Matthew Tkachuk vs Brady Tkachuk

[ReginKarlssonLehner]

Very early to tell. Brady is more raw. Matthew is more proven. Safe bet is Matthew. Although Brady has that chip on his shoulder that seems more like a bigger difference maker

 

[strictlyrandy]

Which one is the one that a Canadian fan base irrationally overrates?

 

[Icebreakers]

Matthew

 

[DomBarr]

Keith....

 

[Pyrophorus]

Brady

 

[Jocke1]

It caught me by surprise how similar some of the brothers stats are when looking at the last three seasons, its only a ten minute difference in total ice time:

Games Played
Matthew 241
Brady 242

Time On Ice Per Game
Matthew 18:59
Brady 18:51

Total Time On Ice
Matthew 4,573
Brady 4,563

Goals
Matthew 108
Brady 102

Even Strength Goals
Matthew 75
Brady 70

Backhand Goals
Matthew 8
Brady 9

Goals Tipped In (Shots Tipped)
Matthew 18 (105)
Brady 17 (107)

Deflected Goals
Matthew 4
Brady 4

Power Play Goals
Matthew 32
Brady 32

Shootout Goals
Matthew 1
Brady 1

Game Winning Goals
Matthew 14
Brady 11


Blocked Shots
Matthew 79
Brady 68

Takeaways
Matthew 118
Brady 119

Missed Shots
Matthew 336
Brady 352

Shootout Shots
Matthew 7
Brady 6

Penalties Drawn
Matthew 124
Brady 124

Minor Penalties
Matthew 91
Brady 91

Misconduct Penalties
Matthew 7
Brady 8

 

[Felidae]

It caught me by surprise how similar some of the brothers stats are when looking at the last three seasons, its only a ten minute difference in total ice time:

Games Played
Matthew 241
Brady 242

Time On Ice Per Game
Matthew 18:59
Brady 18:51

Total Time On Ice
Matthew 4,573
Brady 4,563

Goals
Matthew 108
Brady 102

Even Strength Goals
Matthew 75
Brady 70

Backhand Goals
Matthew 8
Brady 9

Goals Tipped In (Shots Tipped)
Matthew 18 (105)
Brady 17 (107)

Deflected Goals
Matthew 4
Brady 4

Power Play Goals
Matthew 32
Brady 32

Shootout Goals
Matthew 1
Brady 1

Game Winning Goals
Matthew 14
Brady 11


Blocked Shots
Matthew 79
Brady 68

Takeaways
Matthew 118
Brady 119

Missed Shots
Matthew 336
Brady 352

Shootout Shots
Matthew 7
Brady 6

Penalties Drawn
Matthew 124
Brady 124

Minor Penalties
Matthew 91
Brady 91

Misconduct Penalties
Matthew 7
Brady 8

You're ommitting overall production, which is conveniently the area Matthew largely separates himself from his brother. 2 100 points seasons good enough to finish top 10 in scoring, in addition to an 88 point season this year that still eclipses Brady's career high.

It may change in the future but Matthew has clearly been the better player the past 3 seasons.

 

[Jocke1]

You're ommited overall production, which is conveniently the area Matthew largely separates himself from his brother. 2 100 points seasons good enough to finish top 10 in scoring, in addition to an 88 point season this year that still eclipses Brady's career high.

It may change in the future but Matthew has clearly been the better player the past 3 seasons.

Absolutely, there are many stats where they differ.
I was just surprised at how many they are similar at or even equal each other on.

 

[Arthur Morgan]

LOL. Brady Tkachuk vs. Auston Matthews? This poll is a joke, yes?

I know this is old but did u just not know who the Tkachuks were back then? seen you also say who the hell is Brady and then mistaken Matthew for Matthews lol

kinda funny thats all

 

[Felidae]

Absolutely, there are many stats where they differ.
I was just surprised at how many they are similar at or even equal each other on.

Ah, fair enough. My apologies for coming off strong then.

 

[NyQuil]

You're ommitting overall production, which is conveniently the area Matthew largely separates himself from his brother.

Just like hits which are also missing.

Brady - 806 hits
Matt - 219 hits

 

[SNES]

Crazy how similar those numbers are. Cool beans. Thanks for sharing!

 

[tabness]

nice bump lol

Brady dukes it out with Perry and Eichel of the most Beavis looking mofo playing hockey after Guentzel though lol

 

[Bouboumaster]

Matthew

The fact that Brady has to play for a clown show team like Lolttawa doesn't help him

 

[Pablo El Perro]

I like Brady, but Matthew has started career pretty well. Two 100 point seasons, good playoff numbers, and a cup. Hell I hope Brady one-ups that, even moreso as a Panther.