Item No. 1: A new day
Two worlds collided Saturday in Columbus in a way many locals never imagined.
Script Ohio was formed in the middle of Ohio Stadium, but in a hockey rink, not on a football field. A crowd of nearly 95,000 chanted “Johnny Hockey” one minute and sang “Hang On, Sloopy” the next. The Ohio State University’s championship football team was honored in the middle of a hockey game.
And in the afterglow of the Blue Jackets’ 5-3 win over the Detroit Red Wings in the NHL’s latest Stadium Series game, the band played and the crowd sang “Carmen Ohio,” Ohio State’s alma mater.
Most of those fortunate enough to attend the NHL’s 43rd outdoor game seemed almost to float out of chilly Ohio Stadium late in the evening Saturday, convinced that they’d witnessed one of the truly unique and memorable nights in the long sporting history of Columbus.
Maybe some were wondering, too, if this is the beginning of a new day in Ohio’s biggest city, one in which Columbus’ major sports franchises do more than simply co-exist, but start working on ways to support and elevate each other.
It hasn’t always been that way.
When the Blue Jackets first arrived on the scene in 2000, Ohio State acted like a big brother who never really wanted a sibling. If not for Blue Jackets founder John H. McConnell, who pushed to build Nationwide Arena beginning in 1998, the Jackets would have played in Schottenstein Center and lived under OSU’s thumb.
Even though Nationwide Arena and Ohio Stadium are barely three miles apart, the Blue Jackets and Ohio State existed in almost separate universes during the early years of the Blue Jackets.
This has never made sense, of course. Fans in Detroit have no issue cheering for the Red Wings, Tigers and Lions and either Michigan or Michigan State. Fans in Boston support the Red Sox, Bruins, Patriots and either Boston U. or Boston College.
Too often, fans in Columbus have been placed in different buckets, in which they either cheer for Ohio State or the Blue Jackets or the Columbus Crew, one of Major League Soccer’s top organizations. In fact, that’s never been true. The vast majority of fans have no issue supporting all three.
For fans of certain age, Columbus had a certain sporting hierarchy for most of their lives. The block ‘O’ of Ohio State loomed large above the local sporting scene, with the Blue Jackets and Columbus Crew fighting to be seen in the periphery.
It’s too big to be acting that way.
This is a surprise to many, even locals, but Columbus is Ohio’s largest city, with 913,000 residents, according to the latest U.S. Census. It’s bigger than the combined populations of Ohio’s better-known big cities Cleveland (362,000) and Cincinnati (311,000) by nearly a quarter-million residents.
Judging by online comments on this site and others, there were some Blue Jackets fans who felt as if Saturday’s game had too much of an Ohio State touch.
I’m sure there are Ohio State fans who weren’t too excited to have an NHL game played in “their” stadium, especially one featuring a Columbus dressed in blue and the Michigan team wearing red. (Hey, at least it wasn’t scarlet!)
Each of those opinions are valid, but both of them, I believe, are in the minority. Sports, like politics, can make for strange bedfellows. Most fans, especially those 30 and younger, see Ohio State sports, the Blue Jackets and the Crew as existing on even footing.
Most on hand for Saturday’s festivities seemed to stand in awe of the scene and the atmosphere, the perfect melding of the city’s two biggest sports franchises.
Saturday’s game probably wouldn’t have happened if not for key developments at Ohio State and in college athletics, specifically football. The expanded college football playoffs, now at 12 teams, requires universities to host opening-round games, meaning teams (especially in the north) needed to get their buildings ready for winter. Ohio State took steps to winterize Ohio Stadium — the tune of $8 million — in the event that it hosted a game.
And wouldn’t you know, they hosted Tennessee in a first-round game on Dec. 21. Before the grand old stadium was winterized, the water would have been shut off by that date, leaving it unable to host events such as an outdoor hockey game.
It’s likely that Ohio State president Ted Carter (an avid hockey fan) and new athletic director Ross Bjork will signal a change in the future relationship, too.
There were minor quibbles behind the scenes of Saturday’s events.
An NHL executive told The Athletic that Ohio State at first resisted allowing the league to refer to the game as “the” Stadium Series because OSU has trademarked “THE” on clothing and other branded products.
The school also wouldn’t allow Blue Jackets goaltender Elvis Merzlikins to put buckeye leaves on his helmet, and they wouldn’t allow the NHL to use its name for the pre-game football pep rallies — Skull Session — to promote its own pep rally in St. John Arena.
But to get stuck on these details is to ignore the big one: Ohio State opened up its grand stage, the largest stadium in Ohio and one of the largest in the country, so that the Blue Jackets and the NHL could have a celebration. Saturday is a night many will remember forever.
In the minutes after the Blue Jackets clinched the win and the cannon blasted for a final time, fans filed out of Ohio Stadium singing “We Don’t Give A Damn for the Whole State of Michigan,” just as they do on football Saturdays.
Except this time they wore Blue Jackets sweaters.