Birds of Prey is just a complete mess. First of all, the pace is all over the place. There are too many jump-start moments, that I actually feel as if I have motion sickness, and I just want the thing to end by the midway point. The narrative style also does not help, because while I understand the goal is to create an unreliable storyteller in order to highlight the inherent craziness of the character, all the techniques used, from a single flashback sequence that is out-of-place and then never utilized again, to the fourth wall breaks that are ultimately pointless, make the whole story unnecessarily confusing and downright annoying. Then there is the main antagonist, who is important in the comics, but he becomes a run-of-the-mill villain who never actually seems to be able to threaten the protagonists, and that is always fatal to any comic book movies. Finally, the moments of levity and the lines that are supposed to be funny all falls flat. I did not chuckle once during the movie.
What is it with the DC cinematic universe? After so many movies, it still cannot find its voice and identity. Other than Patty Jenkins, David F. Sandberg and to a lesser extent James Wan, no other director seems to actually knows the material. Warner Brothers wanted to be serious after Christopher Nolan showed that it can work, but the people in charge picked the worst possible choice in Zack Snyder, who cannot tell a story to save his life. Then they wanted to copy the success of Marvel, so they threw more jokes in The Suicide Squad, but that just made it a Frankenstein monster so terrible, the sequel is now called a "soft-reboot". At this point, DC needs to figure out something soon, or the whole thing will become a sunk cost. For every success, there is a failure in between, and that is no way to sustain a franchise. The DC superheroes can be great and resonate with people, as various comic book writers have shown, but the people in charge of the films absolutely do not know what they want to do. Marvel is not perfect, but the cookie-cutter formula works, and even when I complain, I am still entertained.
Birds of Prey is a 3/10 for me. Robbie is fun, even though she, at times, gets blogged down by the style of the director, and there are some great mise-en-scene here and there, but that is not enough for me to recommend the movie. Even if one is curious, just wait for it to be on streaming services. It is not worth the price of admission.