I'm very intrigued by Curtis Douglas. At first I thought he would just be another AHL'er. He looks like a legit prospect that will play NHL games now. His stat line is pretty respectable for a guy who doesn't play the highest in the lineup or get much powerplay time. Likely a 4th liner, but a guy that big is quite a unique player to have. The guy can also flat out fight and knows how to utilize his reach in doing so. His skating isn't AWFUL especially for someone his size, but if it can get a little better I think that goes a long way for him.
Him and Petruzzelli are the main guys on AHL contracts who are looking like they will earn an ELC. Nobody else really comes close right now.
I don't think the Douglas contract comes this year, and maybe not even in the offseason, but I think he is given a guaranteed role with the Marlies next year (possibly including some more top 9 minutes) and if he shows well in the first 2-3 months, he gets his ELC at that point. Same happened with Marchment.
Petruzzelli is tougher. You have Kallgren and Woll. Scott could also be there, but I think it would be in the Hutch spot which doesn't make much sense for Petruzzelli anyways. Then there is the question about Kallgren willing to stick in an organization where he doesn't really have a clear path to the NHL.
If we are maximizing goalie development and depth, I think you start next year with both Woll and Kallgren, re-sign Scott for one more year in the Hutch spot to see if he can stay healthy, and then sign a guy like Taylor Gauthier to an AHL contract to split the ECHL with Petruzzelli.
Woll/Kallgren
Scott
---
Petruzzelli
Gauthier
Then we answer some questions: Does Kallgren have a future above a #3 with this organization or is willing to stay as a #3 beyond next year? Does Scott stay healthy? How is everyone performing and are they healthy? We will want Petruzzelli getting a chance and the answer to those questions will determine who is replaced by him in the AHL.
Beyond that, I think ideally it is something like Woll in the NHL as a full time backup, Kallgren as our #3 (or someone else if he doesn't want to stay or sucks) with Petruzzelli or Scott as the backup (it is unlikely going to be both), and Gauthier as the ECHL starter.
This doesn't include anyone we draft/sign in the future, including our Russian goalies. Although I imagine if our Russian goalies want to come to NA before they make the NHL, it won't happen for at least a couple of years.