Assuming you're talking about the list on Page 1, I made that list probably about 6 years ago haha. If I was to update the BBQ section, Hometown BBQ would be absoultely #1, no doubt about it. Honestly SO many things on the list are outdated or have closed. John Brown's was on there as my favorite BBQ place in Queens, it recently closed due to the pandemic.
I'd love to make an updated list for this thread when I have the time, maybe a longer one since I have 6 additional years of NYC dining experience now. But honestly I should probably wait to make the list until after things get back to normal a bit, never know how many more places will end up closed