Osprey
Registered User
- Feb 18, 2005
- 27,909
- 10,777
The Lighthouse (2019) - 6/10 (Liked it)
An old sea dog (Willem Dafoe) and a new, young assistant (Robert Pattinson) man a lighthouse on a desolate island and struggle to get along. I was very impressed with both actors' performances and am surprised that neither was nominated for an Oscar. I would've given both nominations over DiCaprio and Driver, personally. The cinematography is also very good, with it looking like an old B&W film, and the sound design is, as well, especially the frequent use of the fog horn. Occasionally, it was hard to make out a few words because of the Olde English pronunciations, but subtitles helped. Unfortunately, I wasn't very impressed by the story. There wasn't much to it and it was a bit confusing (and I don't necessarily mean all of the hallucinations and dreams). It often wasn't clear to me where their relationship stood because they'd yell at each other and, then, get drunk and laugh together. A few times, they'd have such an argument and, then, the next scene would be them getting along and we'd learn that it's a week later. The ending also wasn't as climactic as I was expecting and I'm still trying to figure out how the story got from the second-to-last scene to the last scene. In all, it's a good premise with excellent execution, but the actual story was lacking, IMO. I would have to say that I liked it, but more for the technical aspects, the performances and the fact that it's different. I was still a little disappointed because I was hoping that it'd be something that I'd like more.
An old sea dog (Willem Dafoe) and a new, young assistant (Robert Pattinson) man a lighthouse on a desolate island and struggle to get along. I was very impressed with both actors' performances and am surprised that neither was nominated for an Oscar. I would've given both nominations over DiCaprio and Driver, personally. The cinematography is also very good, with it looking like an old B&W film, and the sound design is, as well, especially the frequent use of the fog horn. Occasionally, it was hard to make out a few words because of the Olde English pronunciations, but subtitles helped. Unfortunately, I wasn't very impressed by the story. There wasn't much to it and it was a bit confusing (and I don't necessarily mean all of the hallucinations and dreams). It often wasn't clear to me where their relationship stood because they'd yell at each other and, then, get drunk and laugh together. A few times, they'd have such an argument and, then, the next scene would be them getting along and we'd learn that it's a week later. The ending also wasn't as climactic as I was expecting and I'm still trying to figure out how the story got from the second-to-last scene to the last scene. In all, it's a good premise with excellent execution, but the actual story was lacking, IMO. I would have to say that I liked it, but more for the technical aspects, the performances and the fact that it's different. I was still a little disappointed because I was hoping that it'd be something that I'd like more.
Last edited: