Speculation: Matthews to California team for two 1sts?

[Cas]

Misa and the 3 firsts.

A phenomenally stupid price to pay. By the time the Sharks would be ready to compete (having no defense worth the name), Matthews will be departing in free agency.

You can keep Matthews, as an asset going forward he's not worth the price.

 

[Patty Ice]

Misa+2+9+27?

Friday can't come soon enough.

 

[OVO16]

Auston Matthews is worth a hell lot more then just two firsts

 

[Patty Ice]

Auston Matthews is worth a hell lot more then just two firsts

Yes. I encourage Leafs fans to hold off on their proposals.

 

[Warh1ppy]

Agreed, not close.

But would you do

Misa
2nd
9th
27th

2021/2022 Matthews, might be up for consideration.

2026 Matthews with a leg injury after calling everyone else on his team a "passenger" without taking ownership for his own failures not so much

 

[SanJoseRedditor]

Sharks are fine at F and desperately need D and D prospects.

So SJ should trade Misa+2+9 for Matthews???? Math doesn't add up here.

 

[AcerComputer]

Sharks are fine at F and desperately need D and D prospects.

So SJ should trade Misa+2+9 for Matthews???? Math doesn't add up here.

Should have traded for Byram then

 

[Juxtaposer]

No easier way to get clicks then to dangle the Sharks assets to Leafs fans desperate to rebuild in a single year.

Should have traded for Byram then

You know it’s not an either-or scenario, right? You don’t need either Matthews or Byram.

 

[Grinner]

Should have traded for Byram then

Seeing what Buffalo did get for him
No thanks

 

[TheRumble]

Michael Misa isn't even that good of a prospect. How good are you if you were drafted 2nd overall and had to be sent down to the minors your first season? He's Nico Hischier level at best - which is a great player, but fans overrate the value of unmet potential.

Matthews as a rookie in a lower scoring era with Connor Brown and Zach Hyman as his linemmates scored 40 goals and finished tied for second in the Rocket race.

 

[Stephen]

How credible is this guy?

He’s a funeral director nowadays.

 

[A1LeafNation]

So Leafs trade and sign 29 year old Raddysh long term only to sell 28 year old Matthews days later.

HFboards at its best folks.

 

[lanceuppercut75]

Should have traded for Byram then

They can (if they want) draft Chase Reid at 2 and Daxon Rudolph at 9.

Mike Grier has said he isn't interested in rushing the rebuild. If those kids take 3 or 4 years, then so be it.

 

[Cas]

Michael Misa isn't even that good of a prospect. How good are you if you were drafted 2nd overall and had to be sent down to the minors your first season? He's Nico Hischier level at best - which is a great player, but fans overrate the value of unmet potential.

Matthews as a rookie in a lower scoring era with Connor Brown and Zach Hyman as his linemmates scored 40 goals and finished tied for second in the Rocket race.

Misa was sent down to the minors on a rehab assignment.

No one would be trading for rookie Matthews, they'd be trading for 30's Matthews, who is likely to be worse going forward than a Nico Hishier-level prime.

 

[KevinRedkey]

Michael Misa isn't even that good of a prospect. How good are you if you were drafted 2nd overall and had to be sent down to the minors your first season? He's Nico Hischier level at best - which is a great player, but fans overrate the value of unmet potential.

Matthews as a rookie in a lower scoring era with Connor Brown and Zach Hyman as his linemmates scored 40 goals and finished tied for second in the Rocket race.

No one cares what Matthews did as a Rookie anymore. It's irrelevant now.

 

[TheRumble]

No one cares what Matthews did as a Rookie anymore. It's irrelevant now.

Matthews at 45% is better than Hischier at 253% which is better than the theoretical ceiling of Michael Misa which is 89% of that.

The numbers don't lie.

 

[themelkman]

Im sure he will do great on the Kings. The sharks arent picking this call up

 

[Grinner]

Matthews at 45% is better than Hischier at 253% which is better than the theoretical ceiling of Michael Misa which is 89% of that.

The numbers don't lie.

I think your abacus is off

 

[Pinkfloyd]

Why would the Sharks trade anything of value for Matthews when they have Celebrini and Misa? They need to swing for a top defenseman or stick to building through the draft. Matthews can let his contract expire and come here if he wants to bad enough.

 

[sd1976]

No one cares what Matthews did as a Rookie anymore. It's irrelevant now.

Yeah, because since then he’s become a generational goal scorer behind on 3 guys in the history of the sport. And ahead of Ovechkin.

 

[Mattb124]

Matthews at 45% is better than Hischier at 253% which is better than the theoretical ceiling of Michael Misa which is 89% of that.

The numbers don't lie.

Does the hypothetical trade some with a time machine?

 

[one2gamble]

Why would the Sharks trade anything of value for Matthews when they have Celebrini and Misa?

They won't and likely didn't, smells like LA

 

[ashs]

Matthews scores 40 goals in his sleep. A healthy motivated Matthews with a new coach and he's back to 60 goals. Find anyone who can do that, u can't. So go enjoy misa and his 9 goals.

 

[Grinner]

Matthews scores 40 goals in his sleep. A healthy motivated Matthews with a new coach and he's back to 60 goals. Find anyone who can do that, u can't. So go enjoy misa and his 9 goals.

We will. Thanks

 

[BigDaddyLurch]

Matthews scores 40 goals in his sleep. A healthy motivated Matthews with a new coach and he's back to 60 goals. Find anyone who can do that, u can't. So go enjoy misa and his 9 goals.

...so was he in a coma the last two years, then??...