notDatsyuk
Registered User
- Jul 20, 2018
- 11,982
- 10,152
If you think Rielly and Tavares haven't been getting their fair share of criticism, you haven't been reading enough threads.I'd argue some of that had to do with Marner being targeted by Babcock. Mitch and his camp were under the expectation that the Leafs would be retaining Babcock's services until 2023 after the guy had signed a first of its kind 8-year $50M contract. The incident in his rookie season, where he was tasked with ranking his teammates' work ethic, is something that could have turned him into a pariah and also something that doesn't seem like an isolated incident either. Unlike Keefe, Babcock rarely gave Marner and Matthews ice time together and I'm assuming that aforementioned ego / lack of humility really got in the way of contract negotiations ala "if he (Babcock) stays here, I'm gonna ask for a million more" or something to that effect.
I also agree with Marner being a terrible leader, but I don't think it's just him. The longest tenured defender on the team frequently escapes criticism, and Tavares's lack of anything resembling emotion is readily brushed aside, while key guys outside of the core like Brodie and Kampf have had some of the worst seasons wearing the blue and white. Zilch from this group.
I'm hoping Berube is a breath of fresh air and is able to knock Marner down a peg or two to get him more focused on hockey and less on the discourse outside of the rink.
The difference is that Rielly, like Nylander, has been making about one third less than Marner, and Tavares will be looking for a small fraction of what Marner will be looking for on their next contracts.
If you're making or expecting to make that much more, and your performance isn't in line, you deserve more criticism.