I was starting to get around to this year's Best Picture nominees that I hadn't seen yet and realized that I still hadn't seen two of the more acclaimed ones from last year.
Roma (2018) - 4/10 (Disliked it)
Usually, I summarize the plot in one sentence here, but there isn't much of one. The film just follows a housemaid around and then ends the same way that it started. It feels very much like a short film that's been stretched and padded out to over two hours. That time wasn't even used much to develop the characters--even the lead character is about as uninteresting at the end as at the start--but, instead, seemingly to present writer/director Alfonso Cuaron's own personal memories of growing up in Mexico at this time. I appreciate that personal connection and his obvious passion, but there still should be a story worthy of being told, IMO. Frankly, I found it to be very tedious and one of the more boring films that I've seen in some time. I did admire and love the direction and cinematography, though. It looks like a much older film, not just because it's in black and white, but because it employs wide shots, long takes and slow pans. I wish that more directors today would shoot films like this (instead of resorting to quick edits, fast camera work, closeups and so on). As such, I have no problem with Cuaron winning Best Director and Best Cinematography. I just wish that there had been a lot more of a story to match the direction, i.e. substance to go with the style.
Green Book (2018) - 8/10 (Loved it)
An Italian bouncer (Viggo Mortensen) is hired to drive and protect a "colored" piano virtuoso (Mahershala Ali) on a playing tour through the southern states in 1962. The story may seem familiar and cliched, but at least it has one and a fairly good one. There's nothing exceptional or unique about how it's directed or shot, but it also doesn't rely on that. It's a good story with interesting characters, and that's what's more important to my personal enjoyment. It was quite a bit funnier and lighter than I expected. It doesn't avoid or sugarcoat race relations, but it doesn't make them as tough to stomach as other films. It's not really about race, after all, but about a relationship, and it keeps the focus on that, not with beating us over the head with the wrongness of racism. The performances by Mortensen and Ali are both good, with Mortensen's nomination seemingly being more for getting into character and Ali's for making it look effortless (though, honestly, I was wondering why he won halfway through, but I eventually saw, especially in one powerful scene in the rain). Anyways, is it feel good Oscar bait? Yes, it is, but I like to feel good and get emotionally invested and I'll take that any day over Oscar bait that makes me feel nothing.