According to NHL.com no one has more 1st stars of the week to today. Same is true for 2nd star of the week. This is an excellent barometer for the Hart.
Nikita Kucherov is the clear favorite for the Art Ross Trophy
- Thread starter ViD
- Start date
- Status
Stammertime91
TBL: TEAM OF THE CENTURY
Lol and he's back with more crayons and charts in his post. Still trying to lead people to believe Kucherov doesn't score against tough opponents. Delusional.
CupsOverCash
Registered User
- Jun 16, 2009
- 16,531
- 7,297
People hating kuch what's new. Watch them hate kuch so much they give the mvp to mak. Look at the gap in players on the same team and ask who is the most valuable player on their team. Maybe it should go to who is due or most likeable? What say everyone about that take?
nightonthesun
Registered User
There are people here who think that if Mack wins the hart it’s because the voters are all HF-style internet haters. And I think that’s funny
WarriorofTime
Registered User
- Jul 3, 2010
- 31,193
- 20,111
MacKinnon intangibly lead his team to third in the division so that's gotta get some consideration and lost some faceoffs because the fact that he takes faceoffs automatically makes him better, plus he's a nice boy that's waited patiently and is from the same hometown as Crosby.
Stammertime91
TBL: TEAM OF THE CENTURY
No. As a lightning fan I believe MacKinnon has a legitimate shot. It can go either way.
The problem myself and a lot of lightning fans have is that (I'm sure Edmonton fans can relate), is that when X player is leading, statistics come flying out of the ass to discredit that player. Equal measures aren't used.
This thread has people claiming there's an East coast bias, empty net points shouldn't count, PP points help him, too many secondary assists, and now because he isn't scoring with X amount of time on the clock when the score is a certain stat line.
Additionally, a poster the other day said on the very same day MacKinnon went pointless, that Kucherov going pointless helps MacKinnon. Lol.
MacKinnon has a legit shot, but it's not for these cherry picked, 3 IQ arguments people are making fudging stats and logic.
nightonthesun
Registered User
my post certainly doesn’t refer to you; I thoroughly agree with everything you wrote
… assuming we’re talking about arguments made by both fanbases. Everyone’s been in the weeds
Stammertime91
TBL: TEAM OF THE CENTURY
Yeah, I'm just highlighting that it's not the fact that we think he doesn't have a shot. We just don't think these reasons are logical.
Agreed!
EmptyNetAssassin
Registered User
He isn't lucky enough to play the mighty and feared sharks,ducks, and coyotes multiple times a year. Must be tough to not put up a lot of points against cupcakes like that
Buffalo and Mtl Look like cup contenders compared to those dominant franchises.
RussianGuyovich
Hella Ennui
- Jan 2, 2007
- 9,939
- 8,328
The best part about posting in this thread is not caring at all who wins the hart.
EmptyNetAssassin
Registered User
Nick kuche from Canada
. He has a higher ppg at 5v5 and more pp points then mack.
EmptyNetAssassin
Registered User
Added another one to pad his stats. Does the assist count since a canadian scored it 5v5?
Nathaniel Skywalker
DIG IN!!! RiGHT NOW!!!
- Oct 18, 2013
- 14,211
- 5,852
MacGinnon. Always runner up. Never a winner.
He's the Claude Giroux of his generation. Nothing wrong with being a fine player. But can't keep up with the big boys.
He's the Claude Giroux of his generation. Nothing wrong with being a fine player. But can't keep up with the big boys.
Winston Butterworth
Registered User
I'm an Oiler fan and obviously cheer for McDavid. Seeing what Kuch has done this year , he's got my vote . 100 assists coming as a topper. Impressive season.
Last edited:
hamzarocks
Registered User
Hes the 2nd or 3rd best player since 17/18
Kucherov is marginally better this year while Mackinnon was significantly better last year
Giroux wasnt anywhere near as consistent as Mackinnon or as impactful at his peak outside of maybe 2012
Mackinnon has 4 years better than Giroux 2012 (2018, 2020, 2023, and 2024)
Last edited:
RussianGuyovich
Hella Ennui
- Jan 2, 2007
- 9,939
- 8,328
hamzarocks
Registered User
Naw I give kucherov the slight edge
He should sweep the awards
1. Kuch
2. Mack
3. Mcdavid
4. Matthews
5. Panarin
6. Pasta
Top 6 players this year
Last edited:
- Apr 20, 2016
- 5,911
- 6,947
If you actually look at goals allowed by team, It's actually got a ton of parity in East vs West teams. It goes Sharks, Jackets, Ducks, Devils, Hawks, Habs, Sens and then Coyotes. When it comes to teams giving up points, it's not automatically the bad teams doing it (Hi New Jersey!)
Nathaniel Skywalker
DIG IN!!! RiGHT NOW!!!
- Oct 18, 2013
- 14,211
- 5,852
Literally tough to watch. Literally an nhl team vs an echl. Embarrasing that the NHL actually allows a team like this to be iced
- Status
