Proposal: MTL & SJ

[Treb]

Not really. That's the type of player that the Sharks will likely be targeting moving forward and the only type of player that they'd put anyone with trade value on the table for.

I think the point was that Chernyshov doesn't bring you a Dobson level prospect/player.

 

[Juxtaposer]

I think the point was that Chernyshov doesn't bring you a Dobson level prospect/player.

Obviously not by himself. It would be a package including Chernyshov.

 

[Top cheese Gaz]

Ya change the pieces to Hage and SJ adds a late pick, then it’s better than this proposal, in which Grier passes easily.
The main piece is the SJ piece in the current proposal.

Why would the Habs trade Hage vs Chernyshov + late pick ? i do not think grier would have passes easily on that trade if it was the case.

In any case, Chernyshov is worth more than Bogdan + Strubble. I do not see a team trade a player that they draft two month ago.

Obviously not by himself. It would be a package including Chernyshov.

You're so far of the value. Chernyshov would not be the main piece of the package.

 

[Juxtaposer]

You're so far of the value. Chernyshov would not be the main piece of the package.

Show me where I said Chernyshov would be the main piece of the package, please.

 

[Top cheese Gaz]

Show me where I said Chernyshov would be the main piece of the package, please.

No where.

I just do see why somebody would name a player that is not the main peace in a trade.

I would like Habs to trade for Matthews. Jake Evans would be in the package

 

[Juxtaposer]

No where.

I just do see why somebody would name a player that is not the main peace in a trade.

I would like Habs to trade for Matthews. Jake Evans would be in the package

People say "I would only trade player X in a package for player Y" literally all the time on this forum.

I think you know that.

 

[Pinkfloyd]

I think the point was that Chernyshov doesn't bring you a Dobson level prospect/player.

Which is entirely beside the point of the post that poster was responding to. Nobody said Chernyshov would bring in a Dobson-level prospect/player. All that has been said is that's the only type of asset that they would make him available for. That's a completely different thing to say and not an insane thing as that person claimed.

 

[Spearmint Rhino]

Sharks would be dumb not to make this trade

Habs track record trading D for F is abysmal and you get 2 chances to burn us

 

[Lockin17]

The point is Bodgan and Struble are NHL ready and would make the team this year easily top 4 for SJ.
Chernyshov is a project that could take 3 years to make the NHL, Might end up better might not.
Not saying the Chernyshov dosen't have the potentiel but Bogdan is twice the player playing in the same league at the moment.
And you guy's calling for Hage lolll jezzz get lost

 

[The Devilish Buffoon]

While SJ wont trade a prospect drafted so recently, and the value is still a little off anyways, the “superior forward prospect for two inferior D prospects” dynamic makes some sense for both teams. There are issues with the proposal but the thought behind it shows some insight into team need from both ends

 

[Xirik]

The point is Bodgan and Struble are NHL ready and would make the team this year easily top 4 for SJ.
Chernyshov is a project that could take 3 years to make the NHL, Might end up better might not.
Not saying the Chernyshov dosen't have the potentiel but Bogdan is twice the player playing in the same league at the moment.
And you guy's calling for Hage lolll jezzz get lost

1. Why is SJ needing NHL ready players right away? are they aiming to make the playoffs next season?
2. Chernyshov is one of the closest to ready players in this last draft.

3.



45. Chernyshov
72. Hage

Bogdan where?

 

[hohosaregood]

The point is Bodgan and Struble are NHL ready and would make the team this year easily top 4 for SJ.
Chernyshov is a project that could take 3 years to make the NHL, Might end up better might not.
Not saying the Chernyshov dosen't have the potentiel but Bogdan is twice the player playing in the same league at the moment.
And you guy's calling for Hage lolll jezzz get lost

So why would the Habs want a lesser prospect like Chernyshov when you have 2 NHL ready top 4 defensemen?

 

[Xirik]

So why would the Habs want a lesser prospect like Chernyshov when you have 2 NHL ready top 4 defensemen?

Continuous tank syndrome.

 

[CanadienShark]

While SJ wont trade a prospect drafted so recently, and the value is still a little off anyways, the “superior forward prospect for two inferior D prospects” dynamic makes some sense for both teams. There are issues with the proposal but the thought behind it shows some insight into team need from both ends

No it doesn't. This post shows you don't have insight into the Sharks needs. We need a high end RHD. The Habs have two prospects in that vein and they're obviously not available.

 

[Lockin17]

So why would the Habs want a lesser prospect like Chernyshov when you have 2 NHL ready top 4 defensemen?

Not easy to understand i get it,,, but these guys are not what the Habs need right now but SJ could sure use them right now.

Chernyshov might be a unicor or a burst we don't know.

So Habs are taking a chance giving decent prospects for a *Unicorne*.
OR You guy's think Chenyshov is a God,, allright keep him.

 

[Grinner]

Not easy to understand i get it,,, but these guys are not what the Habs need right now but SJ could sure use them right now.

Chernyshov might be a unicor or a burst we don't know.

So Habs are taking a chance giving decent prospects for a *Unicorne*.
OR You guy's think Chenyshov is a God,, allright keep him.

Get lost indeed

 

[Xirik]

Not easy to understand i get it,,, but these guys are not what the Habs need right now but SJ could sure use them right now.

Chernyshov might be a unicor or a burst we don't know.

So Habs are taking a chance giving decent prospects for a *Unicorne*.
OR You guy's think Chenyshov is a God,, allright keep him.

 

[The Devilish Buffoon]

No it doesn't. This post shows you don't have insight into the Sharks needs. We need a high end RHD. The Habs have two prospects in that vein and they're obviously not available.

Hey, fair enough. I agree that the Sharks primarily need is a high end RD and that they are not going to get one from MTL without giving up a legit top fwd prospect.

That said, I still view SJ’s forward pool better than their D pool as whole. The Habs have an embarassment of riches on the back end and can probably parlay two lesser D into a very good forward prospect. SJ seemed like a team who could potentially take advantage of that, but I’ll tale your word for it that I’m off
about that

 

[MTL Dirty Birdy]

Guy was drafted after Hage for a reason

It would likelly cost a late 2nd to move up from 33 to 21. So itll cost a 2nd for Hage

It cost us more than that to go from 26-21.

 

[Stewie Griffin]

The sharks D pool sucks but it's full of lefties, especially bottom pairing ones like Struble. There is absolutely 0 need for us to make this trade.

 

[Treb]

We're done here.