News Article: Matt Murray on LTIR

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
So…scenario. Murray goes down and plays some games. Nobody’s expecting much, but by game 3 or 4 he’s pitching shutouts and looking really good. Like “best I’ve felt in 8 years” good. We squeak by the first round out-scoring our problems, neither Sammy or Woll are able to take the net. Goaltending is clearly an issue and we are down 2 games in round 2.

I put him in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mad hatter
So…scenario. Murray goes down and plays some games. Nobody’s expecting much, but by game 3 or 4 he’s pitching shutouts and looking really good. Like “best I’ve felt in 8 years” good. We squeak by the first round out-scoring our problems, neither Sammy or Woll are able to take the net. Goaltending is clearly an issue and we are down 2 games in round 2.

I put him in.
I would play him in game 1 of round 1
 
  • Like
Reactions: Taylor Halls Teeth
So…scenario. Murray goes down and plays some games. Nobody’s expecting much, but by game 3 or 4 he’s pitching shutouts and looking really good. Like “best I’ve felt in 8 years” good. We squeak by the first round out-scoring our problems, neither Sammy or Woll are able to take the net. Goaltending is clearly an issue and we are down 2 games in round 2.

I put him in.

Even in the scenario you described, I wouldn't play Murray unless all 3 of Samsonov, Woll, and Jones were unavailable.
 
In all seriousness a scenario in which Murray comes back and actually helps the team in the playoffs (even if it was just for like one game) would be a hell of a fun story. The guy's been through a lot

It would be but there's really no way he plays. It would take some incredibly bad luck for him to even be a back-up.
 
It would be but there's really no way he plays. It would take some incredibly bad luck for him to even be a back-up.

Definitely bad luck. Likely an injury to Jones + a complete collapse of faith in one of Woll or Sammy to have a chance of happening.

Still, I'm happy to see him getting closer to returning to play regardless.
 
Garbage timing. It’s not the exact same but We can’t be mad at stone and be ok with this
 
Definitely bad luck. Likely an injury to Jones + a complete collapse of faith in one of Woll or Sammy to have a chance of happening.

Still, I'm happy to see him getting closer to returning to play regardless.
I think he leapfrogs Jones automatically. He was the #1 until he got hurt and gave the net to Sammy who now is trying hard to give it back. I think it should be him or Woll in the playoffs because they aren't giving him an AHL assignment for any reason other than to see if he can play.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OddyOh
They timed his surgery to be ready like this. He won’t factor into the playoffs but that’s still 4 million we had

That's a bit speculative on your part regarding the timing. We know his surgery was necessary and was going to have a lengthy recovery period. It seemed like there was always going to be a fairly strong likelihood of him missing the season. Even as the Leafs benefited, there's nothing suggesting they delayed or overtly in had to manipulated things

I think he leapfrogs Jones automatically. He was the #1 until he got hurt and gave the net to Sammy who now is trying hard to give it back. I think it should be him or Woll in the playoffs because they aren't giving him an AHL assignment for any reason other than to see if he can play.
That's fair. Though Jones has been played fairly well this season and Murray not playing since March of last year might also influence the decision
 
That's a bit speculative on your part regarding the timing. We know his surgery was necessary and was going to have a lengthy recovery period. It seemed like there was always going to be a fairly strong likelihood of him missing the season. Even as the Leafs benefited, there's nothing suggesting they delayed or overtly in had to manipulated things


That's fair. Though Jones has been played fairly well this season and Murray not playing since March of last year might also influence the decision

He was announced LTIR in the summer. He got surgery months later. Just like kuch. There is no way they didn’t know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ToneDog
They timed his surgery to be ready like this. He won’t factor into the playoffs but that’s still 4 million we had
Of course it was. The idea that the Leafs are above doing what other teams do is naive. Good for them using the rules to their advantage. No different than Vegas, and no one should have an issue with either situation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ACC1224 and ToneDog
This shouldn't need to be said, but making significant additions at the deadline by LTIRing an elite player specifically between the deadline and game 1 of the playoffs is not remotely similar to a backup goalie on full-season LTIR maybe potentially becoming an available replacement option at some point throughout the playoffs if their two existing goaltenders get injured.
 
This shouldn't need to be said, but making significant additions at the deadline by LTIRing an elite player specifically between the deadline and game 1 of the playoffs is not remotely similar to a backup goalie on full-season LTIR maybe potentially becoming an available replacement option at some point throughout the playoffs if their two existing goaltenders get injured.
I would suggest that the Leafs putting Murray on LTIR at basically the last minute before they had to make a decision on buying him out or making a trade was probably not a coincidence. It's also fine. Teams are allowed to do it.
 
I would suggest that the Leafs putting Murray on LTIR at basically the last minute before they had to make a decision on buying him out or making a trade was probably not a coincidence. It's also fine. Teams are allowed to do it.
Vegas basically cheating circumventing the cap
 
  • Like
Reactions: OddyOh
I would suggest that the Leafs putting Murray on LTIR at basically the last minute before they had to make a decision on buying him out or making a trade was probably not a coincidence.
Yes, they determined his status when they had to determine his status. That's not a coincidence, or unusual.
He was injured and put on LTIR, and he was replaced - which is the whole point of LTIR. We're not doing what the other teams did, or gaining the significant benefit they did.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad