LaCarriere
Registered User
With Smoak, the thinking was that he was going off the platform from what he was earning with the Mariners, not the 1M last season. So while MLBTR projected him at 2M, they weren't taking the $3.75M he would have been going off of and probably awarded over $4M.
And I'd argue that's a good case where you challenge the arbitration system. Also, BR and Spotrac has his 2014 salary at 2.6M.
You don't have much to lose in that case -- if you lose the hearing he gets his ~4.0M based on his salary 2 years ago, if you win you save a couple million.