I don’t see the reasoning for Montreal here. I suspect Habs brass value two high 2nd second over a late first. Also, I wish Amirov a speedy recovery and a long and healthy life but I doubt Montreal has the luxury of taking that kind of risk over a player (human) which has a brain tumor. We are also not in a hurry to shed contracts/salary. We can keep Hoffman until he expires.
Proposal: MTL & TOR
- Thread starter Lockin17
- Start date
He’s not the leafs best prospect nor was he ever better then Robertson. He also has a brain tumour and is in the middle of Chemo highly doubt any team values him.
Bouboumaster
Registered User
- Jul 4, 2014
- 10,395
- 8,640
The90
Registered User
- Feb 27, 2017
- 6,126
- 4,876
Not emotionally tied, then posts I want 2 2nd’s and a B prospect. AKA a first +.
Ehhh, I dunno. Muzzin has been quite good for us the past couple seasons but has had obvious injury issues. Rielly also tends to elevate his game in the playoffs but his strengths are more so in terms of transition d (I won't argue that he's as good in the d zone, boards, or net front). And iirc Brodie was pretty good last year too
Spargon
Registered User
- May 31, 2019
- 1,015
- 1,663
Fan bickering aside, these 2 teams do not make trades of significance with each other, period, full stop. Check the history, I think the last trade of any relevance was Plekanec? and then it was Grabovski in 2008 and he was kind of a reclamation project at the time
thusk
Registered User
Thats probably why toronto outplayed montreal in every aspect of the game except 1...
Montreal won because one 1 of 3 best performance by a goalie during last 30 years. ( with Patrick roy in 1993 and js giguere in 2003). The team in front was not better than the team who finished the season at 18th in the NHL. It is what it is
Leafs fans know that lol, no matter what they say. Habs top-4 crushed them. Let them keep doing what they’re doing. I rather enjoy watching them get rag-dolled out of the first round year after year.
HuGo Burner Acc
Registered User
- Mar 30, 2016
- 4,682
- 5,304
Nah keep Hoffman and flip him next trade deadline for a better price (hopefully he performs well next year tho)
Also try to trade chiarot to the Rangers or something. Toronto low-key knows that their 1st will not be too low as they'll lose yet again in round one of the PO
Also try to trade chiarot to the Rangers or something. Toronto low-key knows that their 1st will not be too low as they'll lose yet again in round one of the PO
Suave
Registered User
- Feb 9, 2022
- 16
- 5
We do agree on the later part, he's at best a top4 dman. My point was that he would be in your starting lineup in the playoffs and it's not even close, do they need him - I don't think so, but still my point remains. If you disagree, we can agree to disagree and it's alright friend.
And, YES I'd take Chariot before Muzzin in a heartbeat. On one hand you get Chariot who becomes a UFA at the end of season (+Habs can retain 50% of the salary) and on the other hand, you get the poor Muzzin who got concussed twice in the last month with an awful contract.
Hoffman has negative value with tha contract. To me a more reasonable offer would be to move Chariot for someone like Timothy Lindgren or even straight up for Sandin (who I think is better) but something like that from the leafs, Perhaps Robertson.
I'd do Chariot for a first or Chariot for Lindgren and Robertson.
I'd do Chariot for a first or Chariot for Lindgren and Robertson.
Maybe, not sure its disgustingly bad, but it skews to Montreal. If Chariot is what Toronto needs and if it brings the Cup why not pay? Same division eternal rivals the price has to be high. Would it change if it was one of Robertson or Lindgren?
I'm not actually convinced there is a fit here because Montreal will have to look like they get better value from the Leafs than a West coast team
No...it is. I wouldn't want to deal the 1st for Chiarot....but lets just say Dubas would....Both Liljegren AND Robertson each are worth more to the Leafs than their late 1st....and you think Chiarot gets both?
Last edited:
bigbabybuda
Registered User
Any proposal involving Amirov should just be locked right away, for the time being. He just has been diagnosed with a brain tumor therefore they're unrealistic at this time and frankly its in poor taste to be discussing his trade value at the moment. Be it a Leaf fan proposing them or another team.
No I don't think Chariot gets both. I think Toronto may have to over pay. I'm actually not a fan of Robertson but he seems like an extra young piece Montreal would ask for. I like Lindgren is underused in T.O. and Montreal would be smart to try and pry him away
It's not meant to be rude, it's just logic. Toronto won't be trading a young RHD that they've developed for years, or an upcoming ELC forward with top 6 upside for a rental. Both of those pieces hold more value to the Leafs than their late 1st....and Dubas said he won't be dealing that for a rental.
Not a knock on Chiarot.
Gaston Gingras
Registered User
The Missing Piece
What's Left?
- Sep 19, 2012
- 1,527
- 417
lol that's hilarious i can't believe they bought it.
Would go down as one of worst trades in history
Would go down as one of worst trades in history
Last edited:
i mean, anyone who knows anything about hockey would know that's fake
JustAHabFan
Registered User
- Apr 8, 2008
- 7,774
- 2,798
