Bounces R Way
Registered User
Death on the Nile (2022) - 6/10
On a trip in Egypt, a detective investigates a murder aboard a cruise ship.
Kenneth Branagh stars as Hercule Poirot, a famous detective sightseeing in Egypt. Newlyweds Linnet Ridgeway (Gal Gadot) and Simon Doyle (Armie Hammer) are celebrating their honeymoon on this trip, but Simon's lovelorn ex-fiance Jaqueline de Bellefort (Emma Mackey) has crashed the tour, leaving everyone on edge. Poirot implores both the Doyles and Jaqueline to leave the trip, fearing things will turn deadly. Poirot's fears are proven to be correct when one of the tour-goers ends up dead during an overnight trip on a cruise ship. It's up to the world's most famous detective to figure out who amongst the passengers is responsible...
Death on the Nile was directed by star Kenneth Branagh, and written by Michael Green. The film is based on the 1937 Agatha Christie Novel of the same name, and marks the second film is Branagh's Poirot series. How does it fare?
Meh... it's okay. Death on the Nile has what I consider to be a slog of a first 20 minutes, with sensory overload in a busy scene at a Jazz club, followed by cinematography of Egypt that somehow never looks at beautiful as it should. If you can't keep up with all of the characters, don't worry - one character eventually spoon feeds the backgrounds and motivations of the others to Poirot, including even saying "no one trusts" one particular character. This is at least a half hour before anyone is killed, mind you.
Once the movie settles down from its clunky opening, it becomes decent popcorn entertainment. Death on the Nile is well photographed, and I once again like Branagh's performance as Poirot. Interestingly, the movie tries to give the normally asexual character more of a romantic background, which is coincidentally also the case for the 2004 TV movie, despite it not being a subplot in the book. I thought it worked here, personally.
As for the mystery itself, I've never been the biggest fan of Death on the Nile. It's one of Christie's more well known books, but it feels like a lower stakes version of Murder on the Orient Express. The police board the ship almost immediately after the murder, so the characters don't feel "trapped" with their unknown assailant in the middle of the water. The solution to the crime is one of Christie's most memorable, though I thought the film was a little too obvious with some of the clues.
But to hop on my soapbox and criticize a book that is almost a 100 years old: Poirot is so famous that the paparazzi know him, yet he just happens to be at the wrong place at the wrong time for another murder? This became a problem in a lot of later books, with Poirot transitioning from a hired detective to a death magnet, with someone dying in his vicinity every time he walks out the front door. The film does try to justify this and does the best it can within the confines of the story, but you still have to suspend your disbelief that the killer would go through with their plan with Poirot on the ship. Realistically, the killer would take out Poirot, which they have several chances to do in this film.
Overall, Death on the Nile is an okay movie. It's a light 6 for me, doing a decent job adapting the novel, but not standing out in any particular area. Even with my gripes about this entry, I am just happy Branagh is making these movies, and look forward to a likely fourth Poirot film in the near future. Death on the Nile earned $137M against its $90M budget.
Agree with a lot of what you said here. Brannagh the director delivers clunky yet competent storytelling with Death on the Nile but there's only so much you can do with a who dunnit mystery so ridiculous. I enjoyed some of the aged cinematic nuance he put into it but ultimately a little too silly of a narrative. The explanations and extrapolations of the crime become almost farcical. I would maybe go lower on the rating but not by too much either, 5/10 for me.
I will say the Hercule Poirot character is a fun throwback, and I'm glad he didn't abandon it as it led to the making of :
A Haunting in Venice(2023) - 7/10
I can't really remember Murder on the Orient Express, but I think I felt about it similar to Death on the Nile. Decent but flawed B movie with decent but flawed B movie qualities. Not really the biggest fan of Agatha Christie but I do like the concepts and the Poirot character Brannagh has a lot of fun with. He's overdone in places definitely but it's begging to played exactly like that. I likely would not have bothered with these but my gf is a fan of the character.
A Haunting in Venice was my favorite addition to the collection so far. For one the setting was much more rich for storytelling, and the storytelling was done much more cohesively. Brannagh takes bigger and better risks with the direction of this film and I believe for the most part they pay off. The mystery is more sinister and serious and the cinematography/editing reflect that well. Usually enjoy Tina Fey but she seemed a little out of place in this cast, the rest of which I thought were quality. Michelle Yeoh(Everything Everywhere All at Once) was very strong in her role as the psychic communicating with the dead.
Detective Poirot this time is talked out of seclusion by an non-fiction horror author friend of his to debunk a gypsy medium. In this case this fortuneteller was hired to commune with a young newlywed who had recently drowned in the canals of Venice after falling from her 3rd story bedroom balcony. There's a diverse cast of characters that all happen to have perhaps motives in the death of the girl. Poirot is forced to cipher through the layers of deception and subterfuge as things begin to go wrong on a dramatically dark & stormy night. The protagonist's crisis of faith trope is well traveled in cinema but there was something fresh about the way Brannagh depicted it in this.
Several twists and several murders later the film's themes of confusion and paranoia successfully elevate it beyond the usual standard B murder mystery fare. I wouldn't call myself the target audience exactly but I thought it was well done. Convoluted in the right way is definitely a challenge to undertake and where I thought the last two Kenneth Brannagh Hercule Poirot movies didn't nearly get there this one at least comes very close.
Last edited: