shadow1
Registered User
- Nov 29, 2008
- 16,728
- 5,526
When a Stranger Calls (1979) - 6/10
A babysitter is harassed by a series of threatening calls. Seven years later, the stalker returns.
When a Stranger Calls stars Carol Kane as Jill, a babysitter watching the children of an affluent couple. She starts receiving crank phone calls, which she initially dismisses as a practical joke. However, the calls starting increasing in frequency and maliciousness and her evening turns into a nightmare.
This opening 20 minute sequence is one of the most famous in horror history. Director Fred Walton creates paranoia and tension through a minimalist approach, showing the audience only one character (Kane) in a big dark house, along with a ringing phone. Every time the phone rings, it almost works as a jump scare thanks to Walton progressively increasing the volume of each ring. It is a dreadful sequence, but one that feels real and relatable.
While the opening is classic, the rest of the movie is below average. After a time jump, we follow John Clifford (Charles Durning), a P.I. investigating the stalker (Tony Beckley, in his final role before passing away). Clifford has a personal connection to the case, as he was previously a police officer who responded to the phone call incident.
This part of the movie drags, big time. Durning is excellent as the detective hellbent on vigilante justice, but there isn't enough story in this middle section. There's a subplot that tries to humanize the stalker, but it feels like filler...which it pretty much is: When a Stranger Calls was originally a short that was flushed out and re-filmed as a feature film to try to ride the success of John Carpenter's Halloween.
Fortunately, after the bland middle section, the movie finishes with a strong final 15 minutes that reintroduces the horror and dread of the film's opening. In other words, the movie is a donut. It's satisfying enough, but the final product would've been better had the filmmakers extended the opening and closing sequences by 5-10 minutes each to cut down on the filler middle section of the movie.
A babysitter is harassed by a series of threatening calls. Seven years later, the stalker returns.
When a Stranger Calls stars Carol Kane as Jill, a babysitter watching the children of an affluent couple. She starts receiving crank phone calls, which she initially dismisses as a practical joke. However, the calls starting increasing in frequency and maliciousness and her evening turns into a nightmare.
This opening 20 minute sequence is one of the most famous in horror history. Director Fred Walton creates paranoia and tension through a minimalist approach, showing the audience only one character (Kane) in a big dark house, along with a ringing phone. Every time the phone rings, it almost works as a jump scare thanks to Walton progressively increasing the volume of each ring. It is a dreadful sequence, but one that feels real and relatable.
While the opening is classic, the rest of the movie is below average. After a time jump, we follow John Clifford (Charles Durning), a P.I. investigating the stalker (Tony Beckley, in his final role before passing away). Clifford has a personal connection to the case, as he was previously a police officer who responded to the phone call incident.
This part of the movie drags, big time. Durning is excellent as the detective hellbent on vigilante justice, but there isn't enough story in this middle section. There's a subplot that tries to humanize the stalker, but it feels like filler...which it pretty much is: When a Stranger Calls was originally a short that was flushed out and re-filmed as a feature film to try to ride the success of John Carpenter's Halloween.
Fortunately, after the bland middle section, the movie finishes with a strong final 15 minutes that reintroduces the horror and dread of the film's opening. In other words, the movie is a donut. It's satisfying enough, but the final product would've been better had the filmmakers extended the opening and closing sequences by 5-10 minutes each to cut down on the filler middle section of the movie.