Value of: Montreal Canadiens Looking to Add Some Grit to Their Defensive Corps/Bottom 6

My3Sons

Nobody told me there'd be days like these...
Sponsor
The guy who was a healthy scratch for us last year and is now blocking your 2OA dman from getting into games? We need to let our young D develop
Kivacevic is playing very well. NJ added him thinking he’d be a seventh guy and he’s playing as well as any defender on the team. I’m sure the NJ staff is as surprised as anyone. NJ is trying to win hence all the off season adds. Nemec will get his turn but NJ is past the point of prioritizing the development of young players over winning. Whether it works out for them we will see.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Spearmint Rhino

Jerzey Devil

Jerzey-Duz-It
Jun 11, 2010
6,013
4,957
St. Augustine, FL
The guy who was a healthy scratch for us last year and is now blocking your 2OA dman from getting into games? We need to let our young D develop
He’s not blocking anything. He outplayed Nemec to earn the spot on the team. That’s straight from the coach’s mouth.

If your young players are developing into a bunch of losers that’s not going to help anyone or anything. Please note I’m not saying any of them are bad but they are collectively one of if not the worst defense in the league right now. Maybe the play the young guys no matter what strategy isn’t a very good one even if the goal is tanking.

I agree but he isn't a top 4 guy.
No but he doesn’t need to be. He isn’t top 4 on the Devils either. He adds grit which is what was being requested in the op.

With Pesce returning it honestly might make sense for the Devils to trade him soon too if he keeps up the good play.
 

Spearmint Rhino

Registered User
Sep 17, 2013
9,307
9,316
He’s not blocking anything. He outplayed Nemec to earn the spot on the team. That’s straight from the coach’s mouth.

If your young players are developing into a bunch of losers that’s not going to help anyone or anything. Please note I’m not saying any of them are bad but they are collectively one of if not the worst defense in the league right now. Maybe the play the young guys no matter what strategy isn’t a very good one even if the goal is tanking.


No but he doesn’t need to be. He isn’t top 4 on the Devils either. He adds grit which is what was being requested in the op.

With Pesce returning it honestly might make sense for the Devils to trade him soon too if he keeps up the good play.
Teams are in different places, at the time of the trade we had 3 RHD with high expectations battling for the one spot, all with a higher ceiling than Kovacevic, not saying better today but in 2 years when we should be starting to compete, so he was never part of the long term plans, Could maybe have got more if they waited or could’ve got nothing if they had to put him on waivers. Unfortunately injuries have hit again and definitely looking more like another tank year which is fine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HabsAddict

Xirik

Registered User
Sep 24, 2014
9,751
14,446
Alberta
Teams are in different places, at the time of the trade we had 3 RHD with high expectations battling for the one spot, all with a higher ceiling than Kovacevic, not saying better today but in 2 years when we should be starting to compete, so he was never part of the long term plans, Could maybe have got more if they waited or could’ve got nothing if they had to put him on waivers. Unfortunately injuries have hit again and definitely looking more like another tank year which is fine.
Did Savard look better then Kovacevic last year? I struggle to see why he was kept instead of Kovy. Yeah Savard is older and a "veteran" but I'd think Skill > Veteran is more logical.
 

Spearmint Rhino

Registered User
Sep 17, 2013
9,307
9,316
Did Savard look better than Kovacevic last year? I struggle to see why he was kept instead of Kovy. Yeah Savard is older and a "veteran" but I'd think Skill > Veteran is more logical.
Savard played very well last year, has been brutal this year. Think the thought was good. Veteran presence for most of the season and a trade chip at the deadline, wouldn’t have much value with his current play unless there’s an extreme shortage of RHD on the market.
 

General Fanager

Registered User
Feb 2, 2010
12,017
3,723
Chambly, Qc
He’s not blocking anything. He outplayed Nemec to earn the spot on the team. That’s straight from the coach’s mouth.

If your young players are developing into a bunch of losers that’s not going to help anyone or anything. Please note I’m not saying any of them are bad but they are collectively one of if not the worst defense in the league right now. Maybe the play the young guys no matter what strategy isn’t a very good one even if the goal is tanking.


No but he doesn’t need to be. He isn’t top 4 on the Devils either. He adds grit which is what was being requested in the op.

With Pesce returning it honestly might make sense for the Devils to trade him soon too if he keeps up the good play.
Yea I get it but I think there is enough grit on the D. A top 4 RHD is a far more pressing need. One with about 2 years left on his deal. That would give time for Mailloux and Reinbacher time to develop. I think the grit is more needed in the bottom 6.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad