backlund

Take out Beaulieu for McIlrath and it's a fine deal for the Habs. As is, I see an emphatic "no." Then again...Bergevin is the manager.

 

[One Winged Angel]

For the Habs:

Plekanec ≥ Nash
Beaulieu > McIlrath
2nd ≤ Backlund

Take out Beaulieu for McIlrath and it's a fine deal for the Habs. As is, I see an emphatic "no." Then again...Bergevin is the manager.

Fine deal for the Habs? It's slanted heavily in their favor at that point. Nash is a far better player than Plekanec. If you called me asking to trade the 2 straight up for each other and I had Nash I'd tell you to go play in traffic.

One year all of a sudden makes a player crap. Love it. Sidney Crosby must be ******* then. Corey Perry and Ryan Getzlaf too.

 

[DropIt]

Flames get bent

 

[Ashasx]

2nd ≤ Backlund

This just goes to show how underrated Backlund is.

A 2nd isn't even close to being equal to Backlund.

 

[ohmyjlord]

This just goes to show how underrated Backlund is.
A 2nd isn't even close to being equal to Backlund.

Well...

Nash is a far better player than Plekanec. If you called me asking to trade the 2 straight up for each other and I had Nash I'd tell you to go play in traffic.

...this just goes to show how underrated Plekanec is.

So where does that leave us ? Cheese sticks anyone ?

 

[Zirakzigil]

Flames get worse after that trade. Zero reason for them to do it.

 

[RangerGuru]

Hard pass and laughable from NYR. Way too much offense out giving 3 good pieces here. Hamilton is nice but not at this expense thanks

 

[Redline]

3 ways never work....in hockey and elsewhere

Oh but they do.

 

[BLNY]

Forget the value, how many times do we have to say that Nash has put NO CANADIAN teams on his list of teams he's willing to accept a trade to?

 

[Johnnybegood13]

Forget the value, how many times do we have to say that Nash has put NO CANADIAN teams on his list of teams he's willing to accept a trade to?

Which tells you he likes paychecks over pressure.

 

[webersshot]

Somehow this is awful for everyone.

 

[Johnnybegood13]

Somehow this is awful for everyone.

No it isn't, Rangers make out like bandits.

 

[CanadienShark]

This just goes to show how underrated Backlund is.

A 2nd isn't even close to being equal to Backlund.

He's somewhere around a late 1st or early 2nd imo.

 

[dashripdot]

Which tells you he likes paychecks over pressure.

Or, simply, he prefers winning.

 

[Ashasx]

He's somewhere around a late 1st or early 2nd imo.

The Flames wouldn't trade him for a mid-1st round pick. He's our strongest defensive player who can put up 45+ points. He's gotten progressively better with each season.

 

[LordNeverLose]

Fine deal for the Habs? It's slanted heavily in their favor at that point. Nash is a far better player than Plekanec. If you called me asking to trade the 2 straight up for each other and I had Nash I'd tell you to go play in traffic.

One year all of a sudden makes a player crap. Love it. Sidney Crosby must be ******* then. Corey Perry and Ryan Getzlaf too.

I don't agree with what you're saying about Nash, but I figured it was just your average homerism. Then I read the bolded. Now I'm convinced you spent the last year under a rock.

Over PPG, Hart finalist, wins the Cup and the Conn Smythe. What a **** season.

 

[Captain Mountain]

Don't really like it from a Montreal perspective, but Calgary gets bent over.

 

[Major Happy*]

Awful for Calgary, wow.

 

[CaptainCrunch67]

Absolutely stupid trade for Calgary. Treliving barks out stop wasting my time and slams down the phone.