Nylander - In round 2 doing his thing.

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates

What do we do with Nylander?

  • Re-sign

  • Trade

  • Let walk


Results are only viewable after voting.
I hate how this is how us Willy stans got our validation.

A complete egg of the core 4 outside of Willy.

Team is done if they move Willy and keep Marner...scores 40 goals and shows up for the playoffs while making less.
Plays PP2, plays with Tavares, who might be a 4th line centre.

Plays with a LW half the speed. Tavares 1/4th the speed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: usernamezrhardtodo
O'Reilly over Nylander on PP2 is same as Thornton over Nylander from what I saw.

What did he do beside putting home a Marner tap in pass. Looked like he was skating in mud and handling grenades on our PP
 
  • Like
Reactions: sunstersun
Willy needs to be signed
His speed won't go away in 7 yrs.

To me he is better than Matthew's

Mathews next contract will be 14 million

We can get 3 or 4 quality players for that price

Example of recent contracts signed
Verhaege 4.1mil
Bennett 4.4 mil
Hyman 5 mil

Stars are great if you have a team
 
Last edited:
LAST on the team in blocked shots and hits for the playoffs, worst plus minus for forwards despite most sheltered zone time.

Great goal last night, liked his effort, proved a spark, but people here are mostly biased fanboys. Perhaps it’s why he’s so controversial.

He’s up and down for me and overall I didn’t like his playoffs.
 
LAST on the team in blocked shots and hits for the playoffs, worst plus minus for forwards despite most sheltered zone time.

Great goal last night, liked his effort, proved a spark, but people here are mostly biased fanboys. Perhaps it’s why he’s so controversial.

He’s up and down for me and overall I didn’t like his playoffs.

Without a hint of irony eh?
 
Nylander's issue is that he is easily the most tradeable relative to his cap-hit.

And that's both a compliment to him as a player and a dig at how poorly our soon-to-be-expired-GM negotiated the other 3 big contracts for our core players.

For that reason, we should probably trade Nylander to re-balance the roster and prospect depth slightly better...

And again, that's nothing to do with Nylander as a player/person.
I don't want to keep guys who shrink in big games and trade the one that doesn't. Marner is the most obvious one IMO
 
I don't want to keep guys who shrink in big games and trade the one that doesn't. Marner is the most obvious one IMO
So by that logic 34 is gone too, because he was the worst of all of them. Name one “big game” he’s done something? I’m just saying.
 
So by that logic 34 is gone too, because he was the worst of all of them. Name one “big game” he’s done something? I’m just saying.
He sucked too and you can check my post history, I called him out more than anyone these last two games.

However, he's still had games where he's been point blank the best player, whereas Marner has had very few of those in the playoffs in his career. Marner's body type unfortunately just doesn't work for playoff hockey either, he gets rubbed out too easily with the additional interference and pressure and doesn't have the elusiveness of someone like Patrick Kane in his prime to get out of it.
 
Nylander's issue is that he is easily the most tradeable relative to his cap-hit.

And that's both a compliment to him as a player and a dig at how poorly our soon-to-be-expired-GM negotiated the other 3 big contracts for our core players.

For that reason, we should probably trade Nylander to re-balance the roster and prospect depth slightly better...

And again, that's nothing to do with Nylander as a player/person.

While that very well may happen, it doesn't correct the issue.

Matthews and marner are not taking a pay cut, and Tavares isn't going anywhere.
 
LAST on the team in blocked shots and hits for the playoffs, worst plus minus for forwards despite most sheltered zone time.

Great goal last night, liked his effort, proved a spark, but people here are mostly biased fanboys. Perhaps it’s why he’s so controversial.

He’s up and down for me and overall I didn’t like his playoffs.
He's the only leaf I trusted with the puck on his stick. Even when Marner, Matthews or Oreilly had the puck there was a decent chance of a neutral zone or done turnover but with Willy he at least got it into the ozone first.
 
So by that logic 34 is gone too, because he was the worst of all of them. Name one “big game” he’s done something? I’m just saying.
I just don't think AM or MM have it in them to be both leaders of a team (as their most important players) and be able to elevate their games. If they go to another team with a good culture in place and they don't have to be the focal point...yes I can see them winning something...but it will not happen here. The well is spoiled for them here IMO. Mitch is going to want the moon on his next deal from us...let him and AM get their money elsewhere.
 
Also I don't ever want to hear bitching about him in the regular season ever again. We obsessed over regular season performance for 7 years and come playoff time it meant nothing when the regular season heroes always disappeared. Fans and media were ruthless with Morgan Rielly this year and yet he was our playoff MVP. f*** off with that regular season bullshit.
 
So by that logic 34 is gone too, because he was the worst of all of them. Name one “big game” he’s done something? I’m just saying.

#1
SCF 31
HDCF 16
Takeaway 7
Hit 19
Shot blocked 11
#2
SCF 27
HdCF 21
Takeaway 4
Hit 13
Blicked shot 3
#3
SCF 17
HDCF 9
takeaway 2
Hit 1
Shot blocked 0
#4
SCF10
HDCF 3
Takeaway 5
Hit 13
Blocked shot 3

Stats from top 4 without any name on anybody

Best player was easily by far #1
Second is #2
Third best player #3
Worst #4

Lets find whos is #1,2, 3 and 4...
 
#1
SCF 31
HDCF 16
Takeaway 7
Hit 19
Shot blocked 11
#2
SCF 27
HdCF 21
Takeaway 4
Hit 13
Blicked shot 3
#3
SCF 17
HDCF 9
takeaway 2
Hit 1
Shot blocked 0
#4
SCF10
HDCF 3
Takeaway 5
Hit 13
Blocked shot 3

Stats from top 4 without any name on anybody

Best player was easily by far #1
Second is #2
Third best player #3
Worst #4

Lets find whos is #1,2, 3 and 4...
I have the hardest time giving a f*** about any of those stats when he put up goose eggs on the score board yet again. I can't take that bullshit anymore, you can't make excuses for your highest paid player not producing ANYTHING in an entire f***ing series.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad