At first I HATED this deal...
But as it "ages" -- call me crazy but I'm not horribly adverse to it.
You look at Joel Edmundson gettng $3.85m x 4, Ilya Lyubushkin getting $3.25m x 2, TJ Brodie getting $3.75m x 2... and there's some things to like.
Yes, he'll be 33 in a couple of weeks, but he's a smart defenceman who skates well with a decent frame & reach. He shouldn't neccessarily drop off massively.
You look at him maybe paired alongside Jake McCabe, and that's a very solid pair for $5.5m. Hanakapa another potential partner, for a $5m pair.
That would then free up something like a McCabe-Liljegren or Benoit-Liljegren pair; and i would argue that either of those are really a very good 3rd pair, or mediocre 2nd.
As a whole, the Leafs are likely to have one of Rielly/Liljegren/OEL on the ice at all times 5on5.
Sure, in a perfect world, it would have been a guy like Brett Pesce and his $5.5m sounds more appealing than these 2 deals, but it seems that Pesce was never really interested in coming to Canada; instead choosing a team 45 minutes from home.
I think one of the real benefits of what Treliving did with the D, is set us up so that we're most likely not shopping for defencemen at the deadline, which makes sense when you consider that the Leafs gave up a 2 3rds, a 5th and a 6th for Lyubushkin & Edmundson at the deadline.
They're somewhat better positioned now to try and just land 1 big fish up front versus the apporach of years past attempting to turn over large portions of the roster.