Proposal: Necas <CAR> for Chytil and Robertson <NYR>
- Thread starter FoxysExpensiveNYDigs
- Start date
TheDoldrums
Registered User
Rangers have a Robertson? This family is out of control
- Sep 20, 2007
- 7,614
- 11,297
This is like the canes offering Jalen Chatfield for Adam Fox
The rumor around the draft involved 4OA; this was a Friedman intel. Chytil, even ignoring his concussion risk, is not in the same value tier. A prospect like Robertson, who has no path to a regular role in Carolina, does not bridge the gap. It’s not close.
It really isn't even close to a comparison. But yes, this offer isnt close.
FoxysExpensiveNYDigs
Boo Nieves Truther
Did no one read the added pick part?
There would definitely have to be concession for Chytil's injury history. Not a fit I guess.
One is a Norris winner, the other is Jalen Chatfield.
There would definitely have to be concession for Chytil's injury history. Not a fit I guess.
Robertson has zero value, what pick will you add
- Sep 20, 2007
- 7,614
- 11,297
Yea...unfortunately I don't think Chytil has much value, if at all with the injury history. If he gets a healthy season under him, maybe he'll get back there. Right now I think it would be very difficult to trade him for any value. I think Necas has tremendous value.
FoxysExpensiveNYDigs
Boo Nieves Truther
Nobody was offering 4th overall for Marty f***ing Necas
- Apr 27, 2005
- 35,398
- 34,146
Here's the receipt:
~15:15
"I do think there were very serious conversations between Columbus and Carolina about the #4 pick. I do think that the Hurricanes…” (he meant Jackets) “…made Necas a contract offer with permission of the Hurricanes. Obviously, it didn’t get done.”
It's a good bet that the Canes were adding to him, but logically he was the primary piece in the talks.
I assume that was the Canes ask and was turned down
I'm going to call bullshit.
Either that or both the Columbus and Carolina GMs are incredibly stupid and should be fired
Columbus for being dumb enough to offer 4th, and Carolina for being dumb enough not to take it and add whatever else it took to get it done.
SingnBluesOnBroadway
Retired
Not going to comment on the value of your offer, but the Rangers have traded a lot of picks over the last few seasons....
spockBokk
Registered User
- Sep 8, 2013
- 7,493
- 18,984
Calling BS after being proven wrong is a strange take.
The trade didn’t go through because Necas wouldn’t sign with the Blue Jackets.
~35:00
Per Seravalli, Necas wouldn't sign an extension in Columbus and the deal (for 4OA) died as a result.
Prairie Habs
Registered User
- Oct 3, 2010
- 12,276
- 13,424
A rumour doesn't really prove anything, though. Teams use rumours in the media to try and inflate trade value all the time.
Waddell knows Necas really well obviously. His skating and ability to make plays at that high pace is quite rare. Fans/pundits just see his statline, but that was surpressed by PP usage. If Waddell sees him as a PPG type in a different situation, it's not unfathomable. The contract presumably would have been long-term starting at 25.
- Oct 31, 2007
- 40,716
- 47,545
Apparently the deal revolves around Necas and the 4th overall, but it never came into fruition because Necas wouldn’t sign a new contract with the Jackets.
A similar rumor came around about a week ago, with Necas and Ehlers as the center pieces, but again, Necas apparently wouldn’t sign a new contract with the Jets, so it fell through.
A similar rumor came around about a week ago, with Necas and Ehlers as the center pieces, but again, Necas apparently wouldn’t sign a new contract with the Jets, so it fell through.
spockBokk
Registered User
- Sep 8, 2013
- 7,493
- 18,984
I wouldn’t put any stock into what that Hasbullcane-whatever account says.
- Nov 2, 2011
- 7,766
- 7,850
Not even commenting on the proposal, or why Carolina would never trade with the Rangers outside of an overpay while both are division leaders
Necas being rumored for mega high value pieces like the 4th overall only comes out because the Carolina front office wants to leak that to try to drive value. No one from Columbus is leaking that they almost got a deal done but didn't.
The fact is, the deal didn't get done, so what we know for sure is what he isn't worth.
Necas being rumored for mega high value pieces like the 4th overall only comes out because the Carolina front office wants to leak that to try to drive value. No one from Columbus is leaking that they almost got a deal done but didn't.
The fact is, the deal didn't get done, so what we know for sure is what he isn't worth.
- Oct 31, 2007
- 40,716
- 47,545
The deal didn’t get done because Necas wouldn’t sign a new contract. So what we know for sure is an unsigned Necas isn’t worth a 4th overall, which we already knew.
