Take a peek around the league...at the teams we'll be matching up against in the ECF and SCF. Their 3rd line C is putting up numbers. In fact, some of those teams have 3LCs who have more points than Kelly was on PACE for. Expectations are different here during the Chara window. If you want to contend in this league, your 3rd liners need to produce. I still think it's a mistake to look at 2011 and 2013 as blueprints. We got historical goaltending in those two years, I think it's wrong to count on that.
So...you are now assuming we have reached or will reach the ECF/SCF?? hmm, I`m assuming you are viewing Brandon Sutter`s 16-17pts in almost 50 games as one baromoter, then I`ll have a peek at the Hawks as the other comparable who rotate Handzus as their 3rd, or have Pirri there (Pirri is an exceptionally talented player by the way if ya haven`t seen him), Handzus has 10pts in 30ish games.
Make no mistake about it, the success or production of the 3rd line is 100% dependant upon what the top 2 lines have done in the past when this 3rd has been at it`s most dangerous (been a while since we have said that)
When at it`s most productive, the B`s top 2 lines were big time handfulls to deal with, other teams scrambled to put a line out to stop them, then the B`s counter with a Kelly/Pevs/Ryder or whomever, and opponents had NOTHING to answer with. Last season was what last season was, a lockout year in which I put zero stock into anything. This season, Kelly was playing solid hockey (solid doesn`t = pts) with Sods and at that time, Smith, then Kelly`s injury happened.
What Spooner offers is an offensive threat up the middle out of the center position (nice), what Spooner is still working on, is his strength and defensive positioning (which aren`t where they need to be for CJ to be 100% trusting) which is hardly an issue with a young prospect still learning.
Again, many here scoff at the intangible aspect of what certain players bring, Chia (ya know, the guy making decisions
) doesn`t, and he knows what Kelly can bring. I`ll bet when the B`s brass sits down before the season, they look at every player and project what they "hope" is attainable offensively, and I`d be shocked if they post a number on Kelly any higher than 30pts.
I`m not saying Kelly isn`t or won`t be replaced before the end of his contract, but the way he is undervalued here is silly IMO, much the way Seids was far too often. Chris Kelly isn`t Wayne Primeau or Steve Begin, Kelly is an exceptionally responsible player playing for a coach who loves responsible players, and when he produces, it`s considered a bonus, not an expected event.
When he returns, who knows what will happen.