Pranzo Oltranzista
Registered User
- Oct 18, 2017
- 4,026
- 2,939
Turning Red (2022) Directed by Domee Shi 8A
Turning Red focuses on Meilin, a 13-year-old Chinese-Canadian girl who lives in Toronto with her loving but overly protective mother. Mei is a dutiful, hard working girl who does what her mother tells her to do, including getting great grades, but she is becoming interested in the sort of things--boy bands and, well, boys, in general--that make her mother nervous. Trying to balance between her mother's wishes and her own emerging needs proves too much for Mei, and she inadvertently transforms into a fearsome creature, a giant red panda who is capable of going totally bonkers with very little warning. Turning Red may be my favourite Pixar movie since Wall-E. It helps, I suppose, that Mei's story is set in sunny, happily multi-cultural Toronto. It is fun to see the city play such a positive role in the goings on. But Mei is a wonderful character, and the plot, which relies in part on Chinese mythology, is original, smart and charming and provides plenty of opportunities for laughs and dazzling animation. I also like the way that Turning Red treated Mei's mom as overbearing, sure, but loving as well, definitely no villain. The messages for kids are all supportive ones about growing up, navigating changing family dynamics, accepting oneself, and even embracing the fact that one's inner demons are part of you. Turning Red is among Pixar's best films.
Believe Warlock (the 1959 film) is on YouTube, have been meaning to check it out. I like Chief Dan George in Josey Wales, not an actor just a kind soul.
Terrific review.I also just watched Turning Red over the weekend, and I enjoyed it.
Partly because of the little Canadian touches (Tim Hortons coffee and timbits, the convenience store has the Beckers logo) and partly because it's definitely an homage or a time capsule to the creator's teenage years in the early 2000s which is when I was an older teenager as well. Some of the animation sequences were quietly stellar, including some of the lighting effects and night scenes.
Mei is an adorably proud geek with a positive group of supportive friends, friends who do not necessarily meet the standards of her over-bearing mother. How that relationship evolves, and echoes her mother's own relationship with Mei's grandmother, is the central focus of the story.
There is clearly a lot of Domee Shi, the creator, in the character and in the story. It's basically an autobiography (down to taking care of the oldest temple in Toronto), and she publicly airs out a lot of unresolved issues regarding her family and her place within the Canadian context as a second-generation Chinese-Canadian. I also watched the "Making of" documentary (~45 mins) afterwards and you can still sense a certain degree of awkwardness in scenes where the creator engages with her parents. You also get to see a lot of pictures of her as a child, where she was basically Mei.
I have a couple of Asian-Canadian female friends who definitely fit the stereotype of trying to fit in with traditional Canadian culture while keeping their grades sky-high, piano and violin lessons, and meeting the ambitious career aspirations of their parents.
One of them rebelled completely, leaving to travel the world as a professional violinist in a variety of international orchestras - ironically her parents did not want her to be a musician despite all of the hours she had put in - it was a hobby to impress their friends but should be set aside for medicine when appropriate. Her father was distant and her mother was controlling, just like with Mei. She now lives in Malaysia, married a Spanish cellist, moving about as far away from Canada as she could get.
Turning Red brought all of that back for me, even if I was only a spectator and occasional confidant.
All of the senior production staff were women, and many of them Asian-Canadians or Asian-Americans. In the little glimpses into their lives in the documentary, I was perhaps not surprised about how many of them were in relationships with seemingly laid-back white guys. My wife is an A-type and I am a more relaxed individual and it sort of works.
In any event, despite the subject matter, it's a very family-focused story with little in the way of an external challenge or villain. While she learns to become comfortable as the panda, she never turns into a superhero or fights crime. If anything, it's the climax of the film that probably fell a bit short, in terms of the big set-piece at the SkyDome. I think it loses its sense of scale a little bit, going for dazzle just for the sake of it.
Interestingly, Domee Shi, in the documentary, admits that she wasn't quite sure how to end the film. I suspect that, despite the obvious pride shown by her parents, there is still a lingering gap between them and it was hard for her to get over it in order to produce a happy ending.
The film really drives home the challenge facing second-generation immigrants to honor and respect their traditions while attending public school and being inevitably assimilated to some degree by the culture of their new home. I think it also tries to capture what it was like for girls to be going through puberty and the emotional roller-coaster that it entails over the smallest of things.
I actually don't see Coda as Oscar material either but I did see it during a lockdown period and found it uplifting. It was obviously not a banner year for films but Coda will remain my emotional favorite. A nice little film that is punching above its weight and I will be rooting for it (in any category). Although I think Troy Kotsur has an above average chance of running away with the best supporting actor.Yeah, Power of Dog is still the favorite everywhere it seems. Can't believe Belfast is 2nd on most odds lists, which was a great movie but I wasn't blown away by it, especially emotionally which it was primarily aiming for. CODA looks to be 3rd on most lists, haven't seen it though and personally don't have much interest in it. Can't believe West Side Story and Licorice Pizza are high on most lists. Dune I understand. I don't know if this was a weak year or what have you.
City of Pirates / La Ville des pirates (Raúl Ruiz, 1983)
I’ve only ever seen one film from the extremely prolific director Raúl Ruiz (over 100 films to his credit!), his Dickensian like period piece epic Mysteries of Lisbon, and I went in blind with City of Pirates knowing nothing about it and thinking it would be a somewhat similar style. I could not be more surprised. City of Pirates is a surrealist film that feels like an absolute fever dream, many wave lengths from what I had experienced prior with Ruiz. The plot, which is at times indecipherable, follows a woman who meets a homicidal but angelic little boy fresh off of raping and murdering his family, who then travel to an abandoned island where they meet a man with multiple personalities. The story is very loose, the only logic to the film is a dreamlike logic as you drift from scene to scene with beautifully weird moments and vibrant colours. The plot is nonsensical because Ruiz wrote the script for the day each day based upon his dreams from his siesta that afternoon. There is lots to interpret and uncover in the film; its overwhelming for a first viewing but I’m sure repeat watches are rewarding, but it is never boring and is always beautiful and interesting. One of those films that you should just let wash over you and try not to make heads or tails of its plot and instead feel the images. Definitely not a film for everyone but one to watch if you have an interest in surrealist, avant-garde, or experimental film.
Still can't put a like on this post, but I love it! Oh that feeling when you discover these amazing films from Ruiz. That period from '78 to '84 is my favorite from him. Lots of amazing films.
Les trois couronnes du matelot is my favorite film ever. L'hypothèse du tableau volé is also top-3. La ville des pirates, Le territoire, On Top of the Whale (this one is rather dry), La présence réelle are all very interesting films too.Yeah I remember you being a big fan of Ruiz! Whats your favourite of his from that period?
Glad to see CODA is getting better reviews lately.
CODA (2021) Directed by Sian Heder 3A