LD Lane Hutson - Boston University, NCAA (2022, 62nd, MTL)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Anardil

Registered User
Nov 25, 2012
611
434
West of Chalet BBQ
As much as I enjoy what Hutson has accomplished up to now in his career, I cannot get overly excited about him. I do not see his style translating well to the pro levels.

I also find it very concerning that one of his major weaknesses is backwards skating. That will need to improve greatly if he is to have a productive NHL career.

The videos are great, however they only show what he does well. Thankfully, one of his strengths is his hockey IQ, so he should be able to improve his weaknesses, but I will temper my expectations, at least until I see him play regularly in Laval.
 

Lafleurs Guy

Guuuuuuuy!
Jul 20, 2007
78,371
49,687
As much as I enjoy what Hutson has accomplished up to now in his career, I cannot get overly excited about him. I do not see his style translating well to the pro levels.

I also find it very concerning that one of his major weaknesses is backwards skating. That will need to improve greatly if he is to have a productive NHL career.

The videos are great, however they only show what he does well. Thankfully, one of his strengths is his hockey IQ, so he should be able to improve his weaknesses, but I will temper my expectations, at least until I see him play regularly in Laval.
This is incorrect. The videos show his warts as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Habs10Habs

Raistlin

Registered User
Aug 25, 2006
5,003
3,933
Have they really changed though? Has anyone doubted his offensive potential? You have some critics who will look at his stature, skating, or perception of two way play and doubt his long term viability as a top four NHL all situations defender, but as a dispassionate observer, the same statements have been made for some time about him. At this point there may be some waning interest from fans that only follow the NHL and only care about a prospect that will play for the team they root for. Ultimately, he will go as far as his defense takes him. I have no doubt he will QB a PP and with the puck on his stick will be quite a dangerous player. It is what he will do without the puck that will define his career. If he can just be slightly below average defensively his overall impact should be quite positive. I guess the best case scenario is sort of like Fox or Quinn Hughes? The low end is a third pair guy who runs the PP which is still a good player when you put it in context.
Following quite a bit of BU games because of Celebrini and Willander. Hudson's skating is his greatest undoing in my opinion, when he has the puck, its like the lightshow goes on, and the offense just flows so naturally through him. but without possession, hes just not mobile enough. The comparison with Hughes is odd, becasue he is defined by his skating. his 8 way mobility is peerless except for McDavid, hes like on videogame controls walking the line. Willander on the other hand is the opposite of Hudson, elite skating and very good defense, but clueless at times with the puck on his stick, he needs a puck skills coach. Hudson Gostisbehere comparison is apt at this time. he will need a very good skating coach this summer to fill this crucial gap in his game.
 

Sam de Mtl

Registered User
Oct 11, 2021
1,370
2,461
Following quite a bit of BU games because of Celebrini and Willander. Hudson's skating is his greatest undoing in my opinion, when he has the puck, its like the lightshow goes on, and the offense just flows so naturally through him. but without possession, hes just not mobile enough. The comparison with Hughes is odd, becasue he is defined by his skating. his 8 way mobility is peerless except for McDavid, hes like on videogame controls walking the line. Willander on the other hand is the opposite of Hudson, elite skating and very good defense, but clueless at times with the puck on his stick, he needs a puck skills coach. Hudson Gostisbehere comparison is apt at this time. he will need a very good skating coach this summer to fill this crucial gap in his game.
That is accurate at this point in time. Hutson is special in some ways, but doesn't look special when you look at him play, except for the dangles. He is a strange case.

However, very few players transition to the NCAA as seamlessly as he did. My reflex would be to say he will struggle when he reaches pros, but he is so smart he seems to find his way out of many situations and learn quickly. I am convinced he will be in the AHL next year (not NHL) but I wouldn't be surprised if the discourse was the same: "he is doing great in the slower AHL, but he will get hammered in the NHL". A slow burn approach will be best for him, where he can slowly adapt to each levels, but he seems like a guy who will always keep on surpassing expectations (except the lofty 1D expectations of some over the top fans who don't watch the games).
 

HabzSauce

Registered User
Jun 10, 2022
1,728
2,373
a lot of his offence comes from deception and shimmies... I wonder how that will translate to NHL. Players are way more disciplined and won't bite as much. And he's not great in his zone. Worst case scenario, if he's a PP specialist, it's still a win.
If all he ends up being is a PP specialist I'd trade him now in a heart beat while his value is at an all time high. Would be very disappointing with all the skill, IQ and compete this guy has.

Time will tell. He is impossible to predict but his warts are definitely concerning. I want this guy to be a stud lol. Anything less than that and I'd rather have Xhejak/Engstrom/Struble/Guhle as our LD.
 

WhiskeyYerTheDevils

yer leadin me astray
Sponsor
Apr 27, 2005
35,270
33,818
If all he ends up being is a PP specialist I'd trade him now in a heart beat while his value is at an all time high. Would be very disappointing with all the skill, IQ and compete this guy has.

Time will tell. He is impossible to predict but his warts are definitely concerning. I want this guy to be a stud lol. Anything less than that and I'd rather have Xhejak/Engstrom/Struble/Guhle as our LD.
If you get a contributing NHL player with a late 2nd round pick, it's a win. If he turns out to be a bottom pairing dman at 5v5 who can run PPs at an elite level, that's a very good outcome honestly. I know the points are exciting but there's a lot more to being an NHL defender.
 

Boxscore

Registered User
Sponsor
Jan 22, 2007
14,632
7,722
a lot of his offence comes from deception and shimmies... I wonder how that will translate to NHL. Players are way more disciplined and won't bite as much. And he's not great in his zone. Worst case scenario, if he's a PP specialist, it's still a win.
Imho, worst case scenario this kid ends up Shayne Gostisbehere. Best case, Quinn Hughes. If you take the middle ground, you're looking at the "good version" of Brandon Montour... or a #4D who can run a top PP and score 60 points a pop.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GordieHowYaDoin

BKarchitect

Registered User
Oct 12, 2017
8,170
14,595
Kansas City, MO
Imho, worst case scenario this kid ends up Shayne Gostisbehere. Best case, Quinn Hughes. If you take the middle ground, you're looking at the "good version" of Brandon Montour... or a #4D who can run a top PP and score 60 points a pop.

There’s no version of this where he ends up as Quinn Hughes. He will never have that skating.
 

Boxscore

Registered User
Sponsor
Jan 22, 2007
14,632
7,722
There’s no version of this where he ends up as Quinn Hughes. He will never have that skating.
Might not have Quinn's skating, but there's always a "best case scenario" where Hutson could be a PP titan who scores 85-90 points and leads NHL D scoring. Is it highly-likely? Probably not. But if he ends up Gostisbehere on steroids and Red Bull the Habs have themselves a gem.
 

Blue Chip Prospect

Registered User
Feb 9, 2019
96
158
Montreal
a lot of his offence comes from deception and shimmies... I wonder how that will translate to NHL. Players are way more disciplined and won't bite as much. And he's not great in his zone. Worst case scenario, if he's a PP specialist, it's still a
a lot of his offence comes from deception and shimmies... I wonder how that will translate to NHL. Players are way more disciplined and won't bite as much. And he's not great in his zone. Worst case scenario, if he's a PP specialist, it's still a win.
one of the big issue with his offence and breakouts in my opinion is that he creates all kinds from fakes and misdirections but I don’t think he has the legs to explode into the space he will creates at the NHL level. Even in the NCAA he often gets caught up after spinning off pressure. What is it gonna be in the NHL when the gap created is smaller and players are faster ? I’m a Hutson Belieber so he has the benefit of the doubt since he always destroyed expectations but I can’t wait to see him play against pros and have a clearer idea.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mudz

HabzSauce

Registered User
Jun 10, 2022
1,728
2,373
If you get a contributing NHL player with a late 2nd round pick, it's a win. If he turns out to be a bottom pairing dman at 5v5 who can run PPs at an elite level, that's a very good outcome honestly. I know the points are exciting but there's a lot more to being an NHL defender.
MEH you're right that is good value for a late 2nd, but I want him to be able to run a PP, AND be effective 5v5.

Not dumping on the guy lol I hope he does it. Time will tell, but I'm not really a fan of PP specialists. If that's all he is I think Habs would be better using that asset in a trade to get someone that can contribute more at 5v5, especially come playoff time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anardil

Mudz

3peat watch: 0/3
Sep 11, 2006
3,121
1,087
Montréal
@bluechip...
During his first dev camp, Hutson took JB out of his pants. At first, I liked the move but usually it's against fillers. Now JB is not he best defensively but still, I think it's encouraging that his moves worked against that level of opponent.

Now I understand what you mean. And one big flaw I saw this year (at the dev camp) was that he was holding the puck waaaayyyy too long. Maybe it's because no one was getting open, maybe he was trying to do too much.

Can't wait to see him at a real NHL with and against players. Unless he decides to stay one more year...
 

badfish

Habs fan in ON
Sponsor
Nov 12, 2005
2,849
3,108
ON
@bluechip...
Now I understand what you mean. And one big flaw I saw this year (at the dev camp) was that he was holding the puck waaaayyyy too long. Maybe it's because no one was getting open, maybe he was trying to do too much.
From what I've watched this year, I think he is holding onto the puck less, and even doing high-risk dangles less, and trying to drive his offense more through passing/skating. I think this is why there seems to be less highlights of Hutson this year, despite him having a better season offensively.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GordieHowYaDoin

Guess

Registered User
Jul 16, 2010
1,283
1,189
Brossard, QC
Habs have a skills coach who is a skating specialist. Hutson is also extremely motivated to improve. I find it hard to believe he won't have a skating program to improve during the offseason. He'll do whatever it takes to make the show.
 

jiboy

la game dans la game
May 2, 2007
1,865
1,112
Hes got lots of Adam Fox in his game , higher risk but the poise and the way he walks the line and generate his offense should translate to higher levels.

Hes going to be a special player and of course on some highlights he will look very bad. A little bit like Subban who was a huge overal net positive player on the ice but who looked awful when his play driving failed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad