Value of: Martin Prospisil, Nicolas Deslauriers and Mathieu Olivier to Montréal

[Habby4Life]

Deslauriers for a 5th?

Propisil for Florida 2025 1st +? (I would add something, I know it's not enough, but it would be the base)

1st, yeah no, that’s horribad.

 

[ponder719]

Deslauriers for a 5th?

Propisil for Florida 2025 1st +? (I would add something, I know it's not enough, but it would be the base)

I'd give Montreal DLo and a 5th, sure.

 

[Treb]

Deslauriers for a 5th?

Propisil for Florida 2025 1st +? (I would add something, I know it's not enough, but it would be the base)

Go to sleep and read in shame tomorrow.

 

[madmike77]

Go to sleep and read in shame tomorrow.

Pospisil isn’t going to go for less than a low 1st. He’s an NHL regular who people hate to play against, can score the odd goal and is defensively responsible.

There’s no point trading him for a 2nd or less. You’d be lucky to get a Pospisil with a 2nd and a few years of development.

Would I give up a 1st for him? Probably not. But there’s zero incentive for the Flames to trade him for less than that given his age and what he’s done so far.

 

[BernieParent]

Deslauriers for a 5th?

Propisil for Florida 2025 1st +? (I would add something, I know it's not enough, but it would be the base)

You had me at Deslauriers.

 

[bud12]

Viel got put on waivers by Bos. Just claim him

 

[Conbon]

Give us Xhekaj for Pospisil

 

[Double Dion]

1st, yeah no, that’s horribad.

I wouldn't even consider it as a Flames fan. Pospisil is worth a lot more than Florida's 1st. Mtl 1st and I do it.

 

[HuGo Sham]

I wouldn't even consider it as a Flames fan. Pospisil is worth a lot more than Florida's 1st. Mtl 1st and I do it.

he's 25 in a month, missed a full year and has never scored more than 8 goals and - he's worth a potential lottery pick?

 

[Double Dion]

he's 25 in a month, missed a full year and has never scored more than 8 goals and - he's worth a potential lottery pick?

Drafted in 2018. Guess how many guys were drafted with a bottom 10 1st who are better from 2017 to 2019? It's a short list. 2 players. K'Andre Miller and Jake Oettinger. 2 out of 30.

If you're judging Pospisil by goals then it's abundantly clear you don't know who he is. He's a defensive savant and a top 5 irritant in the league. He's a missile on the forecheck. How would you feel about a physical, nasty Lekhonen? That's Pospisil. He'll add 15 goals minimum this year too. The coaching staff is playing him with our 10.5 Million dollar failure of a winger because they are hoping POSPISIL can help HUBERDEAU to be useful.

 

[stevo61]

Olivier is actually a hockey player who legitimately deserves to be in the lineup, he's not a detriment to his team when he's on the ice and I hope they keep him around for awhile. I thought the Xhekaj bro's are supposed to terrorize the league someday?

 

[dgibb10]

Drafted in 2018. Guess how many guys were drafted with a bottom 10 1st who are better from 2017 to 2019? It's a short list. 2 players. K'Andre Miller and Jake Oettinger. 2 out of 30.

If you're judging Pospisil by goals then it's abundantly clear you don't know who he is. He's a defensive savant and a top 5 irritant in the league. He's a missile on the forecheck. How would you feel about a physical, nasty Lekhonen? That's Pospisil. He'll add 15 goals minimum this year too. The coaching staff is playing him with our 10.5 Million dollar failure of a winger because they are hoping POSPISIL can help HUBERDEAU to be useful.

You left a LOT of guys out.

In terms of games played in the NHL as a basic look:

7/10 in 2018 have him beat
9/10 in 2017 have him beat
4/10 in 2019 have him beat

To say he's better than Rasmus Sandin or Morgan Frost is wild.

Also a disgusting way to value assets, by that logic of "well late 1sts only have a so and so % chance of becoming NHLers" every single NHLer in the league would be worth a 1st.

 

[Habby4Life]

I wouldn't even consider it as a Flames fan. Pospisil is worth a lot more than Florida's 1st. Mtl 1st and I do it.

Potential top 5 pick for that guy, hahahahaha!!!

 

[Double Dion]

Potential top 5 pick for that guy, hahahahaha!!!

I never said top 5. I said 2 out of 30 bottom 10 picks are better than Pospisil from 2017 to 2019. One year before his draft, his draft and one year after his draft. Galchenyuk was picked 3 OA. I'm sure you remember him.

Pospisil is a player who you win with. Florida just won with a bottom 6 full of lesser versions of Pospisil.

You guys traded a less physical version of Pospisil for a 2nd and Justin Barron. Did that work out well for you or for the Avs?

 

[Mersss]

Yeah, as much as I'd like him on the Habs, there's just no reasons for the Flames to trade him, he's still pretty young, he can play, his salary is still manageable, and he's crazy.

I'd probably do it for the Monahan pick back. Just in case we get on a role and end up 11th or something

Pospisil is not worth a 1st
Period

 

[HuGo Sham]

Drafted in 2018. Guess how many guys were drafted with a bottom 10 1st who are better from 2017 to 2019? It's a short list. 2 players. K'Andre Miller and Jake Oettinger. 2 out of 30.

If you're judging Pospisil by goals then it's abundantly clear you don't know who he is. He's a defensive savant and a top 5 irritant in the league. He's a missile on the forecheck. How would you feel about a physical, nasty Lekhonen? That's Pospisil. He'll add 15 goals minimum this year too. The coaching staff is playing him with our 10.5 Million dollar failure of a winger because they are hoping POSPISIL can help HUBERDEAU to be useful.

Wow. In your evaluation, he sounds generational. Keep him. Habs aren’t trading a potential lottery pick for him

Olivier is actually a hockey player who legitimately deserves to be in the lineup, he's not a detriment to his team when he's on the ice and I hope they keep him around for awhile. I thought the Xhekaj bro's are supposed to terrorize the league someday?

well he did beat up the sens tough guy and then scored a goal so there's that

 

[dgibb10]

I never said top 5. I said 2 out of 30 bottom 10 picks are better than Pospisil from 2017 to 2019. One year before his draft, his draft and one year after his draft. Galchenyuk was picked 3 OA. I'm sure you remember him.

Pospisil is a player who you win with. Florida just won with a bottom 6 full of lesser versions of Pospisil.

You guys traded a less physical version of Pospisil for a 2nd and Justin Barron. Did that work out well for you or for the Avs?

Do you genuinely believe Pospisil is better than Rasmus Sandin

 

[Habby4Life]

I never said top 5. I said 2 out of 30 bottom 10 picks are better than Pospisil from 2017 to 2019. One year before his draft, his draft and one year after his draft. Galchenyuk was picked 3 OA. I'm sure you remember him.

Pospisil is a player who you win with. Florida just won with a bottom 6 full of lesser versions of Pospisil.

You guys traded a less physical version of Pospisil for a 2nd and Justin Barron. Did that work out well for you or for the Avs?

You said MTLs first which will be very high. Pospisil isn’t worth even close to that.

Scrub for a potential top 5, only on HF boards, haha.

Btw - Pros isn’t qualified to carry Leks equipment bag.

 

[Double Dion]

You said MTLs first which will be very high. Pospisil isn’t worth even close to that.

Scrub for a potential top 5, only on HF boards, haha.

Btw - Pros isn’t qualified to carry Leks equipment bag.

Just your assessment of him as a scrub is plainly ridiculous. It means your opinion is really uninformed. Guy plays 60 games and is second in the league in hits while playing lights out D and he's a scrub.

According to MTL fans they have a good nucleus. Yet you think it's a top 5 pick? Only one of those things can be true.

 

[Habby4Life]

Just your assessment of him as a scrub is plainly ridiculous. It means your opinion is really uninformed. Guy plays 60 games and is second in the league in hits while playing lights out D and he's a scrub.

According to MTL fans they have a good nucleus. Yet you think it's a top 5 pick? Only one of those things can be true.

He is a scrub, worth a first round pick, lol, thanks for the laugh.

 

[Double Dion]

He is a scrub, worth a first round pick, lol, thanks for the laugh.

I said I wouldn't trade him for the Florida pick. He's worth substantially more. Just because you guys gave away Lekhonen for nothing doesn't mean we're going to give away a more physical version of him for nothing.

 

[Some Other Flame]

Pospisil is not worth a 1st
Period

Yeah, he's worth a lot more than a 1st. Which is exactly why he's not getting traded anytime soon.

 

[L4br3cqu3]

Pospisil is not worth a 1st
Period

Why do you quote me ? Never said he was.

 

[Skolman]

I wouldn't even consider it as a Flames fan. Pospisil is worth a lot more than Florida's 1st. Mtl 1st and I do it.

Well, this is laughable

 

[Bouboumaster]

Olivier is actually a hockey player who legitimately deserves to be in the lineup, he's not a detriment to his team when he's on the ice and I hope they keep him around for awhile. I thought the Xhekaj bro's are supposed to terrorize the league someday?

Florian Xhekaj need a year or two in the AHL but someday, they should be able to police the Ice together

I wouldn't even consider it as a Flames fan. Pospisil is worth a lot more than Florida's 1st. Mtl 1st and I do it.

That's way Too Much lol