Proposal: MTL/DET

[mrinsane]

To Montreal: Filip Hronek and Robby Fabbri

Vs

To Detroit : Alex Romanov, Tyler Toffloli and 4th round pick 2023

MTL pov: Hronek is a RHD with some offensive upside and Habs need this badly. Fabbri have a lot of potentiel can play C/LW.

DET Pov: Toffloli can put 30 goals and with Vrana out for many months he can be useful. Romanov have some potential but Habs have many LHD in the pipeline.. Detroit are in rebuild/retool so they dont need to rush him

Click to read more...

 

[Lil Sebastian Cossa]

I don't hate it.

 

[Tatar Shots]

No thanks from Detroit. Detroit is stacked with LHD prospects and needs Hronek

 

[Captain97]

I don't like it but I also don't hate it, so it's probably close to fair.

 

[ThankGord]

Romanov is an interesting piece but Toffoli doesn't do much for the Wings, Raymond has more than covered for Vrana's absence and wing is where we have the most NHL depth. I think if Detroit was to make a move they'd be looking for a top-four LD or top-six C. Our LD prospect pool is already very strong.

 

[Pavels Dog]

I agree that Romanov would be an interesting piece for the Wings, but I don't think it makes any sense for Detroit to give up both Hronek and Fabbri in an attempt to replace Vrana for 3 months.

 

[Hammettf2b]

The last thing the Wings need is a LHD

 

[ThankGord]

The last thing the Wings need is a LHD

...if you're content with DDK playing top-four minutes. Out prospect pool is strong but acquiring an LD would improve the team this season. Don't think we should be buying yet though.

 

[Hammettf2b]

...if you're content with DDK playing top-four minutes. Out prospect pool is strong but acquiring an LD would improve the team this season. Don't think we should be buying yet though.

The Wings aren't going to carry 3 very strong LHD unless you are sure one of them can play the opposite side?

 

[ThankGord]

The Wings aren't going to carry 3 very strong LHD unless you are sure one of them can play the opposite side?

Not sure what you mean. On the left we have Leddy who looks like he belongs in the top-four, then DDK, Staal, and Osterle who hold their own but I'd call them bottom pair guys. Right side is Seider, Hronek, Lindstrom/Stecher.

 

[Hammettf2b]

Not sure what you mean. On the left we have Leddy who looks like he belongs in the top-four, then DDK, Staal, and Osterle who hold their own but I'd call them bottom pair guys. Right side is Seider, Hronek, Lindstrom/Stecher.

oh im mainly talking about the future. Wings have Johannson, Wallinder, McIssac, Edvinsson all on the left hand side. Its not hard to think at least 2 of them will make for decent NHL'ers. If Yzerman is giving up Hronek and Fabbri, I don't think its for a LHD as good as Romanov is.

 

[ThankGord]

oh im mainly talking about the future. Wings have Johannson, Wallinder, McIssac, Edvinsson all on the left hand side. Its not hard to think at least 2 of them will make for decent NHL'ers. If Yzerman is giving up Hronek and Fabbri, I don't think its for a LHD as good as Romanov is.

Ah, sure, I agree. I'd like to leave an opportunity for Edvinsson (maybe McIsaac or Johansson) to jump into the NHL next year. With Leddy, Staal and DDK expiring I think there's still room to acquire a younger, top-four-ready LD.

 

[SuperScript29]

Why da hell would Detroit do this?

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

No thanks, Detroit is stacked with LHD prospects. As of right now Hronek is more of a need then Romanov and Toffoli.

 

[jfhabs]

I'd prefer keeping Romanov. Give him more ice time and see what we got with him. Trust him and coach him, he's a NHL player.
If we're to trade Toffoli I'd expect some futures.
Don't see Detroit wanting to part ways with Hronek either.

 

[Lays]

That would be awful for Montreal

 

[BSHH]

This is a very fair proposal. But I agree, the fit is not ideal for Detroit, since they have a few LD prospects and little need for Toffoli.

Gruß,
BSHH

 

[Dotter]

YOu want Hronek AND Fabbri for that?

 

[Stuzchuk]

I didnt take time to evaluate the needs on either side but at first glance this looks like a fair deal

 

[Tetsuo]

It's not terrible value, and kudos for making the money make sense to an extent, it makes the trade even more realistic. Fabbri is a UFA so getting anything of value out of him in an interesting player like Romanov is gravy. I also don't hate the idea of taking a gamble on Toffoli, he's only got two more years at a pretty reasonable cap hit. The question is the cost of losing Hronek worth it given that in theory he's a .5 PPG RHD and in return we'd be getting another LHD which we have plenty of, and useful depth scoring player, which we do need but not yet - we're still a year away from being a bubble team afterall. I would say that it's still a year too early for us to be making moves like this without a significant future asset attached.

Counter offer: take out Romanov, upgrade the pick to a 2022 or 2023 1st with the condition that if Montreal's pick falls inside the top 10 in 2022, they can defer the pick to 2023.

 

[Hostile Offer]

YOu want Hronek AND Fabbri for that?

We don't really need Fabbri so if that's the dealbreaker then I'd have no issue leaving him out of this.

 

[Habs10025]

To Montreal: Filip Hronek and Robby Fabbri

Vs

To Detroit : Alex Romanov, Tyler Toffloli and 4th round pick 2023

MTL pov: Hronek is a RHD with some offensive upside and Habs need this badly. Fabbri have a lot of potentiel can play C/LW.

DET Pov: Toffloli can put 30 goals and with Vrana out for many months he can be useful. Romanov have some potential but Habs have many LHD in the pipeline.. Detroit are in rebuild/retool so they dont need to rush him

Montreal reject this trade.

 

[glenbuis]

Montreal reject this trade.

i second that .

 

[Zetterberg4Captain]

No thank you

 

[Habs Halifax]

That would be awful for Montreal

Kind of what I was thinking... But because the Habs are overpaying, some fans going to say "I don't hate it"