TkachuckNotTkaczuk
Registered User
Because I look at the stats. Prove to me that Russians that leave Russia early become great players. Who are those guys?
The "ultimate dream" NHL is also something that should end. The NHL is an arrogant regional league that hurts the development of hockey in the world.
I don't care a bit for the wellbeing of the NHL as long as they treat prospects like they do and hurt international competition.
I do care for the fate of russian players. For Guryanov to leave at this age will probably result in a major decline and he will be thrown away like a used tissue. That is is just about to happen to Nichushkin btw who was just as stupid as Guyanov.
Wow, that is a mouthful of accusations.
First off, why would it be in the NHL's interest to hurt development of hockey the world over. Let's look at the Olympics for example, they have gone so that they can showcase better hockey to the rest of the world. In the process shutting down the league for 3 plus weeks. The NHL is not a regional league, yes it is in NA but has about 25% of it's players from outside NA. Canada as early as the 1990's had about 90% of all NHL jobs, this means the NHL has grown the game enough in Europe and Russia that more kids are playing which equality more players making it from those countries. The same is happening in the U.S. which now makes up 25% of all players in the league and are having a player from the great hockey state of Arizona getting drafted #1 overall, that is from growing the game.
The NHL all has working transfer agreements with all leagues in Europe, except for Russia who will not sign one because they want inexcusably large transfer transfer fees.
The CHL is the best developmental league in the world. It puts through more players to the NHL than all other leagues combined. That s because they develop their players properly. The kids are introduced to a larger amount of games than anywhere else in the world which will only increase their skill level and get them ready for the NHL, IF and only IF they are good enough.
The CHL has a great plan in place for all their players to go to university after they have played in the league, something that NO other league in the world has in place. This is a great program which allows these kids to get a degree should they not make the show. Now kids playing in the VHL or MHL, are there opportunities like this after they stop playing?
If Guyanov is good enough as a player he would step onto a team in the CHL and play 20-25 minutes a night and play some 68 games. Plus practice each day which is a hell of a lot better for development than 5-10 minutes a night and what 30-40 or so games? And now, a very large amount of CHL teams are either owned by, run by or coached by former NHLERS, this gives them first hand knowledge and access to some of the best people in the world who want NOTHING MORE than to see them succeed. Can you say that the MHL and VHL give kids access to past top league players, guys who aren't doing it for the pay cheque but more the love of the game? Is the quality of coaching and dedication to the betterment of the person the same, I would think not or the influx of kids to NA would stop.
Do you not understand, or is your bias that strong that you cannot see the vast amount of kids coming out of Europe to play, not only in the CHL but also USHL and the college ranks? That is because the opportunities are there to get better, get playing time and move forward with a game they love. They also get access to free pot high school education. They also get to play with kids their own age which is best for developing on the ice but also off the ice as a person. This is preferred rather than throwing them onto say a KHL team where you have a 17 year old kid hanging out with people up to twice their age, these are kids, they should grow with others their age. These kids become lifelong friends as they spend a lot of time with each other be it on the bus, plane, on the ice and school.
Now then, let's compare apples to apples here. The most highly skilled Russian have stayed and played in Russia for a few reasons, pay cheque, ice time guarantees, family and I hate to say it but threats by the Russian Hockey Federation about future roles with the Russian National team. The prospects who are not top flight are not given the ice time in Russia against better competition that they would get over in NA and thus it is there that their growth is stunted. Kids this age need ice time to develop, ot riding the pine getting 5 minutes a game or up in the press box.
Now, the biggest problem I have with your statement is you say you can tell that they are hurt because you "stat watch". That is a very common mistake by too many people, stats don't mean that the kids are falling behind in their development. It is a very different game over here, one that uses systems and a much smaller ice.
Nichushkin is not a bust, he has been sidetracked by injuries and is slowly developing into an all around game. He needs to stop complaining in the media and put in the work, he simply cannot be given minutes in the best league in the world because he asks for them, he needs to work like everyone else. And last time I checked this kid was developed in you grand Russian leagues, had he come over to play in the CHL he would have had less adjustment to the NHL as style of play is very similar. Jonathan Drouin, drafted the same year, drafted 3rd overall has played less games and was given less minutes than Nichushkin. Because he too expected to be gifted minutes and not needing to commit to a 200ft game, was sent down to the AHL where he pouted and held out thus getting suspended. It looks like he has come to his senses and realized it was he who had to change, not management, not coaches and is now succeeding. Nichushkin may have burnt a bridge with Dallas and may need a change of scenery now.
Long post but I feel your bias is not based upon reality but maybe based on something else?