I'm really not sure who considers MacKinnon to be great defensively. I thought it was common knowledge that he is an offensive forward. I don't think there's been any time when he was considered a great defensive center or a Selke candidate.
Nikita Kucherov is the clear favorite for the Art Ross Trophy
- Thread starter ViD
- Start date
- Status
Buck Naked
Can't-Stand-Ya
- Aug 18, 2016
- 3,943
- 6,079
A lot of people assume that MacKinnon is great defensively based on the way he plays.
All you can do is laugh, it's ridiculous. He's the best player since Mario.
No offense to the other guys, but if McDavid wasn't playing with what was probably a torn hip flexor or torn ab muscle for like a month+, this isn't even a race.
It's ridiculous too because by his standards I still don't think McDavid is having some kind of great season. Shooting percentage is his lowest since his first full year in the league (16-17), that's generally a tell tale sign of a bad season for most players.
Breakfast of Champs
Registered User
- Apr 15, 2007
- 3,055
- 3,163
at this point it does seem like a foregone conclusion he will win the Art Ross. Its basically a 10 game stretch to win the AR on a relatively even playing field between the 3. In normal circumstances you would be dumb not to pick McDavid. Given his slow start and apparent injury earlier this season, and subsequent climb to the top despite this - it would be even dumber.
Now I'm not saying its impossible for the others, but I would say McDavid should be pegged at about 80% to take this. History would tell us so, and the current situation would tell us so. The fact that there's a good chance he puts up 140+ again is pretty crazy. He has 11 games to go and he has 25 pts in his last 11. If he replicated that he would finish with 147 in 80 games. Its doable.
I don't think he'll win because I suspect the Oilers will rest him and Draisaitl a few of their games. Maybe not, but they have a condensed schedule (thanks NHL schedule makers) for no real great reason down the stretch.
Still I think even by overtaking MacKinnon and Kucherov this late in the season in PPG proves a point if any had to be made ... even in "dream/career/all the stars are aligning for me!" seasons for those guys, McDavid can just step on the gas a bit and go above those guys.
Dude is an alien, what else can you say.
Frosty415
Registered User
He did the same thing last year and disappeared when McD hit 150+
RussianGuyovich
Hella Ennui
- Jan 2, 2007
- 9,957
- 8,333
I agree. It’s going to be great when kucherov wins it and you cry about this all summer. Lmao.
I imagine mcd has probably had his foot on the gas all season just based on common sense.
Having watched almost every game McDavid has played this year, I'd say no. It doesn't really feel like he's had his foot on the gas pedal. He was definitely playing seriously injured for a good 4-5 weeks of the season.
Shooting percentage is down, last year was "foot down on the gas pedal" kind of year for him, this year feels like below that, not shooting as much with a poor percentage too. Oilers PP is not as good this year as last year, etc. etc.
Yet, he's still on pace for like 145 points, what can you say.
Hockey Outsider
Registered User
- Jan 16, 2005
- 9,438
- 15,597
I'm not going to post a full update so soon. But after last night, based on my model, McDavid has emerged as the favourite for the Art Ross.
As of today, the probabilities are 57% for McDavid, 36% for Kucherov, and 17% for MacKinnon. If you go back to my original post on March 10th, McDavid was only at 37%. Since then, he's scored 19 points in 8 games (Kucherov scored 17 in 7, and MacKinnon has cooled off, scoring 12 in 8).
Two important caveats - first, this model works best over large sample sizes. It doesn't take into account the difficulty of a player's schedule. Over the course of an entire season, the differences are trivial. However, now that we're down to the final few weeks, this could impact the race for the Art Ross. To the extent that these three players are playing schedules that are wildly different in terms of difficulty, this hasn't been taken into account.
Second, in the event of a tie, McDavid would lose the Art Ross to either Kucherov or MacKinnon due to fewer goals. Checking the math, it's accurate to say that he has a 57% chance of leading the league in points (tied or outright). Of those outcomes, he really has a 49% chance of winning the Art Ross (ie leading the league in points outright), and a 7% chance of losing the tiebreaker (ie tying for the lead in points with Kucherov and/or MacKinnon, but technically losing the Art Ross). This could be the 4th time in NHL history that someone loses the Art Ross on this technicality (the others are Wayne Gretzky, Eric Lindros, and Andy Bathgate).
Last edited:
I was comparing Kucherov and MacKinnon, not McDavid and MacKinnon.
Also, 3 year weighted cards are irrelevant to a discussion on the Hart this year, and other sources have MacKinnon considerably better than that.
JFresh’s numbers also make no sense considering basic things like xGA are strong for MacKinnon. I also question if they even include this year considering the years listed are 20-21, 21-22, then 22-24. Seems like something is off. And considering this is the evolving hockey data for last year, which coincides with the JFresh chart, I’m assuming none of that is this year or it was very early in the year and combined with last year.
And for reference, this is McDavid and Kucherov this year
Last edited:
Tbh he's already lost a step to some extent, he doesn't have near as many explosive rushes as he used too. His game is way more predicated around cycling right now and he is having the best defensive season of his career. There's a reason he's among the top of the league in basically every possession stat this year.
Golden_Jet
Registered User
- Sep 21, 2005
- 25,943
- 13,382
It’s one of those things where you start to wonder what the limit is exactly. Like if he was never hurt and the PP was rolling like last year. Could he hit 165 if everything went right?
Yes, with both numbers being low. MacKinnon is in the top 1/3 of the 214 forwards with at least 800 5v5 minutes in both xGA/60 and relxGA/60. There’s nothing in the traditional numbers that would suggest MacKinnon would have a bad defensive rating this year like that chart suggested. I’m assuming the “22-24” year listed was likely combining both seasons early in this year, which would negatively influence it by last year’s numbers, which weren’t very good.
MacKinnon isn’t some great defensive player, but I think he’s been stronger on the back check this year and he’s been so good offensively and in possession I think teams are on their heels and he’s been limiting chances against as a solid rate this year, and better than in the past two years.
Last edited:
archangel2
Registered User
- May 19, 2019
- 2,733
- 1,711
Let's be honest, he's winning the Art Ross again unless he gets injured.
McDavid is a scoring title or two away from taking a temporary hiatus to play some random sport like Baseball for a year.
McDavid is a scoring title or two away from taking a temporary hiatus to play some random sport like Baseball for a year.
PuckG
Registered User
- Feb 26, 2015
- 4,337
- 6,158
A lot of people also just take whoever is being compared to McDavid and automatically award them defensive prowess that they don’t have. It’s one of the way people try to narrow the gap.
That entire exchange was made up though because the poster assumed McDavid was being compared to and then used charts that aren’t relevant to this year.
PuckG
Registered User
- Feb 26, 2015
- 4,337
- 6,158
Fair enough, but I think my point still stands. The automatic bonus with any player being compared to McDavid is “defence.” This is in spite of McDavid playing well defensively for quite some time and most of the time, the comparable is not better.
I think that’s starting to turn though as well, at least to current competition, in part because the offense is too strong and because his underlying numbers have been good for awhile. It’s mostly just the random “will never win if he doesn’t play defense” and the “Crosby was more complete” crowd.
McFlyingV
Registered User
Mike Gartner put up the fastest skater at the all-star game in 1996 at the age of 37, a record that lasted 20 years until 2016. I think McDavid will be ok if he remains healthy lol.
McDavid is just a machine. Outside of a month or so in 21/22 and the first 16 games this season when he was clearly injured he's been chugging along at a 150+ point pace for almost 4 years now.
McFlyingV
Registered User
Canadian division, weak pacific division, he gets to play with another hart trophy winner, 2nd assist merchant, power play merchant, 3on3 merchant. You want me to keep going?
HabsQC
Registered User
VainGretzky
Registered User
- Jun 4, 2015
- 14,024
- 12,725
When Mcdavid loses a step he will be a Joe Thornton in his prime comparable
- Status
